FitzPatrick’s tale hard to swallow
January 14, 2011 @ 12:41 pm | by John Collins
It has to be said The Fitzpatrick Tapes is compelling reading. When I first heard about Tom Lyons and Brian Carey book in The Sunday Times I had reservations. What had the two journalists agreed to in order to get the former Anglo Irish Bank boss Sean FitzPatrick to speak at length on the record – something he has streadfastly reused to do since the collapse of his beloved institution?
Tom Lyons covers off the genesis of the book very well in his introduction. FitzPatrick wanted to give his side of the story and Lyons put in the groundwork to win his trust and cooperation.
The issue is that FitzPatrick’s claims around many key events are hard to swallow – even for his colleagues. The authors call him out on some of these claims – such as not knowing the identity of the “Maple 10″, the Anglo clients who bought 10 per cent of Sean Quinn’s stake in the bank. FitzPatrick himself acknowledges that others have different memories of key events – in one case Anglo exec Pat Whelan has phone records to prove he informed him the deal was close to completion. But even then FitzPatrick can’t say he was wrong – just that he believed Whelan.
The true worth of the book, however, is how it has driven the news agenda this week and shown there are significant gaps in our knowledge about events running up to the bank guarantee. The revelations about FitzPatrick’s golf game with the Taoiseach have now been followed with the news that Cowen assembled a kitchen cabinet at Druid’s Glen but apparently one which did not discuss the elephant in the room – the ailing Anglo.
While much more rounded accounts of the meltdown in Irish banking will emerge, and are currently being worked on, The Fitzpatrick Tapes is a compelling, if by its nature limited, contribution to the publics knowledge of events that have helped bring our economy to its knees.
- A full review of The FitzPatrick Tapes by Kathy Sheridan will appear in tomorrow’s Irish Times.