WASHINGTON -- In 1985 as a teenager in Kenya, I was an adamant member of the Muslim Brotherhood. Seventeen years later, in 2002, I took part in a political campaign to win votes for the conservative party in the Netherlands. Those two experiences gave me some insights that I think are relevant to the current crisis in Egypt. They lead me to believe it is highly likely but not inevitable that the Muslim Brotherhood will win the elections to be held in Egypt this coming September.
As a participant in an election campaign, I learned a few basic lessons.
The secular democratic and human rights groups in Egypt and in the rest of the Arab world show little sign of understanding these facts of political life. The Muslim Brotherhood, on the other hand, gets at least three out of four. True, they have never been in office. But they have a political program and a vision not only until the next elections, but in their view until the Hereafter. And they are very good at reminding Egyptians of why the other party's policies will be ungodly and therefore catastrophic for Egypt. Above all, they have succeeded in embedding themselves in Egyptian society in ways that could prove crucial.
When I was 15-years-old and considered myself a member of the Muslim Brotherhood movement, there were secular political groups in the diasporas of Pakistanis, Yemenis and Somalis in Nairobi who lived in exile like my family. These loosely organized groups had vague plans for restoring their respective countries and building them into peaceful, prosperous nations. These were dreams they never realized.
The Muslim Brotherhood did more than dream. With the help of money from Saudi Arabia and other oil-rich countries, they established cells in my school and functioning institutions in my neighborhood. There were extracurricular activities for students. There were prayer and chant hours, as well as communal Quran readings. We were encouraged to become volunteers, to help the indigent, to spread Allah's message. There were classes and activities for all age groups. They established charities to which we could give Zakat (tithe for charity), which was then used to provide health and educational centers.
The Brotherhood also provided the only functioning banking networks, based on trust. They rescued teenagers from lives of drug addiction and excited them about a purposeful future for justice. Each of us was expected to recruit more people for the Muslim Brotherhood, creating a perpetual campaign. The mosques and Muslim centers were the main areas of association, but they visited us at home too. Most importantly, their message transcended ethnicity, social class and even educational levels.
It is true that the movement was violent, but we tend to underestimate in the West the Brotherhood's ability to adapt to reality and implement lessons learned. One such adaptation is the ongoing debate within the network on the use of violence. There are two schools of thought within the network, and both of them invoke the Prophet Mohammed as an example.
Those who want instant Jihad hark back to the time when the Prophet had small armies that defeated massive ones, as in the battles of Badr and Uhud. The nonviolent branch of the Brotherhood emphasizes the Prophet's perseverance and patience. They emphasize Da'wa (persuasion through preaching and by example) and above all a gradual multi-generational process in coming to power and holding on to it. Above all, they argue for Taqiyyah, a strategy to collaborate with your enemies until the time is ripe to defeat them or convert them to Islam.
Why are the secular democratic forces in Egypt so much weaker than the Muslim Brotherhood? There are a number of factors. One reason is that they are an amalgam of very diverse elements: There are tribal leaders, free-market liberals, socialists, hard-core Marxists and human rights activists. In other words, they lack common ideological glue comparable to the one that the Brotherhood has. Finally, there is a deep-seated fear that opposition to the Muslim Brotherhood, whose aim is to install Sharia once they come to power, will be seen by the masses as a rejection of Islam altogether.
What the secular groups fail to do is to come up with a message of opposition that says "yes" to Islam, but "no" to Sharia -- in other words, a campaign that emphasizes a separation of religion from politics. For Egypt and other Arab nations to escape the tragedy of either tyranny or Sharia, there has to be a third way that separates religion from politics while establishing a representative government, the rule of law, and conditions friendly to trade, investment and employment.
The bravery of the secular groups that have now unified behind Mohamed ElBaradei cannot be doubted. They have taken the world by surprise, by mounting a successful protest against a tyrant. Mubarak may be deaf, but the message is loud and clear: He has to go.
