TV Ratings: Sad Happy Town Premiere; But ABC’s Smiling Over Modern Family

Posted on 29 April 2010 by Robert Seidman

Scoreboard FOX ABC NBC CBS Uni CW
Rating/Share: Adults 18-49 4.1/12 2.4/7 1.9/6 1.8/5 1.6/5 0.9/3
Rating/Share: Adults 18-34 3.1/10 2.0/6 1.5/5 1.1/4 1.7/5 1.0/3
Total Viewers (million) 12.34 6.53 6.52 7.45 3.86 2.12

Of Course FOX won the night with an hour of  American Idol. It’s 6.5 adults 18-49 rating was up 10% versus last week.

The premiere of Happy Town on ABC were  bad, but probably only as bad as any reasonable person would’ve imagined, including the executives at ABC.  You know, the same people who cut the order to 8 episodes and kept it off the schedule for almost the entire season. Not even ABC could’ve been surprised it would be its lowest-rated premiere of the season.

Why put it on at all?   Perhaps they figured “C’mon, it can’t do much worse than Ugly Betty or Eastwick!”    At least for one week, they were correct (though Eastwick premiered with a 3.0 before sinking)  The 1.7 adults 18-49 rating was better than the 1.4 Ugly Betty pulled with its last new episode.  But, that was the premiere and the typical trend with any premiere is the ratings for the second episode go down.  The half hourly trend was also not its friend either, dropping from a 1.9 adults 18-49 rating in the first half hour to a 1.6 the second half hour.   

Earlier in the night on ABC Modern Family scored a 4.1 adults 18-49 rating, which is sure to cheer ABC up at least a little.  It was up 11% from its last new episode. Cougar Town pulled a 2.8 with adults 18-49, up 12% from its last new episode.

The last night before May Sweeps officially begin tonight saw CBS entirely in repeats, but with a twist, a repeat of Two and a Half Men at 8:30p up against a new episode of  The Middle on ABC.   The new episode of  The Middle won easily with a 2.4  adults 18-49 rating vs. a 1.8 for the repeat of Two and a Half Men.  It is interesting to note that while Two and a Half Men repeats very well in its normal Monday timeslot,  it won’t score those ratings with a repeat if they just stick it anywhere.

Against a repeat on CBS and Happy Town,  a new Law & Order: SVU had a 2.9 rating with adults 18-49, up from last week’s 2.7 when it ran against repeats on both ABC and CBS.

Over on the CW, America’s Next Top Model had its most-watched episode in more than a month (since St. Patrick’s Day) with nearly 3.3 million viewers.  While TV gossip blogs are talking about a second season of High Society set in the Hamptons,  the CW has not picked the show up for a second season…at least not yet.

Based on last night’s ratings it seems much more likely that Tinsley Mortimer and cast are behind that rumor than the CW.

Nielsen overnight ratings for Wednesday, April 28, 2010:

Late night data info is below the primetime data.

Time Net Show 18-49 Rating/Sh Viewers (Millions)
8:00 FOX Lie To Me (R) 1.7/5 5.28
ABC The Middle  (R) 1.5/5 5.32
NBC Minute to Win It (R) 1.5/5 5.23
CBS New Adventures of Old Christine (R) 1.4/5 5.28
CW America’s Next Top Model 1.4/5 3.27
8:30 ABC The Middle 2.4/7 7.11
CBS Two and a Half Men (R) 1.8/5 6.34
9:00 FOX American Idol 6.5/17 19.39
ABC Modern Family 4.1/11 9.82
CBS Criminal Minds (R) 2.1/6 8.81
NBC Mercy 1.4/4 4.96
CW Fly Girls 0.4/1 1.03
9:30 ABC Cougar Town 2.8/7 6.45
CW High Society 0.4/1 0.91
10:00 NBC Law & Order: Special Victims Unit 2.9/8 9.37
ABC Happy Town (Premiere) 1.7/5 5.23
CBS CSI: NY (R) 1.6/5 7.729


Nielsen TV Ratings: ©2010 The Nielsen Company. All Rights Reserved.

via NBC ratings notes:

In Late-Night Metered Markets Wednesday night:

