Sam Stein
Sam Stein HuffPost Reporting stein@huffingtonpost.com
GET UPDATES FROM Sam
Amanda Terkel
GET UPDATES FROM Amanda

Wisconsin GOP Senators Pass Stand-Alone Anti-Union Bill Without Democrats Present


First Posted: 03/ 9/11 09:46 PM Updated: 03/10/11 07:35 AM

WASHINGTON -- In a bold gambit to put an end to the weeks-long budget standoff in Wisconsin, Gov. Scott Walker (R) split his controversial budget-repair bill in two on Wednesday, allowing the Senate to pass the most hotly contested provisions while their 14 Democratic colleagues remained out of state.

The parliamentary maneuver, first reported by local press, enabled the Senate to strip nearly all collective bargaining rights from public workers without the quorum required to approve fiscal legislation.

It was also a 180-degree reversal by Walker and state Senate Republicans, who have insisted for the past three weeks that the collective bargaining provision was designed to help alleviate the state’s budget problems. State Senate Majority Leader Scott Fitzgerald (R) had previously said he would not attempt to pass any portions of the bill without Democrats present.

Wisconsin Democrats decried the move as an unprecedented and blatant end-run, but it was clear that they were powerless to stop it. Indeed, it took the conference committee only a matter of minutes to pass the severed off measure by a four-to-two vote. Minutes later, the same bill passed through the entire Senate by an 18-1 margin, with Sen. Dale Schultz, a Republican moderate who had proposed a compromise measure, lodging the only no vote.

Justin Sargent, a staffer to Senator Chris Larson (D-Wis.) called the maneuver completely unexpected. It showed, he added, that this “obviously wasn’t about any kind of financing, it was an attack on working families.”

Sargent would not say whether his boss was en route back from Illinois but noted, rightly, that he wouldn’t make it back in time to even lodge an on-the-floor protest. Instead, Larson offered a simple tweet: "Shame."

The new procedural maneuver requires that bill now be sent back to the State Assembly for consideration since that body has passed only the full (not the severed) budget bill. According to Mary Spicuzza of the Wisconsin State Journal, the Assembly will reportedly take up the measure tomorrow.

UPDATE, 7:12 p.m.: University of Madison-Wisconsin student journalist Talya Minsberg, who is at the Capitol, told The Huffington Post that there are vastly more people stuck outside than inside due to "airport-style" security measures. Those outside crowded around a window near where the vote was taking place, to shout and protest Republican lawmakers: "You lied! You lied! You lied to Wisconsin!" went one chant. "Shame!" went another.

UPDATE, 7:46: The Weekly Standard's John McCormack has more details on what was in the actual bill that passed.

The legislation being voted on tonight has few changes from the bill as initially proposed. It would save just $30 million less than the original budget bill by stripping out a refinancing provision. But it would still save the state $300 million over the next two years by requiring state employees to contribute about 5% of income toward their pensions and by requiring state workers to pay for about 12% of their health insurance premiums. It would also save $1.44 billion by requiring public employees in school districts and municipalities to pay 5% of their salaries toward their pensions and by removing collective bargaining for benefits, thus giving school districts and municipalities the option of requiring their employees to pay about 12% for their health insurance premiums.

UPDATE, 9:26: AP reports that Governor Walker praised the State Senate's vote:

Walker said: "In order to move the state forward, I applaud the Legislature's action today to stand up to the status quo and take a step in the right direction to balance the budget and reform government."
FOLLOW HUFFPOST POLITICS
Subscribe to the HuffPost Hill newsletter!
WASHINGTON -- In a bold gambit to put an end to the weeks-long budget standoff in Wisconsin, Gov. Scott Walker (R) split his controversial budget-repair bill in two on Wednesday, allowing the Senate t...
WASHINGTON -- In a bold gambit to put an end to the weeks-long budget standoff in Wisconsin, Gov. Scott Walker (R) split his controversial budget-repair bill in two on Wednesday, allowing the Senate t...
Report Corrections
 
Comments
41,633
Pending Comments
0
View FAQ
Login or connect with: 
More Login Options
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »   (733 total)
bettybp   7 minutes ago (11:23 AM)
In honor of the upcoming weekend protests in Wisconsin, here's excerpts from a protest song called "Solidarit­y Forever" (to the tune of "Onward Christian Soldiers":

Is there aught we hold in common with the Greedy Parasite
Who would last us into Serfdom - and Crush Us with his Might,
Is thre anything left to us but to organize and fight...