The secular democrats' next challenge is the Brotherhood. They must waste no time in persuading the Egyptian electorate why a Sharia-based government would be bad for them. Unlike the Iranians in 1979, the Egyptians have before them the example of a people who opted for Sharia -- the Iranians of 1979 -- and who have lived to regret it.
The 2009 Green Movement in Iran was not a "no" to a strongman, but a "no" to Sharia. ElBaradei and his supporters must spell out over and over again that a Sharia-based regime is repressive at home and aggressive abroad. Moreover, as the masses cry out against unemployment, rising food prices and corruption, Egypt's secular groups must show that a Sharia-based government would exacerbate these agonies.
The Muslim Brotherhood will insist that a vote for them is a vote for Allah's law. But the positions of power in government will not be filled by God and his angels. These positions will be filled by men so arrogant as to put themselves in the position of Allah. And as the Iranians of 2009 have learned to their cost, it is harder to vote such men out of office than to vote them in.
The Obama administration can help the secular groups with the resources and the skills necessary to organize, campaign and to establish competing economic and civil institutions so that they can defeat the Muslim Brotherhood at the ballot box. As I have come to learn over the years, few things in democratic politics are inevitable. But without effective organization, the secular, democratic forces that have swept one tyranny aside could easily succumb to another.
Ayaan Hirsi Ali is the author of "Nomad" and "Infidel." She is a fellow of the American Enterprise Institute and founder of the AHA Foundation, which works to protect the rights of Muslim women.
© 2011 Global Viewpoint Network; Dist. by Tribune Media SERVICES.
Tariq Ramadan: Democratic Turkey Is the Template for Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood
JanoCharbel
Photos: The Uprising in Cairo, Day 16 http://tinyurl.com/6bkoy... #Egypt #EgyWorkers #Unions #Jan25 #Revolution
7 minutes ago from web
|
||
lheron
Very true. Can see it esp in #Egypt coverage. RT @garethoconnor: @lheron social media now mainstream news source #wjchat
9 minutes ago from TweetChat
|
||
grossdm Clearly, self-immolation is hot trend of 2011. The guy in tunisia, the guy in egypt, rep. Chris Lee... | ||
headlinenews AFP: Israel's Barak discusses Egypt at White House: WASHINGTON (AFP) - Israel's Defense Minister Ehud Barak met... http://yhoo.it/dJOI7Y | ||
GottaLaff
RT @cynthiaboaz: If u oppose terrorsm support uprising in Egypt. As nonviolnt action succeeds it delegitmizes violnt action as force 4 chnge
11 minutes ago from TweetDeck
|
||
Tharwacolamus
#Egypt counts cost of turmoil, protesters undaunted | http://goo.gl/qRMXm #jan25
18 minutes ago from web
|
||
fustat
R @msbahari Egypt's army 'involved in detentions and #torture' http://gu.com/p/2n2tf/ip via @guardian #Jan25 #HumanRights
23 minutes ago from web
|
||
muiz
Update on strikes & iteration of protestor spirit/mood by #Egypt'ian blogger/activist @3arabawy on @AJEnglish | http://is.gd/vKf5Rb | #Jan25
24 minutes ago from web
|
||
monaeltahawy I've RTd some views I've received on Ayaan Hirsi Ali to reflect what's out there and now no more: point is she is not expert on #Egypt | ||
BBCKimGhattas #Obama called Saudi King. WH said Obama stressed need for immediate orderly transition in #Egypt. Didn't say what King replied. | ||
fustat
R @Gsquare86 After talking all day ..i am speechless, all i can say is: LONG LIVE THE REVOLUTION ! #Jan25 #Egypt #Tahrir
27 minutes ago from web
|
||
AidNews
Egypt: Investigate Arrests of Activists, Journalists http://dlvr.it/GCBpM
28 minutes ago from dlvr.it
|
||
Gsquare86
After talking all day ..i am speechless, all i can say is: LONG LIVE THE REVOLUTION ! #Jan25 #Egypt #Tahrir
29 minutes ago from Echofon
|
||
BostonUpdate House & home: White House: Basic citizen demands unmet by Egypt - http://b.globe.com/eRS5GI | ||
