NYDailyNews.com
59°F / New York

Weather in NYC

59°F Forecast Traffic

Thursday, March 25, 2010
NewsPoliticsStates sue to block healthcare bill, say it usurps their sovereignty

States sue to block healthcare bill, say it usurps their sovereignty

Monday, March 22nd 2010, 4:01 PM

Surrounded by Democratic House members, Speaker of the House Rep. Nancy Pelosi signs the Senate Health Reform bill.
Wong/Getty
Surrounded by Democratic House members, Speaker of the House Rep. Nancy Pelosi signs the Senate Health Reform bill.

CHICAGO – Less than 24 hours after the House of Representatives gave final approval to a sweeping overhaul of healthcare, attorneys general from several states on Monday said they will sue to block the plan on constitutional grounds.

Republican attorneys general in 11 states warned that lawsuits will be filed to stop the federal government overstepping its constitutional powers and usurping states' sovereignty.

States are concerned the burden of providing healthcare will fall on them without enough federal support.

Ten of the attorneys general plan to band together in a collective lawsuit on behalf of Alabama, Florida, Nebraska, North Dakota, Pennsylvania, South Carolina, South Dakota, Texas, Utah and Washington.

"To protect all Texans' constitutional rights, preserve the constitutional framework intended by our nation's founders, and defend our state from further infringement by the federal government, the State of Texas and other states will legally challenge the federal health care legislation," said Texas Attorney General Greg Abbott, in a statement.

The Republican attorney generals say the reforms infringe on state powers under the Constitution's Bill of Rights.

Virginia Attorney General Kenneth Cuccinelli, who plans to file a lawsuit in federal court in Richmond, Virginia, said Congress lacks authority under its constitutional power to regulate interstate commerce to force people to buy insurance. The bill also conflicts with a state law that says Virginians cannot be required to buy insurance, he added.

"If a person decides not to buy health insurance, that person by definition is not engaging in commerce," Cuccinelli said in recorded comments. "If you are not engaging in commerce, how can the federal government regulate you?"

In addition to the pending lawsuits, bills and resolutions have been introduced in at least 36 state legislatures seeking to limit or oppose various aspects of the reform plan through laws or state constitutional amendments, according to the National Conference of State Legislatures.

So far, only two states, Idaho and Virginia, have enacted laws, while an Arizona constitutional amendment is seeking voter approval on the November ballot. But the actual enactment of the bill by President Barack Obama could spur more movement on the measures by state lawmakers.

As is the case on the Congressional level, partisan politics is in play on the state level, where no anti-health care reform legislation has emerged in Democrat-dominated states like Illinois and New York, according to the NCSL.

Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum, a Republican candidate running for governor, said the mandate would cost Florida at least $1.6 billion in Medicaid alone.

All states would receive extra funding to cover Medicaid costs that are expected to rise under the reform, including 100 percent federal coverage for new enrollees under the plan through 2016.

Medicaid is the healthcare program for the poor jointly administered by the states and federal government.

  • Email
  • Print
  • DIGG
  • Delicious

Related Topics

Ads by Yahoo!

EDITORS' PICKS

GOP: Hurt the health bill, not Dems who voted for it

GOP: Hurt the health bill, not Dems who voted for it

Republicans plead with health care bill's opponents to refrain from violence.

Not wiley enough...coyote nabbed in downtown NYC

Not wiley enough...coyote nabbed in downtown NYC

Four-legged varmint is caught by NYPD in a lower Manhattan parking lot.

Gossip Apocalypse! Bullock gave Elin Woods advice

Gossip Apocalypse! Bullock gave Elin Woods advice

Actress gave the golfer's wife unsolicited advice when her marriage was imploding.

Third woman claims affair with Jesse James

Third woman claims affair with Jesse James

Mess may be spiraling into a scandal of Tiger Woods proportions.

PHOTOS: The gals of the Jesse James scandal

PHOTOS: The gals of the Jesse James scandal

Get a closer look at the fetish model who may have destroyed Sandra's marriage.

Fat chance: New scale Tweets your weight & BMI

Fat chance: New scale Tweets your weight & BMI

Talk about a great deterrent! Using Wi-Fi, scale shares your private info with the world.

BEST OF NYDN.COM

Cyberbullying leads to teen's suicide - taunts continue after death

Cyberbullying leads to teen's suicide - taunts continue after death

Cops are probing the death of 17-year-old New York girl.

Rock star admits to sex with teen boys

Rock star admits to sex with teen boys

Co-founder of KC and the Sunshine Band cops to sex with teenage boys, police say.

PHOTOS: Making art with X-rays -- Rock!

PHOTOS: Making art with X-rays -- Rock!

X-rays give glimpse into the art behind the everyday.

Bin Laden to U.S.: Kill 9/11 mastermind, and I'll kill more Americans

Bin Laden to U.S.: Kill 9/11 mastermind, and I'll kill more Americans

Bin Laden weighs in on fate of Khalid Sheikh Mohammed.

Did PETA go too far with 'Hitler Dog' ad ?

Did PETA go too far with 'Hitler Dog' ad ?

Ad shows a Maltese with a black comb under its nose. What do you think of the spot?

PHOTOS: Even Robert Pattinson gets caught looking bad!

PHOTOS: Even Robert Pattinson gets caught looking bad!

Check out the pics H'wood's hotties never wanted you to see.

MOST POPULAR