Alfalfa seeding rates: how much is too much?
Anyone who follows baseball has probably heard of Bob Uecker. He’s the former major league catcher and current Hall of Fame broadcaster of the Milwaukee Brewers who has carved-out a pretty nice living making light of his dismal .200 career batting average and other performance deficiencies. Failing to get the desired result 80 percent of the time generally is not considered acceptable, unless we’re talking about Uecker and establishing alfalfa.
I’m guessing that virtually everyone who has applied their trade as an alfalfa researcher has done a seeding rate study at some point in their career. The scientific literature is full of such studies and most come to the same conclusion: very little of what we dump in the drill ends up as a productive alfalfa plant that lives to see the next presidential election. It’s not anyone’s fault, but rather that inefficiency is a part of the deal. However, there should be some consideration given to cutting losses simply because input costs, including seed, are not getting any cheaper.
To take a closer look at the issue of alfalfa seeding rates, let’s start at the beginning with the seed itself. One of my references indicates that there are 199,000 alfalfa seeds per pound. If that one pound was evenly spread over one acre (43,560 ft.2), there would be in the neighborhood of five seeds per square foot. So pick your seeding rate, multiply by five, and that’s how many seeds per square foot are sitting a fraction of an inch below the soil surface waiting to become productive plants when you pull out of the field with your seeder or drill.
What happens next?...
So let’s begin with a 15 pound per acre seeding rate (Figure 1). That equates to 75 seeds per square foot. Research suggests that only about 50 to 70 percent of those seeds will be accounted for as seedlings after emergence is complete in three to four weeks. Using a 60 percent average, that leaves us with 45 seedlings per square foot. At this point, it’s a survival of the fittest game. As plants become bigger and compete for available resources, another 40 to 50 percent will be gone by the next spring. This leaves us with about 25 plants per square foot as our stand heads into the first production year. During the next 12 months, research suggests to expect another 30 to 40 percent loss of plants, leaving us with 8 or 9 productive plants per square foot, a batting average of .120 from our original 75 seeds.
As depressing as all of this may sound (after all, we paid for 75 seeds per square foot), our example stand counts for the spring following seeding and a year later are on the high end of what research suggests are fully productive stands. Generally speaking, we like to see 15 to 25 plants per square foot at the beginning of the first production year and at least 3 healthy plants per square foot in older stands. As stands age, evaluation based solely on plant counts becomes problematic because variables such as stem number, stem size, plant health, weed encroachment, and crop rotation restrictions must be considered.
The seeding rate effect.....
It seems intuitive that more seeds dropped per square foot should result in more seedlings and plants per square foot. Seeding studies suggest that higher seeding rates do result in more seedlings through the end of the seeding year. Further, very low seeding rates (below 8 pounds per acre) often have fewer seedlings and lower total-season yields in the seeding year. However, as seeding rates increase, the percentage of plants that die during the first year also increases. Research from Missouri and Pennsylvania recently showed a 45 percent first-year plant mortality for a 10 pound per acre seeding rate and a 60 to 70 percent mortality for seeding rates over 20 pounds per acre. It’s been an almost universal research finding throughout the Midwest and Eastern U.S. that plant densities and yield are nearly equal for seeding rates of 10 pounds per acre or more in the year following seeding.
How can doubling the seeding rate, say from 10 to 20 pounds per acre, possibly result in the same forage yield and near the same plant density in the years after seeding? It’s all explained by the alfalfa plant’s ability to compensate based on neighboring plant competition. Forage yield is not just a function of the number of plants per unit area, but also the number of stems per plant and weight per stem. As stands thin, plants initiate more stems and in some cases larger stems as a response to less plant to plant competition.
Determining the optimum seeding rate...
Recommended seeding rates vary with region and can be obtained at your local extension office. As evidenced in Table 1, the research suggests strongly that there is little benefit to seeding over 10 pounds of pure live seed per acre in the Midwest and Eastern U.S. regions. If you’d like, throw in an insurance factor and make it 12 pounds (60 seeds per square foot). As alfalfa seed becomes more expensive and transgenic traits like glyphosate resistance come with a technology fee, reducing seeding rates to the agronomic and economic optimum is more easily justified. Further, it’s always better to invest in good alfalfa genetics and seed at an optimum rate than to buy the cheap stuff and seed at a higher rate.
Obtaining the desired seeding rate starts with seeder calibration. Factors such as seed size, seed coating, and the percentage of pure live seed (indicated on seed tag) will impact how the seeding implement needs to be set for the desired result. Further, there may be times where it makes good sense to increase seeding rates. These include situations where the seedbed is less than optimum and where the desired seeding depth is difficult to obtain (either too deep or too shallow). Also remember that Roundup ReadyŽ varieties will have about five percent of seed as glyphosate susceptible.
Finally, because seeding equipment and planting conditions vary significantly, it might be well worth your time to track plant densities on your own farm. Count plants per square foot about a month after seeding, then in the fall of the seeding year, and again the next spring. At this point, we like to see about 15 - 25 plants per square foot to achieve maximum yields. Don’t worry if your numbers are a bit lower, plants will likely compensate with more stems per plant and excellent yields are still attainable.
Seed costs, spread over the life of a stand, currently comprise a small percentage of the total alfalfa production investment. Still, it’s generally hard to justify over-seeding alfalfa that costs $4 to $5 per pound. Rather, take the savings and take-in a ballgame this summer.
For more information contact Mike Rankin