Most Helpful Customer Reviews
|
|
71 of 76 people found the following review helpful:
2.0 out of 5 stars
Watchmen bonus features., March 24, 2009
Is "Tales of the black Freighter" a very cool animated short film and a fantastic companion to the Watchmen film? Yes. Should it have been sold as a separate full-priced DVD altogether? No way. What this is is essentially a disc of bonus features marked up to the price of a feature film. This is no bueno. I was looking forward to a fleshed-out version of the story with tons of great material, but unfortunately there is very little on this release that you haven't seen if you've read the graphic novel.
The feature tale is 25 minutes long, looks cool, and has all the brutality of the comic and maybe even more. But God, do I hate me some roaring sharks. Filmmakers, take heed: SHARKS DO NOT ROAR! That aside, the film is good and would have made an amazing bonus feature on the double-disc DVD release of "Watchmen", but packaged by itself, it just isn't enough. Even when thrown together with a 37 minute live-action interview featuring cast members from the film discussing the original Nite Owl's tell-all autobiography "Under The Hood" it's not enough. The contents of "Under The Hood" is mostly just a reiteration of things from the graphic novel and even some redundancy from the film. Again, an outstanding bonus feature, but not worth a lot by itself. It's nice to get more Carla Gugino without that awful aging makeup, though. Also featured is a half-hour documentary about the projects, and a 10 minute preview of the promising "Green Lantern" animated feature. All good, but one more time: it all amounts to nothing more than a disc of bonus features that should have been saved for the "Watchmen" DVD release.
If you are a complete rabid maniac over anything "Watchmen"-related then by all means, pick this up. But know what you are getting. This is not a feature-length release that will substantially enrich your appreciation of the film. It's more of a cash-in to scrape some capital from the hardcore fans while they await the real DVD. I would recommend a rent for this if you're really itching to see it like I was because I for one would have been seriously bent if I'd spent $15 on it. It's definitely worth seeing because it is a very well done animated version of the comic within the comic, but as a full-priced standalone release it reeks like a boat built out of corpses. If I were you, I'd wait until it's packaged with the film before buying.
2 1/2 stars, rounded down for taking advantage of the film's supporters.
|
|
|
19 of 20 people found the following review helpful:
3.0 out of 5 stars
Borne on the Naked Backs of Murdered Men, March 21, 2009
Tales of the Black Freighter was a story within a story in the Watchmen graphic novel. A young black man visits a newspaper stand everyday and reads comic books without paying for them. A pirate story bled through the pages and introduced the reader to a man who had lost his entire crew thanks to the attack of the Black Freighter. He decides to head home in hopes of warning the people before the Black Freighter makes it to his town. After making his way back to shore, he uses the corpses of his crew to make a raft and sets out to sea. He winds up going mad in the process as the Freighter impairs his judgement of what's truly fantasy and what is actually reality.
The storyline was almost identical with the source material in this animated feature. The only issue I had was the character design. Everything else looked fantastic and was animated beautifully. The sky was incredibly vibrant the entire time and the sea looked almost lifelike at times. The characters were animated rather poorly, in my opinion though. It may just be the design, but their quality looked poor and their animation wasn't up to par in comparison to everything else around them. Reminded me a bit of the character designs in Aeon Flux. All in all, it's well worth seeing. But it's rather short as it only clocks in at around twenty one minutes without the credits.
Under the Hood is the autobiography of Hollis Mason, the original Nite Owl. It's basically his version of the events that transpired during the time he was a superhero and was a part of the Minutemen. There's a feature devoted solely to this autobiography on the Black Freighter DVD.
The feature is basically a live-action documentary of Hollis Mason/Nite Owl being interviewed about Under the Hood and everything he included in his book. It also focuses heavily on the Minutemen, the original team of superheroes from the thirties. Sally Jupiter/Silk Spectre and Edward Jacobi/Moloch are also in it quite a bit. There's even a brief cameo from The Comedian. It's really just a companion piece to the film that sheds a bit more light on characters that were only briefly touched on in the actual Watchmen film. A must see for anyone who was a fan of the film.
