The New York Times


February 16, 2011, 9:50 pm

Love and Other Insurance Policies

TowniesTownies is a series about life in New York.

“In the Spring a young man’s fancy lightly turns to thoughts of love.” — Alfred Lord Tennyson, “Locksley Hall”

New York City seems paradoxically to be drawing farther away from spring with each day’s descent into February, and I make no claims to youth. Still, Tennyson’s cliché was clamoring about my head last Saturday as I drove through the Red Hook section of Brooklyn. To one side of me was Ikea, a blue-and-yellow behemoth squatting near an inlet to Gowanus Bay, and to the other, melt-resistant drifts of snow and debris and black ice deposited here by the city’s work crews during this season’s seemingly endless blizzards. In their car seats, my four-year-old boy peppered me with questions on every subject and my infant daughter snoozed. Tomoko, my girlfriend, sat beside me listening to the radio. Not a scene of particularly romantic bliss, and yet my thoughts (light, vernal and otherwise) still turned to love and, yes, marriage.

I should use the proper term: Tomoko is my fiancée, and has been since last week when I signed my separation agreement with Harper’s Magazine, negotiated by my union lawyer. Among other details included in the contract — 10 weeks of severance; an agreement to give any of my would-be employers a “neutral” reference; and a non-disparagement clause that I refused to sign — Harper’s agreed to make the Cobra health insurance payments on my behalf for the next four months. This last bit marks the inception of my betrothal: when the payments end we will be married.

Rich Tu


Tomoko and I met and fell in love nearly two years ago, as I was going through a protracted divorce. A beautiful, caring and patient woman, she endured my rants on custody law and the indignities of court appearances, taught me yoga, took me surfing. She endured the disbursement of the better part of my income to the divorce lawyer, and accepted that my son’s mother would always remain a fixture in our lives. We took an apartment together as our relationship deepened. She grew close to my boy, became pregnant with our child, and we considered our options for the future. Discussions regarding marriage occurred, predicated, of course, on the completion of my divorce. (It was a source of much joking at Harper’s — another thing I’ll truly miss — that my second child came before my first divorce.) But neither of us wanted to rush things. It felt unseemly to dive immediately into a new marriage so soon after the formal dissolution of an earlier one. We’d make our wedding when we wanted, we agreed, not merely when permitted by the state or demanded by a sense of social propriety.

But now that I was out of a job, and with more than $1,300 per month in Cobra payments looming, it seemed we had no choice. No ritual act of asking for her hand ensued. My knees went unsullied with dust from the floor. I didn’t have a ring. I came home from the lawyer’s office and launched into a lecture on what I took to be our connubial options, then muttered something about the refreshing simplicity of a civil affair. Tomoko pressed her mouth firmly shut, did a neck stretch that I recognized from her yoga practice, and frowned beatifically — an indication, I knew, that her reserves of forbearance had been dangerously depleted.

Tomoko had been married once before, and she’d told me she wouldn’t require a grand country-club affair this time around, with white dress and black tie, two dinner choices and a band fresh from its latest bar mitzvah engagement. I also believe she wants to be married to me and that we will be married. She was just insulted by the brutally practical approach I had taken to the matter.

We let the subject rest for the day, but throughout the week, when we weren’t preoccupied with the sleeping and dining habits of our 3-month-old girl; when we weren’t ferrying my son to pre-school or soccer class or hockey or play dates, or whatever myriad social obligations we had scheduled for him; when I wasn’t off reporting and writing my book or sending around my resume; we talked about a wedding. Tomoko, to her everlasting credit, did her best. City Hall, she said, wasn’t her first preference. She wanted a ceremony, at home in our backyard, with family and some friends, in warm weather. Besides, her maternity leave will end soon, and she worried she wouldn’t have time or energy to plan a proper wedding before the insurance payments ended. As such, she offered, she would be willing to be married now at City Hall and then do things correctly later in the summer when we were more able.

Foolishly, I objected. I wanted one wedding, as soon as possible, and couldn’t be made to understand why organizing it would prove so difficult.

My perspective can’t solely be ascribed to financial considerations. Waiting for the right moment has never struck me as an effective way to move through life. There is no right time. We all seem to have an innate tendency to create complexities for ourselves, and obstacles will ever bar the way. Many people stubbornly insist on the proper moment or person or opportunity to have children, marry, travel, start a business, write a book, build a house, change cities. What they really seem to need is an excuse not to act. This philosophy has taken me around the world, provided me with two children, and allowed me to pursue goals (editing, writing) that if they have failed to make me rich, and likely never will, have offered other satisfactions.

Still, I knew I had fallen far short of Tennyson’s amorous ideal. The image of the “wanton lapwing” who “gets himself another crest” doesn’t quite jibe with a 38-year-old man squiring his reluctant beloved to an anonymous City Hall wedding. And a quiet woman in a car bodes no man well.

Tomoko and I spent much of the rest of that Saturday apart. She attended a yoga class, her first and much-deserved opportunity in months to be away from the baby. Even while keeping up with both kids, I kept part of my mind free to think. I wanted very much to blame this predicament on my former employer. If I hadn’t lost my job I would have kept my insurance and we would have married how and when we saw fit. I was an angry man; fuming that Harper’s had taken my job; irate that I had been asked to sign over my integrity (I know non-disparagement language is fairly standard, but no writer or reporter should contractually give away the obligation to be honest); and most of all, infuriated that I was allowing the magazine to set the parameters of my wedding.

That act of allowing, and the weakness that it implied, transformed things for me. Along with my children, Tomoko’s presence in my life is a sure sign of my unwarranted good fortune. We haven’t yet decided what we’re going to do. But what I should have understood immediately I understand now: to yield to what she wants, and when, isn’t yielding at all. It’s a privilege.


