« Got questions? Leave 'em here | Main | Jay Leno set to pass the 'Tonight' torch to Conan May 29 »

Originally posted: May 14, 2009

Finale watch: 'Fringe' pulls off some tasty OMG moments

A few thoughts on the excellent season finale of "Fringe" are below. And if you're not of a mind to read my mind (via some wacky looking device that Walter made back in the day), read this interesting comparison of "Fringe" and "Dollhouse" by Nathan Alderman instead.

Sorry for the delay in posting, but I had to share a few thoughts about Tuesday's "Fringe" finale.

It was pretty swell, wasn't it?

Once again, John Noble as Walter Bishop was the best thing about the steadily improving Fox show, but there were a lot of other enjoyable elements: The quietly creepy atmosphere, the slowly building tension in the dual Walter/Olivia stories, the way those stories were skillfully woven together, the suitably tense lakeside encounter between Olivia, Peter and Mr. Jones.

Olivia's scenes with Nina Sharp were, well, sharply written, and I also enjoyed her scenes with her boss, Philip Broyles. The show still has a ways to go in fleshing out all these characters (well, except Walter), but it's certainly doing 100 times better than it was last fall in that arena. And that Walter-Observer scene? Delicious and somehow faintly sad at the same time.

120_morethanone_108 The show has also been doing a fine job with the Peter-Walter relationship -- the moment between them in the pastry shop last week was brilliant. Instead of barbed banter, we just saw a quiet moment of a son's compassion for his father, who was overcome with regret and sadness.

Like the bar scene a few months ago between Olivia and Peter, it was a key moment in the emotional development of these characters, and a sign that "Fringe" is maturing into a show worth sticking with.

Sure, there are still plot shortcuts aplenty and coincidences by the dozen on this show, but when the pacing, the atmosphere and the characters are creating an interesting world, I'll give most of a lot of that stuff a pass.

120_morethanone_157 Noble was so wonderful in his freakout scene at the beach house. And of course he still brings the comedy and the weirdness and the pathos and everything else. But the cool thing about "Fringe" is that now he's not the only reason to watch the show, which was more or less the case when the show began.

But back to Walter: John Noble must get an Emmy nomination this year. I demand it!

The best part of this interesting (and well-directed) finale were a few reveals that came near the end: Peter actually died back in the day. What?! Walter presumably grabbed a Peter 2.0 from some other reality, and nobody knows this but him (will we ever meet Peter's mom? Any version of her?)

William Bell, meanwhile, lives in another version of New York, one in which the Twin Towers still stand. I can't wait to see Leonard Nimoy and Noble mix it up next season.

120_morethanone_097 I do hope that the show fixes what the incomparable Nathan Alderman, who wrote a great essay on comparing and contrasting "Fringe" and "Dollhouse," calls "Fringe's" central problem: Olivia is "as dull as a post." True. She's a staid combination of earnest and dull. Please, "Fringe," let her be funny. Let her be weird, just a little bit. Let her wear a color for God's sake.

I take issue with a couple of thing's in Alderman's otherwise excellent essay: I think Anna Torv is competent but not particularly charismatic. And if he's gonna say that Noble would win a "crazy-off" with "Dollhouse's" Alan Tudyk, well, them's fightin' words. 

Clearly, it would be a TIE.

Here are a few questions I was left with at the end of the "Fringe" finale:

  • Is The Observer actually a version of Walter? There's more than one of everything, after all.
  • Is The Observer somehow related to Walter? Is he another version of Peter? There's more than one of everything, after all.
  • Is something Mr. Jones did the reason that Walter went insane and/or was committed? Or is Bell responsible for that?
  • How much did you want to see what Walter's whale-shaped pancakes looked like?

A few quotes from a recent phone press conference with "Fringe" co-creator J.J. Abrams:

  • "Obviously, it is not a brand new convention, the idea, especially science fiction, the idea of traveling through time and space.  But I would say that while Lost concerns itself more with traveling through time, I would say that 'Fringe' can serve itself more in traveling through space."
  • "I would argue that in a way Season 2 is getting to know the enemy. Season 1 is identifying that there is an enemy and really getting to know each other. But I think that as the show progresses what you’ll see in the second season is that it's building to a very specific type of confrontation and I think that you’ll see that there will be a really interesting shift in the sort of fundamental paradigm of the show at the beginning of next season, in a very cool way."
  • [On the show's frequent reliance on what even Abrams calls "massive chunks of exposition"]: "There is nothing more crazy than having that sort of massive chunk of exposition thrown at you at the beginning of the story. It is one of those things that I would love to avoid, and I think that sometimes the desire of either the producers, writers, network studio, wherever it comes from, to try and provide clarity, there is almost always the net result of confusing the hell out of people, like clarity looks like one thing on a script but is another thing ... And I feel like those kind of monologues of exposition don’t help anyone. I mean, although, by the way, I think Lance [Reddick] delivers them beautifully and he's a wonderful actor, but I think any actor tasked with catching an audience up deserves a drink at the end of the day."