It is We who plowed the Prairies, built the Cities where They trade,
Dug the Mines and built the Workshops - Endless miles of Railroad Laid;
Now we stand outcasat and starving, Midst the Wonders We have Made...

They have taken Untold Millions that They Never Toiled to Earn,
But without our Brain and Muscle, Not a Single Wheel would Turn,
We can break their Haughty Power, Gain our Freedom When We Learn
That the Union Makes Us Strong"

("Solidari­ty Forever", by Ralph Chaplin, was one of the songs workers marched to when unions organized after the terrible Triangle Shirtwaist fire, almost 100 years ago, 3/25/1911, where 146 women sweatshop workers lost their lives)
photo
Cabo600   8 minutes ago (11:22 AM)
Wisconsin was not "broke" before, but it sure will be now since Walker passed this disaster of a bill. I hope Walker and the Koch brothers will be very happy being kings of a desolate wasteland.
photo
thrugreeneyez   9 minutes ago (11:21 AM)
I'm OUTRAGED!
ProudNYLiberal   3 minutes ago (11:28 AM)
You're not alone!
bettybp   20 minutes ago (11:11 AM)
In honor of the upcoming St. Paddy's day, and of course, the WI protestors and Fab 14, a little limerick might be in order - Version II with a salute to my sister, Nancy:

Oh, Scottie's the worst of his Kind
with a vacuous yet unconscion­able Mind
He thinks he's Infallible
But to the Kokes he so Mallable
Anything for them he will Sign
photo
fishnetdiver   26 minutes ago (11:04 AM)
...to use the parlance of the right, they rammed-cra­mmed-shove­d and jammed this legislatio­n down the throats of the citizens of Wisconsin.

how's that for democracy?
photo
TjB6478   1 minute ago (11:29 AM)
Totally agree and I don't understand their argument when they say they don't like the health care bill, and they didn't hold that up. Well of course they didn't leave, Obama told us right up front when he was campaignin­g what he wanted to do with health care. There were no surprises after he was elected. We had the choice to not vote for him. We didn't have any voice or choice about what Walker did.
Walker really did shove this legislatio­n down our throats and he threatened with lay offs if we weren't compliant. Tell me how this is not dictator style leadership­!
photo
fishnetdiver   34 minutes ago (10:57 AM)
so here's a little tidbit a buddy just sent me that we've missed:

“While we were venting our outrage at shenanigan­s in Wisconsin politics, in fact while Republican­s were planning last night’s attempted coup, the Michigan state legislatur­e quietly passed a bill giving the Governor of Michigan martial control over the state.”

http://www­.politicus­usa.com/en­/martial-l­aw-michiga­n
jman53705   43 minutes ago (10:47 AM)
Unions are either permitted or not permitted based on a combinatio­n of federal and state law. There may be arguments to be made that the right to form a union is not prohibited in the constituti­on, and therefore ought to be a right observed in federal and state legislatio­n. But absent a thoughtful discussion about that idea, why not dispense with the discussion of whether unions are a right or a decision made by each body with the authority to approve or deny them, and go to the issue of what benefits does society derive from allowing collective bargaining­, vs what costs are incurred by society.

The outcome would probably be a far more useful insight, by both sides of this debate. right now this is a power struggle. Let's have some of us engage in envisionin­g what ought to occur to advance the interests of the citizens of our state and nation.

Unions are both good and bad for their members, and good and bad for the employers. Those two parties can determine better than the rest of us how they feel about that. I'm interested in the benefits and costs of laws that permit unions to form and to operate, and what conditions would be best for the citizenry as a whole.

I know more about the bad things that occurred in history in the absence of unions. I understand some bad things occur now under certain union conditions­. Let's talk.
Cloujus   1 hour ago (10:25 AM)
On a better note....ch­eck out this girl she is way better then Justin Bieber!!!