  • “The Tonight Show with Jay Leno” (3.5/9 in metered-market households) out-delivered CBS’s “Late Show with David Letterman” (2.6/7) and ABC’s combination of “Nightline (2.9/7) and “Jimmy Kimmel Live” (1.4/5) in Nielsen’s 56 metered markets.
  • In the 25 markets with Local People Meters, “The Tonight Show with Jay Leno” (1.4/6) ranked #1 among the major networks in the time period over “Late Show” (0.8/4), “Nightline” (1.0/4) and “Jimmy Kimmel Live” (0.5/3).
  • At 12:35 a.m., “Late Night with Jimmy Fallon” (1.5/5 in metered-market households) topped CBS’s “Late Late Show with Craig Ferguson” (1.3/5 with an encore telecast).  In the 25 markets with Local People Meters, “Late Night” (0.7/5 in 18-49) topped “Late Late Show” (0.5/3 with an encore telecast).
  • At 1:35 a.m., “Last Call with Carson Daly” averaged a 0.9/4 in metered-market households and a 0.5/4 in adults 18-49 in the 25 markets with local people meters.

You can see TV ratings from other recent Overnight ratings reports here.

Definitions:

Fast Affiliate Ratings: These first national ratings, including demographics, are available at approximately 11 AM (ET) the day after telecast, and are released to subscribing customers daily. These data, from the National People Meter sample, are strictly time-period information, based on the normal broadcast network feed, and include all programming on the affiliated stations, sometimes including network programming, sometimes not. The figures may include stations that did not air the entire network feed, as well as local news breaks or cutaways for local coverage or other programming. Fast Affiliate ratings are not as useful for live programs and are likely to differ significantly from the final results, because the data reflect normal broadcast feed patterns. For example, with a World Series game, Fast Affiliate Ratings would include whatever aired from 8-11PM on affiliates in the Pacific Time Zone, following the live football game, but not game coverage that begins at 5PM PT. The same would be true of Presidential debates as well as live award shows and breaking news reports.

Rating: Estimated percentage of the universe of TV households (or other specified group) tuned to a program in the average minute. Ratings are expressed as a percent.

Share (of Audience): The percent of households (or persons) using television who are tuned to a specific program, station or network in a specific area at a specific time. (See also, Rating, which represents tuning or viewing as a percent of the entire population being measured.)

Time Shifted Viewing – Program ratings for national sources are produced in three streams of data – Live, Live+Same Day (Live+SD) and Live+7 Day. Time shifted figures account for incremental viewing that takes place with DVRs which are currently in approximately 24.4% of all U.S. TV households. Live+Same Day (Live+SD) include viewing during the same broadcast day as the original telecast, with a cut-off of 3:00AM local time when meters transmit daily viewing to Nielsen for processing. Live+7 Day ratings include incremental viewing that takes place during the 7 days following a telecast.

For more information see Numbers 101.

Share:
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Digg
  • Reddit
  • StumbleUpon
  • Yahoo! Buzz
  • email
  • Add to favorites
  • Print
Your comments not appearing? You must be a registered Disqus user and have verified your e-mail address or use your Facebook, Twitter, Yahoo or OpenID account. If you have a registered Disqus account but never verified your e-mail, you may request another verification e-mail here. http://disqus.com/verify.
  • Anthony_m
    First of all Modern Family is hilarious. For the one or 2 people here who think its not funny someone must have stolen your funny bone. Secondly Happy Town was so bad it was almost insulting. I bailed out 3/4's of the way in.
  • johnlawsoncasey
    Well played Cyc2u. I guess this proves...

    A) I really am not a geography major
    B) I lost interest in Happy Town quite quickly and missed that, but did truly regain interest in the last minute or two
    C) Both A & B <grin>
  • nailpolish
    I was going to tape Happy Town but forgot all about it.
    I have the Middle set for every week so I watched that the next day.
    Love the Middle and can't wait till Betty White is on in May.
  • versaille2
    The Middle is a funny show. It reminds me of Malcolm In the Middle.
  • Cyc2u
    "Cyc2u: I am no geography major, and could very well be wrong, but is it not possible to have freshwater and salt water bodies of water close to each other?"

    The show is in Minnesota. Looooong drive to the ocean hehe.
  • johnlawsoncasey
    I think the promotion of Happy Town was lacking. I was looking forward to it, but for some odd reason was oblivious of what day and time it started. Like many shows you are going to need an episode or two to develop characters and plotlines. I have dismissed many shows on first episode or two only to go back later and eventually love the show. I admit for the first half hour I was like, I don't think so, but in the last minute on the show, it pulled me back in.