My rating on the finale-o-meter: 8 out of 10.


in Fringe | Permalink


Comments

Great Comments, Mo! One thing I noticed...when Peter looked at the old photo of his family and dusted off the portion with him and Walter, you could see a blurred/dirty image of his mother. I snickered thinking, "There she is, but they can still cast whoever they want!"

I felt John Noble telegraphed the twist about Peter a bit when he was explaining to Peter about losing something precious and doing everything he could to replace it. Either he telegraphed it, or I think to much and ruin everything. I figured out The Sixth Sense halfway through too.

I can't wait for the fall!!!!!

Posted by: Jon Cunningham | May 14, 2009 3:05:07 PM


I was under the impression that Olivia subconsciously always wears grays and blacks because of her ties to the cortexiphan experiments. Nick Lane says something about it in "Bad Dreams," and I'm pretty sure either Susan Pratt or her twin in "The Road Not Taken" had a closet full of gray and black clothing.

Posted by: Lisa | May 14, 2009 3:14:41 PM


There's rumors that NINA SHARP is Peter's mother. O.O

Posted by: julie | May 14, 2009 4:22:33 PM


Olivia should stay the way she is. Her stoic manner and seriousness are what makes her character unique and interesting. There's a lot going on inside of her that we have yet to find out.

Posted by: surge | May 14, 2009 6:37:38 PM


Well, in terms of the observer, we got a very simple answer when that child was found under the demolition site. No hair, pale as a ghost, and they so coincidentally run into each other at the end of the episode. The observer is something quite out there, but I don't think he's some version of Walter or Peter. Perhaps an experiment of Walter's?

Posted by: Rod | May 14, 2009 8:05:42 PM


When Walter was in the cemetery, I thought it was going to be his wife's grave & he was going to try to get doppelganger her back from Earth-other.
But when Olivia was at the window at the end of the show, as soon as she turned around I knew exactly what was coming, the WTC buildings.

And Mo, don't forget, it wasn't her acting resume, but 95% of the reason Anna Torv got the job is that she's Rupert Murdoch's niece!

Posted by: Garry | May 14, 2009 10:59:58 PM


Fringe succeeds despite the lackluster acting of both Anna Torv and Joshua Jackson. Without John Noble and Blair Brown, Fringe would be almost unwatchable.

However, I am glad I stuck with Fringe (I almost stopped watching after the pilot because of Anna Torv). The creators and writers have creating a compelling story, and I find myself looking forward to new episodes.

BTW, I assumed the Observer and the feral kid were the same person, separated by time. It makes sense - the kid seemed to like Olivia, Walter, Peter, etc. Perhaps he went back through time to use his emphatic link to help the Fringe Division.

Posted by: Frank | May 15, 2009 8:11:57 AM


Maybe it is just me, but I really like Anna Torv. And they DID explain her clothing choices in other episodes, and I think her quiet nature and sullen disposition comes from the fact that she was tested on as a child and as such, she lacks the fun-loving nature of her sister.

Posted by: Lucas | May 15, 2009 1:21:54 PM


Did I miss an episode or was it new information that Blair Brown's character was part machine?

Mo here: I think they'd shown her mecha-arm before, but not that much.

Posted by: Zach | May 15, 2009 6:02:49 PM


Can someone remind me about the first encounter we see between Walter and The Observer? Did The Observer save Walter and young Peter (1.0 or 2.0?) from dying, in exchange for a future favor Walter would have to repay? Was it death by drownding in a car at a lake? Did I make that up?

Posted by: Jane | May 15, 2009 10:02:31 PM


Got no complaints about Anna Torv. I LIKE how different Olivia is from what you typically see on TV ... It's a welcome change of pace.

And, upon reflection, her clothes and mannerisms are very in line with what Nick said ... blacks and grays ... staying in shape .... ZFT Youth, indeed.


