Full-body scanners are waste of money, Israeli expert says

 

 
 
 
 
A security officer examines a computer screen showing a scan from a full-body scanner.
 

A security officer examines a computer screen showing a scan from a full-body scanner.

Photograph by: Reuters, Canwest News Service

A leading Israeli airport security expert says the Canadian government has wasted millions of dollars to install "useless" imaging machines at airports across the country.

"I don't know why everybody is running to buy these expensive and useless machines. I can overcome the body scanners with enough explosives to bring down a Boeing 747," Rafi Sela told parliamentarians probing the state of aviation safety in Canada.

"That's why we haven't put them in our airport," Sela said, referring to Tel Aviv's Ben Gurion International Airport, which has some of the toughest security in the world.

Sela, former chief security officer of the Israel Airport Authority and a 30-year veteran in airport security and defence technology, helped design the security at Ben Gurion.

He told MPs on the House of Commons transport committee via video conference from Kfar Vradim, Israel, that he wouldn't reveal how to get past the virtual strip-search scanners, but said he can provide briefings to officials with security clearance.

Canada this year bought 44 body scanners for major Canadian airports -- three of them for Vancouver International. Each machine cost $250,000 and is being use for secondary screening to detect non-metallic threats, unless the passenger prefers a physical pat-down.

CATSA, the Canadian agency in charge of screening airline passengers, declined to provide comment on Sela's analysis.

Junior Transport Minister Rob Merrifield, who is responsible for the agency, defended the $11-million investment in the machines.

"Full-body scanners are used by dozens of countries around the world and are considered one of the most effective methods of screening," Merrifield said in a statement.

Sela testified it makes more sense to create a "trusted traveller" system so pre-approved low-risk passengers can move through an expedited screening process. That would leave more resources in the screening areas, where automatic sniffing technology would detect any explosive residue on a person or their baggage.

Behavioural profiling also must be used instead of random checks, he said.

"Having a random search at the airport is like Russian roulette," said SelaPolitical scientist Mark Salter, an aviation security expert at the University of Ottawa, testified alongside Sela. He told MPs he disagreed with Sela's take on full-body scanners, calling the machines a "genuine leap forward" because they not only detect current threats, such as liquid explosives, but also the next generation of non-metallic threats.

"It is a much better mousetrap," Salter said.

 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Story Tools

 
 
Font:
 
Image:
 
 
 
 
 
A security officer examines a computer screen showing a scan from a full-body scanner.
 

A security officer examines a computer screen showing a scan from a full-body scanner.

Photograph by: Reuters, Canwest News Service

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Travel Photo of the Day: Market vendors in Zimbabwe

Travel Photo of the Day

Great travel photos from around the world

 
Shanghai World's Fair

Photo Gallery: Shanghai gears ...

Shanghai's World Fair begins in May and it promises...

 
Netherlands river cruise

Photo Gallery: River cruising ...

River cruising in the Netherlands and Belgium is a...

 
Passengers stand next to a Eurostar information sign at Gare du Nord station in Paris April 16, 2010. A huge ash cloud from an Icelandic volcano spread out across Europe on Friday causing air travel chaos on a scale not seen since the September 11 attacks. About 17,000 flights were expected to be cancelled on Friday because of the dangers posed by volcanic ash from Iceland, aviation officials said. Airports in Britain, France, Germany, and across Europe were closed until at least Saturday.

Photo Gallery: Volcano vs. Air...

Flights throughout Britain and much of northern Europe...

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Destination Guides
 
 
 

Featured Travel Guide Destinations

 

 
 
Opera House, Sydney, Australia
 
The Land Down Under is about as far awa as it gets for travellers from Canada.