    And what's up with American Idol's numbers. What is the big facination with competition/reality TV style shows. Are viewers so mind numb that they are actually willing to watch 35 minutes of crap so they can be subjected to 25 minutes of commercials.

    Cyc2u: I am no geography major, and could very well be wrong, but is it not possible to have freshwater and salt water bodies of water close to each other?
  • Cyc2u
    I knew Happy Town had bad writing right off the bat. The guy is making a big stink about putting his boat in the water. And then they show them going to see a murder, and they are walking on a frozen lake. Sorry to say, but if 1 lake in the area is frozen enough to support ice fishing huts and walking, then NO lakes or ponds in the area will be clear of ice for boating. So the guy wanting to launch his boat is either retarded, or he fishes hundreds of miles to the south. Anyone from a cold climate knows, if 1 lake is frozen, they all are. Terrible writers error right off the bat.
  • Too add to Holly's answer, I can pretty much guarantee NBC puts dramas at 10pm from Monday-Thursday next fall because they still fear the affiliate whining/deal interference. The darkness of those dramas is presumably up for debate.
  • Holly
    1. ER flourished for years following NBC comedy night. Not as dark as HT is advertised, but not light and fluffy either.

    2. Ugly Betty had already failed long before it got moved to Wednesday (and before it got moved to Friday).

    3. I don't think ABC expect HT to do well and simply used it to fill a hole in their schedule.
  • annasarah1988
    Happy Town looked dumb so I'm not suprised it failed miserably.
  • jeffrey33
    i don't even get why they aired it after a string of back-to-back comedies, they should have aired this after DH. seriously, if Ugly Betty failed to build an audience there a few wks prior, did they seriously think a dark mystery drama would do better? THINK ABC!
  • AO
    And if High Society IS renewed, then maybe we will see a show with consistent 0.0 Ratings? It seems unlikely, and yet, Dawn is all about defying expectations. =)
  • Lucky_in_Vegas
    The new shows are done basically that way. I would say that it doesn't matter if ABC passes NBC or not, as advertisers will know what they are getting, and in terms of NBC, it's this season's weakest performing slate of regular series. And with ABC, some series that are starting to show their age, and a need for new blood.
  • AO
    I gave Happy Town a chance too, and definitely was underwhelmed. There were certain elements of it that I liked, for example I thought that it did a decent job of introducing a large cast of characters and for the most part made them reasonably distinctive, but overall I was not a fan. I'm not surprised by the numbers and would expect them to drop quite a bit by the time that the 8th Episode airs, if it is aired.
  • CJ_Shizzle
    I see an ABC R/C index in the future titled, "Unhappy future ahead for Happy Town".

    The sad thing was, H-Town was actually a mildly interesting show. Certainly not as awesome as FF or V were when they began, but probably the best new midseason show on ABC this year. Well, guess the network will just have to settle with the fact that 10 PM Wednesday has been a death zone for them and if V falls(and it may have already), then that's 0-6 on their new dramas this year. Of course premiering H-Town with just a few weeks left before the upfronts is never a bright idea.

    And are you kidding me with High Society?? Yeah, the CW's not behind that idea, otherwise Dawn Ostroff has gone off the deep end this time. :[

    On the positive side, MF hit another series high, well deserved there. Wonder if that episode is a build up to the season finale?
  • DarkSunStormbreak
    I am not surprised about Happy Town's poor start. I reviewed the promotion clips and thought it looked like a merging of Twin Peaks, Northern Exposure, and some Garrison Keillor radio stories brought to life, only without any of the good parts. I was that underwhelmed by the promos.

    Modern Family would have been first except for that American Idol bully! Phah! Foiled Again!
  • Ryan47
    Oh, HT premiered last night? I heard all the ads coming on the last couple weeks and just tuned them out, I guess. Heh. Had no idea it was starting up now. Oops!

    HT's bombing has to be good news for all dozen remaining fans of FF and V. I actually had semi-high hopes for it...but it makes absolutely zero sense at the end of ABC's comedy block. Yeah, the Cougar Town/comedy audience is going to stick around for a thriller/slasher/whatever-it-is. What genius thought of that slot?
  • i wanted to watch "happy town" last night, but totally forgot. guess i needed a GIANT V to remind me every 2 seconds it was on.
  • krisp8888
    I do not like cougar town either and yes- Romantically Challenged is horrible. I do not know how that is sustaining any ratings at all!!!!