But, yes ... thumbs up for Torv. She doesn't get enough positive plugs so I'm putting one out there.

Posted by: Wilder | May 15, 2009 11:11:44 PM


Post a comment

Comments are not posted immediately. We review them first in an effort to remove foul language, commercial messages, irrelevancies and unfair attacks. Thank you for your patience.








All TV, all the time.

>> More about Maureen Ryan


What's on TV tonight




Last 10 posts
•  A good day for unconventional television: 'Dollhouse' renewed
•  Here for the 'Party' and full of 'Glee': A talk with Jane Lynch
•  Finale watch: Open thread
•  Finale watch: 'The Office' goes out in fine style
•  Finale watch: It's going to be a long summer for 'Supernatural' fans
•  Jay Leno set to pass the 'Tonight' torch to Conan May 29
•  Finale watch: 'Fringe' pulls off some tasty OMG moments
•  Got questions? Leave 'em here
•  'Lost's' season finale: Touched by a Jacob
•  The 'Idol' final two: Adam Lambert and that other guy



Categories
• 24
• 30 Rock
• Aliens in America
• American Idol
• An interview with...
• Arrested Development
• Awardsfest Mania!
• Battlestar Galactica
• Best and worst of 2005 TV
• Best and worst of 2006 TV
• Best and worst of 2007 TV
• Best and worst of 2008 TV
• Big Bang Theory
• Big Love
• Brothers and Sisters
• Burn Notice
• Caprica
• Celebrity Rehab
• Chuck
• Comic-Con
• Commentary
• CSI
• Damages
• Deadwood
• Desperate Housewives
• Dexter
• Dirty Sexy Money
• Doctor Who
• Documentaries
• Dollhouse
• Dr. Horrible's Sing-Along Blog
• Election coverage
• Emmys
• Entourage
• Epitafios
• Everwood
• Everybody Hates Chris
• Farscape
• Flight of the Conchords
• Footballers Wives
• Friday Night Lights
• Fringe
• General television
• Generation Kill
• Gilmore Girls
• Gossip Girl
• Grey's Anatomy
• Heroes
• House
• How I Met Your Mother
• In Treatment
• It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia
• Jericho
• Just for grins
• Kathy Griffin
• Kids TV
• Late night TV
• Late Night with Conan O'Brien
• Law & Order (all versions)
• Lost
• Love Monkey
• Mad Men
• Men in Trees
• Moonlighting
• Music
• Music on TV
• My Name Is Earl
• NCIS
• New shows for the 2006-2007 season
• New shows for the 2007-2008 season
• New shows for the 2008-09 season
• Nip/Tuck
• Nobody's Watching
• Non-TV entries
• Olympics
• Oprah
• Oscars 2007
• Oscars 2008
• Party Down
• Prison Break
• Project Runway
• Psych
• Reader feedback
• Reality TV
• Reaper
• Rescue Me
• Returning shows for the 2008-2009 season
• Ricky Gervais
• Rock Star
• Rome
• Saturday Night Live
• Saving Grace
• Scrubs
• Slings and Arrows
• South Park
• Sports on TV
• Star Trek
• Star Wars
• Stargate SG-1/Atlantis
• Studio 60 on the Sunset Strip
• Summer TV preview
• Supernatural
• Survivor
• Swingtown
• TCA Summer Press Tour
• Television review
• Tell Me You Love Me
• The Amazing Race
• The Apprentice
• The Closer
• The Daily Show/Colbert Report
• The O.C.
• The Office (US & UK)
• The Shield
• The Sopranos
• The Unit
• The Wire
• Threshold
• Top Chef
• Torchwood
• True Blood
• TV grab bag
• TV news
• TV tech/cable/satellite
• TV Viewers Bill of Rights
• Ugly Betty
• Veronica Mars
• Virtuality
• Watcher Web chat
• Weeds
• WGA strike
• What to watch this weekend
• Wonder Showzen


New TV shortcuts:
TV Page
Zap2it listings






May 2009 posts
Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
1 2
3 4 5 6 7 8 9
10 11 12 13 14 15 16
17 18 19 20 21 22 23
24 25 26 27 28 29 30
31

Search The Watcher
Powered by Google


Archives

Mo Ryan's Twitter Updates

follow The Watcher on Twitter




Powered by TypePad





New TV shortcuts:
TV Page
Zap2it listings