Theodore Ross

Theodore Ross is the author of the forthcoming book “Am I a Jew” and a contributor to the blog Dadwagon.


Townies, a series about life in New York written by the novelists, journalists and essayists who live there, appears every Thursday. This month’s columnist is Theodore Ross, the author of the forthcoming book “Am I a Jew.”

Inside Opinionator

February 18, 2011
William Webb’s World

How a Mississippi slave built an information network across the South.

February 18, 2011
Start Spreading the News

How Lincoln won over a skeptical New York crowd – and a local poet.

More From Disunion »

February 18, 2011
What Makes Community Health Care Work?

Five factors that help programs in poor villages without doctors succeed.

February 14, 2011
Villages Without Doctors

In poor countries, people with no or little formal medical training are improving the health of entire villages.

More From Fixes »

February 18, 2011
Cairo in the Midwest?

Will Wisconsin’s battle over state employees create a domino effect?

February 11, 2011
Egypt’s Revolution, Bush’s Victory?

Some conservatives feel that the ousting of Mubarak was a result of the “freedom agenda.”

More From The Thread »

February 17, 2011
There Won’t Be Blood

No disrespect to Jefferson, but Egypt showed us the blood of patriots and tyrants is better left unspilled.

February 3, 2011
Bonfire of American Vanities

The revolution in Egypt owes little to well-meaning American naïvete.

More From Timothy Egan »

February 16, 2011
Love and Other Insurance Policies

Should wedding bells follow the pink slip?

February 9, 2011
A Beginner’s Guide to Unemployment

A writer’s confusing first week after losing his job.

More From Townies »

February 16, 2011
How Goldman Killed A.I.G.

The financial crisis commission’s much-overlooked big story.

February 2, 2011
Summers’s Crystal Ball

Lawrence Summers, the former N.E.C. director, sees an encouraging economic future.

More From William D. Cohan »

February 16, 2011
Budget Politics

In proposing such timid cuts, is President Obama daring the Republicans to go first? Is that a smart move?

February 9, 2011
Let’s Talk About Social Security

What is the best way to tackle what seems like an insurmountable problem? Should we raise the retirement age? Create private accounts? Or both?

More From The Conversation »

February 15, 2011
Why Aren’t G.M.O. Foods Labeled?

American consumers who want to avoid genetically modified foods should not have to resort to guesswork.

February 8, 2011
Is ‘Eat Real Food’ Unthinkable?

The new diet and health guidelines from three powerful sources don’t go quite far enough.

More From Mark Bittman »

February 9, 2011
What Would Shirley Do?

As Shirley Chisholm noted, it’s black and Hispanic women who are hurt the most when access to abortion is restricted.

January 22, 2011
Legacy of a Fence

The momentary infatuation with a “virtual fence” with Mexico resulted in changes to the separation of powers that raise constitutional questions.

More From Linda Greenhouse »

February 7, 2011
What Is Academic Work?

In academic debate for academic debate’s sake, the pleasures are as palpable as they are esoteric.

January 31, 2011
Race to the Top of What? Obama On Education

Do the president’s remarks on education indicate more trouble ahead for the humanities?

More From Stanley Fish »

January 28, 2011
The Wrath of Grapes

The author reckons with the time he drank all that scotch, and finds a measure of comfort in Lady Astor, Kingsley Amis and ‘Othello.’

January 7, 2011
Sauce for the Goose? Take a Gander

An early television-writing gig unravels, and the author hits the bottle — which hits back.

More From Dick Cavett »

January 19, 2011
Pilgrim’s Progress

An Iraq veteran finds that the time and space between New York and Iraq can disappear in an instant.

November 10, 2010
Lives During Wartime, Vol. 2

Recollections and photographs of members of the United States Armed Forces in acknowledgment of Veterans Day.

More From Home Fires »

January 18, 2011
Sharing the Burden of Peace

How the United States can stopping footing the bill — and taking all the flak — for neutralizing security threats around the world.

January 11, 2011
First Comes Fear

Violent rhetoric isn’t the problem; it’s casting political opponents as scary outsiders.

More From Robert Wright »

January 13, 2011
All Tomorrow’s Taxis

Let’s raise the bar for New York City taxi design.

December 17, 2010
Can Airports Be Fun?

A newly renovated terminal at San Francisco International Airport hopes to improve the traveler’s experience.

More From Allison Arieff »

January 13, 2011
All Tomorrow’s Taxis

Let’s raise the bar for New York City taxi design.

December 17, 2010
Can Airports Be Fun?

A newly renovated terminal at San Francisco International Airport hopes to improve the traveler’s experience.

More From Allison Arieff »

Opinionator Highlights

What Makes Community Health Care Work?

Five factors that help programs in poor villages without doctors succeed.

Villages Without Doctors

In poor countries, people with no or little formal medical training are improving the health of entire villages.

A Cautious Faith in the Army

In the complex balance of powers in Egypt, the army is both the ruler and “ally” of the people.

Race, Sex and the Trials of a Young Explorer

Even as scientific knowledge flourished in the 19th century, many naturalists remained steeped in racial prejudices and stereotypes.

Thumbnail
Making the Text-to-Mom Connection

How teamwork and a “fanatical attention to science” bolster a simple but effective program for prenatal and infant health.

Previous Series

Thumbnail
Line by Line

A series on the basics of drawing, presented by the artist and author James McMullan, beginning with line, perspective, proportion and structure.

Thumbnail
The Elements of Math

A series on math, from the basic to the baffling, by Steven Strogatz. Beginning with why numbers are helpful and finishing with the mysteries of infinity.

Thumbnail
The Stone

Contemporary philosophers discuss issues both timely and timeless.