    I couldn't even get through the second half of last mondays episode.

    Never watched HIMYM, though it looks alot better than RC.

    Cougar town- I saw the pilot. Nothing beyond that!

    I love Modern Family. If you have never seen- see the episode My Funky Valentine. Best episode!
  • SJ
    I don't know... I think Crystal has more star potential than Lee. As for Mike, he was already voted off once so he is for all intents and purposes on shaky grounds. But he is a good singer though.

    Didi, Siobhan and Lacey had a lot of appeal but alas, the voting system is, uh... broken.
  • krisp8888
    Ahhh.... That'll do it! That matt ghiard was from my state last year though(MI) and I did not care for him.
    I am thinking a mike/crystal finale-though I like lee alot too!
    Crystal is vocally very talented, But I fear a bit too emotional. Everyone says how hard the business is and how the show prepared them for it. I do not think she could handle it. With her almost quitting and ryan came out and stopped a very emotional crystal from leaving, etc. I just do not think she could handle the entertainment industry. I could be wrong- But that is what I think.

    Siobhan had a good voice but screamed much too much for me.
  • Order of finish in the ratings is meaningless except for PR purposes.

    Average 18-49 ratings for the season for the network as a whole is significant because it determines how much the network had the potential to make in advertising income for the current season.

    I suppose that ratings for shows that are to be canceled have no bearing on future sales, because they are no longer in consideration.

    I think Holly's description of how new shows for next season are priced is likely correct, but whatever advertisers pay for they get, either in the slots they originally contract for or in make up slots if the promised ratings do not materialize.
  • tvfanatic
    My reviews for last nights shows:

    The Middle--7/10
    Modern Family--8/10
    Cougar Town--9/10
    Happy Town--8/10
    Mercy--7.5/10

    I really liked Happy Town!
  • Holly
    The ads are based on what the advertiser think you will get, in the coming season. For returning shows, that's largely based on history. For new shows, it's based on the upfront presentations, educated guesswork, and pure speculation. Rearranging your schedule to give a boost to a soon-to-be-canceled show isn't going to help with either, and a couple of tenths of a point this late in the game isn't going to change the average much anyway.
  • annasarah1988
    wasnt the last aired Ugly Betty episode 1.8? not 1.4...
  • groove365
    Wouldn't every little ratings tick help NBC stay ahead of ABC for the year in the rating race so that they can charge that much more for ads on their shows next year?
    Or do I have that whole concept wrong and you don't charge more money being number 3 as opposed to number 4?
  • SJ
    I might have been a bit biased with Siobhan, as she's from my state. :) Plus, she's like the only contestant ever from MA.

    But my favorite was Didi, after she left I pretty much continued watching out of habit. And come on, who are we kidding - we're so having a Lee/Crystal finale. I'm rooting for Crystal.
  • SJ
    I don't like Cougar Town, but Romantically Challenged is without a doubt a million times worse. They actually had the audacity to copy HIMYM with that "All by myself" bit (well, it was "All by ourselves" on HIMYM, at least they made it original).

    For those of you who don't believe me, you can check it out here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UVU2kQmdmds (if you watched RC on Monday, you'll know what I'm talking about).
  • chef91
    cougar town gets a bad rep, but with an uncool name and much less acclaim than modern family and going against the harder part of the idol hour (the part with the actual results), a 2.8 isn't bad at all. it was pulling 3.0+s most of the time before idol came around anyway. and wooohooo for modern family! totally unaffected by idol.

    and sucks for happy town.. they def showed a TON of promos for it and i heard it was actually pretty good
  • Carol_R
    It's not a midseason show. It's a ending season show. The season is ending in a couple of weeks for most of primetime. It's idiotic IMO to put a new show on at the end of the season. New shows should start - in the fall (Sept-Oct), the Spring (Jan-Feb), or Summer (June). It is the end of April. May 1st is Saturday. Most viewers IMO are focussed on watching the last few episodes of the shows that they are interested in and not getting invested in new ones right now.
  • jhaas, "Human Target""s finale (probably series finale) was on April 14.
  • jhaas
    Happy Town was so phony. You can't expect Hollywood writers to convey the way regular people behave in the real world, but the characters on that show were beyond phony. To the point where the premise of a "Magic man" seemed implausible. A Magic man would have exterminated the whole town.