Rating: 7/10
|
|
|
17 of 22 people found the following review helpful:
4.0 out of 5 stars
A great Follow Up to the Graphic Novel and Movie, March 14, 2009
Following on the smash success of "Watchmen" Warner Brothers Premiere has released "Tales of the Black Freighter" on DVD and Blue Ray. The features laden set is truly impressive an tells the story within a story of The Black Freighter in an animated format. Fans of the graphic novel Watchmen will remember that the newsstand owner had a patron who would read a pirate adventure and that the savage tale also served as a counter point to the events happening in the Watchmen universe.
The animated feature is voiced by Gerard Butler and tells the story of a captain who is the lone survivor of an assault by a mysterious freighter. Convinced that the freighter is headed to his home, the captain faces a series of ghastly challenges to stay alive and return home. As the obstacles mount, the captain slowly starts to lose his grip on reality which leads to a startling finale.
The top flight animation serves the episode well as does Butler's solid voice work. The episode is briskly paced and runs in at roughly 3o minutes.
Another feature of the set is the Under the Hood segment which tells the story of the original Night Owl Hollis Mason and provides a background on the world of the Watchmen. Done in the format of a television interview show, the great segment features characters from the film as they tell the story of the original Night Owl and the formation of The Minutemen and Watchmen as well as the villains they faced and the pending Keane Act.
This was a fantastic and unexpected feature of the disc and when combined with the look at the upcoming Green lantern DVD made this collection an absolute gem.
|
Share your thoughts with other customers: Create your own review
|
|
Most Recent Customer Reviews
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
Awesome Order!
Everything was exactly as I hoped it would be! So pleased with this purchase!
Published 4 months ago by James Blevins
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
WATCHMEN FAN MUST HAVE!!!!
As a newly introduced fan to the Watchmen Comic novel, I have to say I thoroughly enjoyed the Captain's tale against the Black Freighter but I appreciated the story even more so...
Published 6 months ago by Explorer
|
|
3.0 out of 5 stars
Good Watchmen bonus
This is an original animated feature which takes all the material from the actual Watchmen comic, and comprises it into a single short-movie.
Published 6 months ago by J. Alford
|
|
3.0 out of 5 stars
From novel to comic to screen
Being a fan of Alan Moore and Watchmen, buying the movie blue-ray, "Tales of the Black Freighter" cannot miss in my videoteque.
Published 6 months ago by Luigi Ermini
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
An interesting supplement to the Watchmen movie
I've only just recently gotten a chance to see the theatrical version of "Watchmen", and while as a fan of the graphic novel, I was a little dismayed to see that the "Tales of the...
Published 6 months ago by Renee C. Mulhare
|
|
1.0 out of 5 stars
Digital Copy is Windows Only
The production on these is great.
My one complaint is that the Digital Copy for this Blu Ray is Windows format only.
Published 7 months ago by L. Lentz
|
|
2.0 out of 5 stars
Disapointment on My Mind
I have been anticipating what I call the real version of the movie: with the comic and the book intermixed in the theatrical release.
Published 7 months ago by Leslie Bowers
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
One of the better Watchman stories
Although I am not a big Watchman fan, this story was great. It made me want to see the main movie on DVD.
Published 7 months ago by Kathleen M. Mcgury
|
|
5.0 out of 5 stars
The Promise of Storytelling Beyond Linear Narrative
A nice companion to the film itself that deepens and expands upon the underlying themes of the story by adding further layers of richness and texture to what can only be described...
Published 8 months ago by Katphish
|
|
4.0 out of 5 stars
Great Blu-ray
I bought this for Black Freighter and the best part of this is the Under the Hood fake documentary. If you are a watchmen fan go get this, if you are a anime fan you will love...
Published 8 months ago by Syed S. Rahman
|
|
DVD ~ Tom Stechschulte
DVD ~ Jackie Earle Haley
DVD ~ Jackie Earle Haley
DVD ~ Marc Worden
on IMDb.com 