ShereefAbbas
"Pentagon moving warships, preparing for possible evacuations: http://lat.ms/gGGAwZ " v @pdxuser #Jan25 #Egypt
31 minutes ago from TweetDeck
|
||
headlinenews Reuters: U.S. and Egypt square off over protesters' demands: CAIRO (Reuters) - The government of embattled Egypt... http://bit.ly/idNRAG | ||
unicefusa
Following events in #Egypt & elsewhere? The @UNDP Arab Human Development Report is worth a look http://bit.ly/exOp3R
35 minutes ago from HootSuite
|
||
Rouelshimi Egypt's army 'involved in detentions and torture' http://t.co/ukNtlH3 via @guardian | ||
BreakingNews In call with Saudi king about Egypt, Obama calls for 'immediate steps toward an orderly transition that is meaningful, lasting' - NBC News | ||
CBSRadioNews
White House says Egypt must make a greater effort to satisfy protesters' demands. Listen to the 8pm newscast: http://bit.ly/cbsnewscast
37 minutes ago from web
|
||
The Fix - Harry Reid: "I had nothing to do with" bad economy
Egypt: ABC News' Christiane Amanpour Exclusive Interview with President Mubarak - ABC News
Mubarak family fortune could reach $70bn, say experts | World news | The Guardian
Muslim Brotherhood - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
MIDDLE EAST: Ignoring Egyptians, Iran continues to hail 'Islamic awakening'
Is Muslim Brotherhood shaped by 1950s views?
O'Reilly interview: Obama's Muslim Brotherhood support questioned
Share your Comment:
These are no conspiracy theories.
They with their media are conspiring to control OUR lives!!
Funny these comments are coming from a country that is barely 300 years old and which has already engaged in all kind of horrible things from genocide against the native Indians, the nuclear bombing of civilians, napalming villages in Asia to the institutio
How many millions of people did the tyranny of the US government kill in the last 30 years?
Answer me the above question and tell me who is responsibl
What business does the US have in Egypt???
EGYPT IS NOT YOUR COUNTRY AND DOES NOT REPORT TO YOU OR TO YOUR IMPERIALIS
And as for your question above, the USA is responsibl
Yet likewise there have also been religion-b
2.Candidat
3.The party has to be embedded in as many communitie
4.Candidat
This is basically the republican political model as espoused by the American Enterprise Institute. Too bad the Tea Party has done an end run around it's agenda. I find it a little strange that a person that seems so involved with protecting the rights of women espouses a political agenda aimed at winning without really providing any real protection
Or perhaps she feels that pointing out that the Muslim Brotherhoo
Trust needs to be earned slowly over a period of time.
Nasser was secular but to support Israel they have strengthen
They supported moderate Islam in Turkey where after the 1980 coup (CIA inspired) hundreds of state run religious schools mushroomed
Anything but socialism, anything but fairness for the Palestinia
EGYPT belongs to those who are citizens of that nation, the Egyptians.
Muslim Brotherhoo
In this nation we say, America, take it or leave it.
Same is true for other nations.
One of the golden rules is to treat others as you want to be treated.
Egypt is for Egyptians, alone.
If you actually read Ms Ali you'd know she'd be the first to agree with you.
Soon after Ali arrived in Holland, she saw that instead of liberal politician
As a result, Ali who had been active inside progressiv
The lies and smears about Ali followed. Many are repeated here on this thread. Perhaps what you've experience
"Infidel" should be required reading for anyone interested in this issue. Its an amazing story on many levels and a very fast read.
Egypt has it's own problems and in one basis, it stems from what has been going on in the futures market.
...and that starts on wall street.
No wonder they are pissed at us.
Because of this, the administra
We, the tax payer, pays for the subsidies.