    What happened with Human Target's programming? My DVR is set to record it automatically each week but didn't yesterday. I also saw nothing to remind me a new episode would air, which is weird.
  • krisp8888
    I love julie bowen!
    I was quite surprised by her on kimmel though last night.
  • krisp8888
    The voting system does not work.
    People can vote as many times as they want(Sing off limited it to 10- which was a good idea!)
    Also- That vote for the worst.
    I personally was very glad sibhan was kicked off.
    The only one I care for this year is Big Mike.
    And I agree with Happy Town. It is only so-so and the ending was intriguing, The whole episode felt a bit rushed to me and especially the ending. They were trying to cram in so many characters into the pilto
  • timsdale4ever
    I watched HAPPY also. It wasn't awful, but for no more plot than was covered an hour was way too long for this show. Here's what confused me even before the show aired: ABC cancelled Eastwick in the same time slot after poor ratings, why would you schedule a very similar program in the same slot not that much later in the season? I thought Eastwick was pretty good by the way - 3 interesting leading ladies and the plot zipped along very nicely. Oh well....On another note, Cougar Town is a great show. I know it's silly but it is amazingly written and acted. WIth Cox, I'm surprised it isn't pulling in much better ratings. At least it's not Romantically Challenged -- GOD, what a diaster that is...
  • forg
    Congratulations Modern Family, 4.1 just amazing :D Kudos as well to The Middle and Cougar Town for decent numbers :D

    All episodes of Happy Town will be aired, it is just 8 episodes and it will end off season, it would probably get 1.2-1.5 towards the end of its run though which is what an ABC drama rerun would likely get so ABC will just burn this off and move on
  • peter93
    Cougar Town had an overrun of 1 minute last night.
  • Lucky_in_Vegas
    It doesn't matter what genre is airing in the timeslot. If a show doesn't have enough mass appeal, it will not be a winner. Dramas have been successfully airing after sitcoms for years and years and years. CSI Miami does just fine coming out of TBBT as did ER coming out of sitcoms for years on NBC and NYPD Blue on ABC, etc.,etc., etc.
  • Lucky_in_Vegas
    I don't think CBS will make that decision based only on a repeat airing that aired on entire night of repeats. While I love The Middle, and have been one of the show's biggest fans from the go, a new 2.5 Men, which I don't watch, airing on a night of new programming would have crushed it.
  • I'm looking forward to Persons Unknown. It's also got a "Prisoner" vibe as well. I wonder how well it could have done if NBC used it to plug one of their holes this Spring.
  • RiffRafferty
    Haplin, Minnesota. Home to happy cows, happy Stepford wives... and happy Canuck accents. A place so devoid of crime, Haplin might be the happiest town on earth! You'll know it from the first 5 minutes when some guy gets a spike jammed into his forehead with a hammer! Why, what could be happier than that? From the network that brought you "Twin Peaks" and dozens of virtually-unwatchable Stephen King adaptations and the people who brought you the virtually-unwatched "October Road" comes an unscripted show that's guaranteed to make the ratings for the last episode of "Twin Peaks" look like the ratings for the first episode of "Twin Peaks!" ABC's newest myst-sci-horredy, "Happy Town" (Wednesdays 10:00/9:00c), is already taking one-fiftieth of the nation by storm -- and we here at ABC plan to keep you on the edge of your seats for the duration of its entire 2-week run! But don't take our word for it! Just listen to what the critics have to say!

    Kristin Dos Santos of E! News raves, "It's official! 'Happy Town' is the turn-your-brain-off show of the year! Take it from me -- I turned mine off years ago!"

    Matt Roush of TV Guide rejoices, "Not since 'Harper's Island' has a show in which cardboard characters that exist only to be brutally slaughtered like cattle been so moving! Or would that be... mooooving? Well, mooooove over, David Lynch! If 'Happy Town' were a cow, I would get down on my knees and suck the milk right out of its teats! And then I'd ground it up into hamburger and eat it!"

    Entertainment Weekly's Michael Ausiello agrees, " 'Happy Town' makes 'October Road' look like 'Twin Peaks!' Finally! A show that will give 'Mad Men' a run for its money at the Emmys! I love 'Happy Town' so much, I almost didn't even need to be bribed to say how much I love it!"