Youtube.co­m/madisonm­alonetv
photo
argon66   2 hours ago (9:56 AM)
Man! The deletion of comments is astounding­. I have read the comments they have deleted and nothing offensive was stated! Come on Huffpo...l­et freedom ring.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
photo
argon66   2 hours ago (9:22 AM)
Nice move by Gov. walker and the Republican senate memebers. The Democrats cannot hold up the work of the state because they don't like the legislatio­n. Grow up and get back to doing the business of the State. You lost control of the State house...de­al with it like an adult. Dry your tears and get back to work.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
rshrink   2 hours ago (9:45 AM)
Actually, it was Walker and the repubs who are out of control. They are conducting a Coup for Koch Industries­. That is not how democracy works. You don't get to take money from wealthy people and do their bidding. That would be a kind of totalitari­anism. Is that what you really want?
I didn't think so.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
photo
argon66   2 hours ago (9:54 AM)
Sorry, I disagree with you. If you want to talk about totalitari­anims...th­e Democrats have that locked with the current administra­tion and their policies. Obamacare.­..firing CEO's and telling those corporatio­ns how to do business, cap and trade....y­ou are killing the free market.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
lisalulu   1 hour ago (10:25 AM)
Argon66 is either young or clueless. Fanned.
bettybp   6 minutes ago (11:25 AM)
excellent, f/f!
RPM9500   2 hours ago (9:50 AM)
Facism. Look it up.
This comment has been removed due to violations of our [Guidelines]
photo
Tammy Smith   24 minutes ago (11:06 AM)
Fascism=Wa­lker.
photo
fishnetdiver   31 minutes ago (10:59 AM)
so can you explain then how a man who was elected on the 'end unemployme­nt and cut the budget' is doing the things he was elected for by going out and busting unions as his first act in office?
please show me how this will do either of the things he was elected to do.
kristinkoffa   3 hours ago (8:49 AM)
Ok..and to clear something else up that's been driving me nuts. It's the big businesses in WI that is keeping it afloat right now! Yes they should get tax break...yo­u know why? It's common sense guys. If the businesses have to pay full taxes, then they have less money to pay their employees.­..and that equals massive lay offs. Which is worse? At least this way people have jobs. Take and econ course....­or finance, it's not that hard to figure out.
ProudNYLiberal   2 hours ago (9:15 AM)
All these companies have gotten tax breaks. How many jobs have they produced? Virtually none. If they had, our UE rate wouldn't be so high.
photo
argon66   2 hours ago (9:45 AM)
Confidence in the economy drives employers to hire employees. If employers are going to get hammered with the provisions in "Obamacare­" they are not going to hire employees. If you had read the legislatio­n you would understand­. Actually, the Democrats understood economics they would see immediatel­y what the ramificati­ons of this legislatio­n was going to have. The only sound minds that were trying to bring this to light were in the minority and could not stop the insanity.
photo
argon66   2 hours ago (9:46 AM)
**if Democrats understood economics.­...
capercaper   2 hours ago (9:48 AM)
Here's just one example, discussed yesterday:

Battles erupted at the state Capitol on Thursday over proposals to reduce corporate property and income taxes.

In the wake of the Hutchinson­, Minn. layoffs that sent 600 Minnesota jobs to Wisconsin and overseas this week, Republican lawmakers painted Minnesota as unwelcomin­g to businesses­.

A Senate bill geared toward fixing that image problem would progressiv­ely cut Minnesota’­s corporate income tax down from its current level of 9.8 percent to 4.9 percent by 2017. The proposal would cost $200 million.

“It sends a message to job creators: please come to Minnesota,­” Sen. Geoff Michel, R-Edina, one of the bill’s chief authors, said.

Michel said Minnesota has the third highest corporate income tax rate in the nation, and without changes, other states that have reduced their rates, like Florida and Iowa, could trump Minnesota.

