Butterbeer, as Heston Blumenthal points out in his Tudor Feast, is not just Harry Potter’s favourite tipple, it’s also a bona fide Tudor recipe made from ale, sugar, egg yolks, nutmeg and butter. If you’ve always thought that beer is good but could benefit from a few more calories, then this is the drink for you.
Last weekend I spent an eye watering £80 at the dentist on damage control for my sweet tooth. Just two days later I’m whisking sugar into a steaming pot of ale and hoping my fillings don’t melt.
I heated some beer in a pan over a medium heat till it bubbled. Then I took it off the heat, added the egg, sugar and nutmeg mixture, put it back on a low heat and stirred for a couple of minutes until it went the colour of strong tea meets cloudy apple juice. By this point the kitchen smelled of mulled wine which was a more pleasant odour than you’d expect from a pot of warm eggy beer. I whisked in a little butter and the brew was complete.
Rich, caramelly and super-sweet. There’s a reason Heston serves it in tiny glasses. The dentists round Hogwarts must be raking it in.
Recipe for butterbeer
Ingredients
500ml ale
Yolks from 2 medium eggs, whisked
60g sugar
Dash of nutmeg
15g unsalted butter
Method: How to make butterbeer
Pour the ale into a warm pan on a medium heat. When the beer begins to come to the boil take off the heat and add the whisked egg yolks, sugar and nutmeg.
Return the pot to a low heat (to stop the eggs from scrambling) and stir for 2 minutes. Take off the heat and whisk in the butter. Decant into your finest flagon and chug.
Comments
Wow! cant wait 2 make and try some!
nice
Sounds fabulous can’t wait to try it. will tell you what I think. thanks for a brilliant program.
Should it be drank warm?
Rory, the 4Food team drank it warm and it slipped down a treat.
I just made it and its declious, although i forgot to turn on the heat so the eggs in it scrambled
what ale did you use? im not sure which one to make it with?!?!?
does anyone know after this is made, can you bottle it for later ?? or does it have to be drank warm right after its made??
Hi Tejas - I used London Pride ale - you could try other ales too.
Thanks, i used IPA it tasted great!
My fellow ale drinking friend and I have just made our very first quart of butterbeer, following the exact instructions above.
My my, I should say that upon first sample of our freshly brewed beverage, we were both pleasently surprised, until we noticed the large quantity of egg ‘bits’ floating round. (We took extreme care to fully whisk the mix)
After a moment or two, we both decided we did not like the taste, due to the intense sweetness and heaviness we felt in our guts.
We used Bishops Finger ale, and we suggest that people reduce the amount of suger when making their own butterbeer.
I would love to add butterscotch to it aswell - probably will melt the teeth straight through my face - but it’d be tasty - definitely trying this in the next few days
i tried it with OSH and didn-t like it much
but i think i went over the top on nutmeg.
oh well
You made my whole day. I can’t wait to make some Butterbeer. Living in southern Wyoming, USA I have a bunch of excellent local micro brewed English Ale’s to use.
eeeeeeeeh how exciting! i am making this at the first opportunity i get
Jus tried this, not bad!
uhhh just downed my 4th pint not feeling too good used Carlton draft (Aussie brew) like eating 10 Mars Bars
Leave a comment
* Required field.