    It's anonymous, ABC has another second-rate "Lost" on their hands! So make like Ann Wilson and grab a case of Bon-Bons, plop your gigantic ass down on the couch, and tune into the critically-reviewed "Happy Town" every Wednesday night, and you can try to understand, try to understand, try, try, try to understand this magic man! Of course you probably won't, because this show makes no sense whatsoever! (But if you do understand it, could you write in and explain it to us? Seriously, we've sat through it four times. None of us know what the hell this thing is about. We've heard there's a plot or something in there somewhere, and maybe Steven Weber croaks at some point, and supposedly Sam O'Neill shows up later on with a fake British accent to collect a paycheck and--Oh, who the hell cares. Just tune in and watch the commercials. They're more interesting, anyway.)
  • MrBlueEyes
    Trailer looked pretty nice for Happy Town. I haven't watched it yet, but those numbers are very bad.
  • To me, the real story is a rerun of Lie To Me winning the it's first 1/2 hour. The way it was promoted I was under the impression it was going to be a new episode.

    For a pilot episode, Happy Town really seemed to drag on to me. It's obvious ABC is still looking for its next 'Lost' (HT even has M.C. Gaines who was in few episodes of Lost) type hit show. Unfortunately, as it has been made pretty clear(ratings wise) Lost is not a show formula that is as easy to duplicate like CSI or L&O.; The only reason I tuned in at all was to see Angel/Dollhouse alum, Amy Acker's performance.
  • Thanks for that link to the Persons Unknown video... that looks pretty interesting. Too bad it's on NBC and the ratings will probably tank, but still, it should make for a good summer mini series!
  • tv_viewer
    Thanks for the information. I looked at the internet movie database but they didn't have a synopsis of the 8th episode of Happy Town. People may fear that the show will get cancelled before the murderer is revealed like Fox's Reunion.
  • added to the post:

    Over on the CW, America's Next Top Model had its most-watched episode in more than a month (since St. Patrick's Day) with nearly 3.3 million. While TV gossip blogs are talking about a second season of High Society set in the Hamptons, the CW has not picked the show up for a second season...at least not yet.

    Based on last night's ratings it seems much more likely that Tinsley Mortimer and cast are behind that rumor than the CW.
  • Lester's Fan
    A freshman series (Modern Family) pulling above a 4.0 against the highest rated show on TV should alarm the 'time slot killed my favorite show' theorists.
  • marcelrochester
    With Lost being sub-4 for its last 3 new episodes, and Grey's & Desperate still recovering from slumps, looks like Modern Family may be for now ABC's top scripted show. And arguably it's above at least one of the big 2 reality shows above it, if you average out Dancing with the Stars' 4.4 90 minutes & 2.4 60 minutes.
  • katie_kat
    You can't say ABC did not promote Happy Town. I have been seeing promos up the wazzo and nothing. I Dvr'd it and watched SVU. It's not the worst show but it's not the best. ABC has nothing it looks like replacing Lost. Good that Modern Family is doing well. It is a great show.

    IDOL is crap this year. The judging this year has been far more biased than ever in terms of who they want to push. One woman left. How pathetic. Isn't it interesting that the only IDOL winners that have risen to super star status are Kelly Clarkson(barf) and Carrie Underwood(love her). Daughtry's good but he didn't win.
  • People just didn't know it was on, like always. Monday's new episode of Big Bang at 9 instead of 9:30 very well could be a season low.
  • SJ
    They're not gonna pull it. It's the end of the season and it's not hurting any other show.
  • Tommy
    It's so late in the season I can see ABC just letting it air the remaining 7 episodes just to get it done with. They don't have anything they can replace it with that could get better ratings so they may as well let it ride.
  • Tommy
    I think ABC could have some success with a dramedy in the timeslot next season. A show similar to Desperate Housewives could do well after the comedies. I don't think a more serious procedural would flow as well as something that's light hearted and fun.
  • Happy Town should have never seen the light of day. Not the worst show but def wasn't good. I predict it being pulled after its third or fourth airing.
  • krthomas
    Happy Town seemed similar to Harper's Island to me, but perhaps less slasher and more gothic mystery. Harper's Island dragged on too long and became more and more ludicrous as the story played out. I guess Happy Town won't get that chance.