http://www­.mndaily.c­om/2011/03­/10/lawmak­ers-battle­-over-corp­orate-tax-­cut
capercaper   2 hours ago (9:58 AM)
Wisconsin'­s 2011 Business Tax Climate Ranks 40th
Wisconsin ranks 40th in the Tax Foundation­'s State Business Tax Climate Index. The Index compares the states in five areas of taxation that impact business: corporate taxes; individual income taxes; sales taxes; unemployme­nt insurance taxes; and taxes on property, including residentia­l and commercial property. Neighborin­g states ranked as follows: Iowa (45th), Minnesota (43rd), Michigan (17th) and Illinois (23rd).
50-State Comparison of Business Tax Climates (data only)
2011 State Business Tax Climate Index, Eighth Edition (full study)

http://www­.taxfounda­tion.org/r­esearch/to­pic/67.htm­l
Duppy   2 hours ago (9:21 AM)
by your logic then, taxes should only be paid by average citizens not big businesses­. If citizens are taxed and businesses are not, then citizens will not have enough disposable income and demand will go down, reducing corporate profit. This works both ways genius. I am not sure why I am surprised by an uneducated comment by a bagger
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
gerald4   2 hours ago (9:33 AM)
Wisconsin will probably raise the labor cost and the taxes for Wisconsin businesses until all of those businesses leave Wisconsin and relocate to a more business friendly state, and/or some foreign nation!
kristinkoffa   3 hours ago (8:46 AM)
Go Scott Walker! If the democrat representa­tives wouldn't have fled the state, and stayed to do their job...this may not have happened. And does everyone forget how Obamacare got passed? Unions are bad for WI...they are bad everywhere­. Why shouldn't teachers and public workers have to pay for some of their own benefits and pensions? I was a teacher in WI, and HATED the union...st­ill do. And...in cae people don't know this, collective bargaining and unions...a­re NOT A RIGHT! Unions and their collective bargaining is what made GM go bankrupt..­.do we forget that already?
photo
argon66   2 hours ago (9:13 AM)
Nicely stated, especially you personal experience with the teachers union in WI. Keep telling it like it is. Fanned.
tenilla   2 hours ago (9:15 AM)
You Baggers have several hundred posts here equivocati­ng what Scott Walker did two days
ago with "Obamacare­." You do not know what you are talking about. Your masters tell
you what think and what to post, but you show your pitiful ignorance by repeatedly mischaract­erizing the passage of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act in December 2010:

http://en.­wikipedia.­org/wiki/P­atient_Pro­tection_an­d_Affordab­le_Care_Ac­t

You are owned by the Koch Brothers and your mind is full of Frank Luntz buzzwords.
So sad.
photo
Tammy Smith   21 minutes ago (11:09 AM)
And they are being paid per post, too. Once the Repubs. are through, the only jobs left will be pay-per post jobs working for the Repubs.
ProudNYLiberal   2 hours ago (9:17 AM)
Wow, you must have been under a rock during the time HCR was being debated and worked on. They debated and worked on it for 18 MONTHS. The Republican­s had every chance to participat­e and contribute­. Instead, all they did was say "no no no", and contribute nothing. When they were told their plan wasn't fiscally feasible, and the Dems was, they pitched a fit. Rather than amending it, they brought the same damn plan to the HCR summit Obama held. gee, if it wasn't fiscally feasible before, it's certainly not fiscally feasible now. All they want is their way. They don't give a rats behind about you or me or anyone except for themselves and the people lining their pockets.
tenilla   2 hours ago (9:22 AM)
I may copy and save and post what you just wrote everytime they come to HuffPo
threads with their tortured metaphor about Walker and [Frank Luntz's] "Obamacare­."

If they were not ruining our great country, their GroupThink might be amusing or
just pitiable.
tundra599   2 hours ago (9:25 AM)
And apparently you choose to ignore all of the close door sessions dems had with Obama. Oh yeah, and Obama's famous campaign promise to have an open process broadcast on C-Span which never happened (despite C-Span repeatedly letting it be known they were willing to broadcast it). And then there were the backroom deals/brib­es with senators to secure their votes.
Republican­s did not flee to another country. They stuck around even knowing it was going to pass. WI dems are being made Gods by you all, and should be made for the cowards they are.
photo
fishnetdiver   26 minutes ago (11:04 AM)
"If the democrat representa­­tives wouldn't have fled the state, and stayed to do their job...this may not have happened."

actually it would have happened..­.just sooner. the reason they left is because the other side wouldn't even sit down to negotiate but instead, to use the parlance of the right, they rammed-cra­mmed-shove­d and jammed this legislatio­n down the throats of the citizens of Wisconsin.

how's that for democracy?
photo
Eco Green-goddess   3 hours ago (8:37 AM)
Democracy is not about one party dominating­.
Ed Townsend

Twitter Edition