    I enjoyed Happy Town, but unfortunately shows like this have no chance. Hard to believe ABC ordered the show in the first place.
  • Tommy
    I am kind of surprised at how low 2.5 Men's repeat was. I know it was a repeat (and it still came close to what the normal Wednesday comedies get with new episodes) but it usually does pretty well in repeats on Mondays. Next week CBS has a repeat of TBBT scheduled at 8:30. So it looks like they are testing proven shows on Wednesday to see if it's worth keeping the Wednesday comedy block. I don't think they will consider moving either one if the repeats can't come close to what the repeats do on Mondays.
  • Holly, when they take someone from GA to PP, namely the Bailey trip, it's is to help PP. When Addison goes to LA it is to help both shows. This season after the Christmas break, the highest rated GA episode was the one that had Addison visiting.
  • SJ
    Oh, you're right. Dirty Sexy Money had the 10PM slot. Well anyway, better luck next year. I'm thinking a procedural could shake things up for that slot.
  • I didn't watch Happy Town because it looked like Harpers Island, it may or may not have been actually like that, but anyone knows that's not a good thing.
  • SJ
    Trust me, I know Mercy is deader than dead. But still, I would think that NBC wanted to try to up their weekly demo, even if by a smidge.
  • can anyone explain to me Fox's reasoning in rerunning LTM when they have new episodes for the summer?
    seems like one of the stranger programming decisions I have seen lately...
  • RealPerson
    So much for the endless promotion for Happy Town. I guess we all got fooled by the name, that's why 5 million people watched it
  • Holly
    The fact that after the move they had quite a few cross-over episodes to keep people from tuning out between GA and PP didn't hurt any either...
  • Tommy
    Somehow I knew the Private Practice move would come up, but if I remember correctly Private Practice actually aired at 9PM on Wednesdays, and it wasn't a total failure. Giving a show a bigger lead-in can help a show with mediocre ratings (especially when the 2 shows are so closely tied together,) but it won't help a show with horrible ratings enough to make a difference.
  • Holly
    I think it's far too late in the game for Mercy to gain from any scheduling changes. At this point, its burn-off and NBC has no real interest in boosting the ratings.
  • rob60990
    LOL funny, this should be added to the bingo card if it isnt there already!
  • Tommy
    I agree with you, either way, ABC didn't have much faith in it and after watching it last night I can see why.
  • SJ
    That could be right, but last season also saw Private Practice moving out of that timeslot halfway through and the new drama they put there, The Unusuals, failed as well. The 2007-2008 season was cut short by the strike but it was clear that Private Practice was slipping in later episodes. So it could be the material, but ABC hasn't had a hit there for at least three seasons. (I don't remember how things were before that.)
  • My understanding is that it was not always an 8 episode deal. That could be wrong, and even if it isn't it has been an 8 episode order for so long now that for practical purposes it was an 8 episode order all-along. That doesn't really change my point though. There's not much relative difference to me between "cut the order" and "gave it a short order". They never loved it either way.
  • Tommy
    I doubt Mercy would see any real bump in the ratings even against repeats. It's never scored well no matter what it's competition was. Again it comes down to Mercy being a bad show, not where it was scheduled.
  • Why Cougar Town don't retains more lead-in from Modern Family?

    The answer is here http://tvbythenumbers.com/2010/04/28/ladies-nig...

    ABC should try airing this show on mondays after Dancing with the Stars.
  • SJ
    Oh, NBC, how you fail at life. For once they had the chance to boost Mercy's ratings by airing it against repeats and they stick it in the Idol hour. I love how they keep digging themselves into a hole.

    Christine's repeat ratings about the same as the originals lately... don't know what to make of it.

    And Julie Bowen should win an Emmy for her performance on Modern Family.
  • Tommy
    That's what I read in the post:

    The premiere of Happy Town on ABC were bad, but probably only as bad as any reasonable person would’ve imagined, including the executives at ABC. You know, the same people who cut the order to 8 episodes and kept it off the schedule for almost the entire season. Not even ABC could’ve been surprised it would be its lowest-rated premiere of the season.
  • Tommy
    Did we really expect anything else from HT? God, that 10PM slot on Wednesdays is totally ABC's death slot.

    I don't buy the argument that the timeslot is a death slot. ABC has scheduled nothing but garbage in that timeslot all season. The shows killed themselves not the timeslot. Eastwick, Ugly Betty, and Happy Town would have all failed in any other timeslot.
  • SJ
    Cut? I thought there was 8 episodes all along.
  • TimFan
    I really dont get why Modern family gets those numbers its not even funny
  • that was done specifically with annoying you in mind. It worked!
  • Tom
    No advertisement LtM repeat gets in the same ballpark as HT? Goodbye HT, hello midseason emergency filler for LtM.

    2.5Men repeat gets in the same ballpark as new Wed. AoP? Goodbye AoP.

    1.6 for the second half of Happy Town? Goodbye HT(2). Given how little ABC has in the wings, it probably stays on the schedule though.
  • cucumberjones
    I didn't watch Happy Town yet (I'll watch tonight), but I'm pretty excited to see it. What a shame that its going to be cancelled already. Hopefully the 8 episodes work well as a mini-series in that case.
  • Tommy
    I tried Happy Town last night, and I have to say it was horrible. I actually enjoyed The Deep End more, and that's not saying much. I completely understand why ABC cut it's episode order.
  • rob60990
    Why is The Middle 2nd if it won the hour?

    Cougar Town will die next season but I can see ABC getting at least 3 seasons out of it.
  • Lester's Fan
    Happy Town was good enough to have the lowest recording priority on my DVR
  • Do not adjust your computer monitors or iPhones. The jumbled mess of numbers was me, not you.

    I'm not sure why that happened, but either way, it's now fixed.
  • tariqq
    probably another edition of the Bachlorette , a new dancing show etc.
  • melbye
    So every new drama ABC have aired this year has been a flop, what are they going to do now
  • tariqq
    Actually they reveal the magic man identity in episode 8 the finale but its revealed as the twist at the end and is not really resolved
  • Lisa
    I did not enjoy Happy Town. No wonder it got held back so long. I guess the only thing I'll be watching on Wednesday the rest of the season is Idol (and Mercy if/when it airs).
  • No. Table formatting is hosed. Robert will likely be correcting ASAP.
  • tariqq
    Happy Town wasnt as good as Harper's Island but i'll still watch it. Persons Unknown looks like the real Harper's Island replacement with a Lost/Saw vibe
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KoiAmWrAinI
  • SJ
    Did we really expect anything else from HT? God, that 10PM slot on Wednesdays is totally ABC's death slot.

    I watched it, and I don't get the comparison to Harper's Island. Twin Peaks, I never watched, but HI was a mini-series, one that CBS intended on moving to Saturdays anyway. The ratings didn't much matter because it was a filler and it had a definitive ending. Plus, even if it had been a ratings juggernaut, how would the show have continued with only 4 survivors out of more than 40?

    That being said, the show is only so-so. My motto is, never judge a show by its pilot, I tend to hate pilots usually so I'll keep on watching but I'm not kidding myself - this show is done come June 16th. The premise is OK, the cliffhanger at the end was intriguing but it felt rushed, it was like "You know, as you know I am the sheriff of this town and we had that meeting that time where we discussed that thing..." It was too explanatory, it was a little dry.

    So that marks ABC's cancellation number 12. Yeah, don't order any midseason shows next year, ABC. But as we already discussed, ABC won't have more than 3.5/4.5 hours to fill but it's still a HUGE failure.

    Surprising Idol results last night; it just goes to show that this voting system isn't working anymore. I mean, if you have one girl and four guys in the top 5, then something's not kosher. And the girls have been way more praised since the beginning of the season than the guys.
  • Julia
    Not just you. I was worried it might be IE, though.
  • Holly
    Is it just me, or is the table not formated to be...well...a table?
  • tv_viewer
    The problem with Happy Town is that people aren't sure when they will reveal the identity of the "Magic Man." At least for Harper's Island, the audience knew that the identities of the two murderers were revealed by the end of the 13th episode.
  • rob60990
    Unless my computer is messed up, I dont see a chart. I see something else I cant explain.
  • Craig_212
    I thought it would be similar to Harper's Island as well.

    I haven't gotten around to watching it yet.
  • show data now added.
  • rob60990
    Yikes at Happy Town! Good for Modern Family and The Middle! Cougar Town couldnt at least pull a 3.0 last night? Wow!
  • I watched Happy Town last night, it didn't think it was horrible but it wasn't amazing either. If they reduced the number of characters it would be better. Way to hard to follow with the number of characters they introduced last night. I'll give it another try next week.
  • I watched Happy Town last night, but was not amused. I thought it would be something similar to the premise of Harper's Island, but it is way out there.

    Highly doubt I'll watch again next week...
  • FairviewU
    Well, I didn't watch "Happy Town " last night. It didn't look interesting enough.
blog comments powered by Disqus
Renew of Cancel Index


Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus