A demonstrator in front of energy firm RWE's HQ in Essen on Saturday. Photo: DPA

Most Germans would sacrifice lifestyle to ditch nuclear energy

Published: 3 Apr 11 11:23 CET
Online: http://www.thelocal.de/national/20110403-34147.html

A majority of Germans would sacrifice a certain level of quality of life in order to close down the country’s nuclear power stations, according to a new survey.

The poll found that 60 percent of those questioned were in favour of Germany generating its energy from only non-nuclear sources – even if this meant personal sacrifices.

Polling company Emnid was commissioned by the Bild am Sonntag to conduct the survey, which questioned 501 people.

Of those, 30 percent said they wanted an immediate exit from nuclear energy while 27 percent said they would accept it for another five years. A further 20 percent said another ten years of nuclear energy was acceptable and necessary – as planned by the Social Democrat-Green coalition.

Only 17 percent of those asked said they were in favour of nuclear power being included in Germany’s energy policy until 2030 or longer.

Such opinions benefit the political fortunes of the Green Party, said Klaus Schöppner, head of Emnid. “After the atomic catastrophe in Japan, people are very emotional. In this situation, the Greens can only win sympathy,” he said.

And the results showed that 27 percent of those asked favoured the Green Party over all others, while 54 percent wanted to see the Greens play a bigger role in the future than currently. This latter view was shared by 36 percent of Christian Democrat supporters.

Those in favour of ditching nuclear energy have the churches on their side too, it emerged on Sunday, when the Catholic and Protestant representatives on the Ethics Commission on Atomic Energy expressed their views.

Munich Archbishop Cardinal Reinhard Marx, who represents the Catholic Church on the commission, told Sunday's Frankfurter Allgemeine Zeitung that he felt a technology that had incalculable consequences for entire generations could not be trusted.

And Ulrich Fischer, Baden state bishop of the Evangelical Church, warned in the Mannheimer Morgen newspaper on Saturday, of a "foul compromise" should domestic nuclear power stations be closed but nuclear-generated energy be imported.

He said Germany should proceed with an exit strategy as fast as possible – under the condition that social life continues with clear energy saving measures.

“We are dealing with goods which we cannot leave to the market,” said Marx, adding that financial help for the poor should be considered if a new mixture of energy, including renewable sources, increased prices.

The Ethics Commission on the Future of Nuclear Energy meets on Monday for the first time and includes a range of people from politics, business, society and the churches. They have been charged by Chancellor Angela Merkel to draw up conditions under which the continued use of nuclear power might continue in Germany in the face of the disaster in Japan.

DAPD/DPA/hc

What do you think? Leave your comment below.

Fark It! Digg This  Share everywhere
Send to a friend Printable version Twitter This

Your comments about this article:

11:45 April 3, 2011 by pepsionice
So, let's get the question right. You wouldn't mind having a daily black-out of power between 9AM and 1PM? Or you wouldn't mind stopping all inter-city subways at 8PM in the evening? Or you wouldn't mind switching off seventy percent of outdoor lighting during the evening hours? Or you wouldn't mind telling stores to toss out half the light bulbs they have throughout a windowless store? Or would you like to mandate that refrigerators barely cool at all....causing spoiled food on a weekly basis?

Which one is it?

Go and try to take any German family back to the 1930s style of living and watch how quick they change their tune.
12:27 April 3, 2011 by Obreption
What are the green alternatives? Is there enough space in Germany for wind farms? Are the Harz Mountains going to be covered in photo voltaic cells? Have we solved the solar powered lamp yet? I agree with the comment above. While appreciating native German angst over nuclear power, it doesn't seem to be such a big issue in the UK; it is barely on the radar apart from scare stories about iodine.

I dread to think how much energy has gone into delivering flowers for the English Mother's Day today.
12:39 April 3, 2011 by berfel
pepsionice,

In B-W, they need to cut back on 60% of their electricity use to be nuclear-free. The measures you note wouldn't be enough.

Manufacturing would have to scale down massively. Of course the products would still be in demand, so the population would tend to migrate along with production, if it's still reasonable to do so. B-W without Mercedes, Porsche, Audi, Bosch, ...

Sure they'd achive the necessary energy cuts. But there'd be nobody left to actually produce wealth to pay real taxes, not just taxes on money handed out by social engineers.

The nuclear fears are totally irrational. Pumped up by fear-mongers who benefit from people making irrational decisions.

if EnBW were totally privately owned, they could shut down all their nuclear power stations as a demonstration of the consequences that the alleged 30% wanting to take an immediate exit.
13:11 April 3, 2011 by DOZ
Maybe, but after a year the German People would have an up-rising. Typical, no guts no glory.
13:16 April 3, 2011 by way2cool
Just try to turn off the electricity few times a weeks just for a few hours at a time to see how these clowns like it? Half of them will beg to build more nuk plants after few months for sure! Or better yet, triple their electricity bills, see how they react to it?
13:22 April 3, 2011 by Englishted
501 people of a country of over 80million .

Not a very good poll.

However that said it is showing the knee-jerk reaction to a earthquake in Japan.

If Germany had a quake on that scale it would have big problems with or without

nuclear power plants .Also the country is surrounded by plants do they intend to force their closer to ?.

I agree with the points raised by pepsionice,Obreption,and berfel, and cannot see any alternatives to nuclear yet but when there is one I am sure we will welcome it.
16:59 April 3, 2011 by catjones
Simply buy power from France. The 'sacrifice' would be higher costs.
03:10 April 4, 2011 by neunElf
I am heartened by the previous reasoned responses to this contentious issue!

I fear that this headlong rush into the abandoning of nuclear energy signals a "top" of the current economic cycle and will if enacted, lead to much greater harm and deprivation for Germany going forward.

Unfortunately in politics momentum is a greater factor than intelligence and leadership!
09:32 April 4, 2011 by moistvelvet
"501 people of a country of over 80million .

Not a very good poll"

Indeed 501 people is not alot, the headline is rather misleading. But what happened to the missing 6% and were all those asked actually "German" which they claim?

Love how the religious throw their opinion in, saying that the technology "could not be trusted", well in Japan wasn't the catastrophe caused by the Earthquake/Tsunami? So surely it is their god that can't be trusted.
09:38 April 4, 2011 by Angry Ami
LOL, yeah right, most Germans would give up their freedom and liberty for a dictator if it meant life ling employment, oh they already did that, oops, but seriously folks like pepsionice said, just as soon as they can't have their spoiled little lifestyle then that would be that, and who did the actually pole anyway, some of the usaul greenies, sure of course they'd say yes to such a stupid idea, but I don't think the rest of us living in DE are so keen on this idea, it'd be like the Philippines and Jamaica, 3hrs on, 3hrs off, and then you'd have folks who'd start using petrol generators which would kill any environmental gains that the greenies hope for, here's a German word that best describes this idea "bescheuert"!
10:01 April 4, 2011 by freechoice
ideas on how to save on electricity.

1. cut down on fancy lightings! just use a single lightbulb with energy saving features.

2. stop watching silly TVs. ditch those energy intensive CRT, LCD, Plasma or LED TVs. Use an battery operated iPad/Mobile phone instead.

3. ditch the high powered Hifi, listen to battery operated iPods/Mp3 players instead.
10:32 April 4, 2011 by mobiusro
1. Why bother with a bulb? Candles baby. Brings more romance in one's life

2. Why watch anything at all. Play board games, play card games, stare at the stars or at the moon.

3. Why use electronics at all? Try to sing. If you cannot sing, try learning to play an instrument.

4. Why turn the radiators on? Make a nice cosy fire.

5. While you're at it, buy 2 horses and a carriage. Ditch that metal four wheeled vehicle.

That's why we evolved x thousand years, to go back to sitting in the dark again. Technology is the devil!!!
15:56 April 4, 2011 by bogart57
Lifestyle sacrifice? Oh please if the power/utility concerns can sell the idea that shutting down the atomic power plants is good for the environment along with raising rates then it will happen. Oh the Germans talk about what is good for the environment, but sadly in the end the money making interests will win out. Ok, maybe what happens with Stuttgart 21 will prove me wrong. But, there is a big shopping mall called Loop 5 in South Hessen built in the last 3 years that shows the environment will always lose out to money interests.
21:36 April 4, 2011 by Celeon
To anyone thinking about wether the nuclear power supported lifestyle is worth it all, let me advise you to read the wikipedia article on the Waste Isolation Pilot Plant in the USA.

Especially the part about the planned warning markers, a "Message to the future" that is to be built there all around the disposal site.

A warning message supposed to be written in words and pictures and in several languages.

Not written down on paper or printed on signs.

These things do not last long enough to fulfill their job.

Encarved into stone so that i may last for 10.000 years after which this place will still be a deadly danger.

A message that is supposed to last longer than the egyptian pyramides, hopefully will still be there and understandable in 10.000 years , no matter what language people will speak by then, or if people will have forgotten about this place thousand of years ago.

No matter if the USA , countries or even civilisation as we know it will still exist by then. The waste stored there will be still there and will still be toxic and radioactive, so much is certain.

A warning that will continue to tell people for 10.000 years a message that will be still as valid as on the day it was created by people who long turned to dust.

"STAY AWAY ! THIS PLACE CONTAINS AN INVISIBLE DANGER THAT WILL HURT OR KILL YOU IF YOU GO THERE"

If humans will still be there that time from now, they will certainly curse us all for what we have left behind for them to deal with in our unlimited shortsightness.
ADD YOUR COMMENT   (YOU MUST LOG IN OR REGISTER TO MAKE A COMMENT)
Today's headlines
Photo: DPA

Obama plans state dinner for Merkel

US President Barack Obama will welcome German Chancellor Angela Merkel to a White House state dinner on June 7, and present her with America’s highest civilian award, the White House announced late Monday. READ »

Photo: DPA

Neo-Nazis 'take over' tiny village of Jamel

Cries of “Sieg Heil” in the street, neo-Nazi rallies, far-right slogans on walls: welcome to Jamel, a tiny northeast German village locals say has been annexed by Nazi sympathisers. READ »

Photo: DPA

Kafka's letters bought by German archive

More than 100 letters that the great German-language author Franz Kafka wrote to his sister will go on display in Baden-Württemberg after they were bought by the German Literature Archive Marbach. READ (1 COMMENT) »

Photo: DPA

Submarine helps in Air France salvage

Bodies of people killed in the Air France crash near Brazil in 2009 have been found, French officials said Monday. Their search for the wreckage and victims – among them 28 Germans – was aided by a robot from a Kiel institute. READ (2 COMMENTS) »

Working in Germany
Photo: DPA

Finding company when you're a freelancer

Freelancers and entrepreneurs tired of working in their pyjamas or nursing a cold cappuccino are coming together in communal offices. David Sharp reports on the hot trend among Germany's self-employed. READ »

A Nazi U-848 in the south Atlantic. Photo: Wikipedia Commons

New files reveal bungled Nazi submarine mission to US

A Nazi submarine mission to the United States during World War II that aimed to unleash a wave of terror ended in farce after being hit by a series of disasters, newly released files showed Monday. READ (11 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Berlin condemns arrest of Chinese artist

Germany expressed its "great concern" on Monday about the detention of Ai Weiwei, a prominent Chinese artist and outspoken critic of the regime in Beijing who was planning to set up a studio in Berlin. READ (8 COMMENTS) »

Photo: DPA

Lucky lotto player wins €24.8-million jackpot

A lucky lotto player from Stuttgart has become the third-biggest winner in German history by snaring a €24.8-million jackpot on Saturday. READ (1 COMMENT) »

More National
Highlights
Photo: Raddatz
SOCIETY »
A bakery that used a photo of a black baby to advertise its special offer on chocolate cakes has defended its campaign, saying protests and complaints of racism have come from an over-sensitive minority.
Photo: Warner Bros.
LIFESTYLE »
The Local's English-language movie listings for Germany
Photo: DPA
OPINION »
Blown out in Baden-Württemberg: Merkel’s out-of-touch CDU couldn’t stave off an electoral defeat of historic proportions in its conservative heartland, writes Marc Young.
Photo: HUK COBURG
SOCIETY »
Working in Germany: Knowing workplace etiquette can make or break your career. Jeff Kavanagh spends a day on the job.
Photo: DPA
SCIENCE & TECH »
Japan's nuclear crisis has thrown Germany's national energy strategy into disarray. Alexander Bakst reports on how phasing out atomic power could speed the transition to renewables.
Photo: DPA
SOCIETY »
Immigration has rarely been out of the headlines since banker Thilo Sarrazin sparked a bitter debate last year. The Local examines the issue.
Photo: DPA
GALLERY »
RIP: Knut the polar bear
TILIA Living Resort
SPONSORED ARTICLE
TILIA Living Resort in Berlin: a vacation in your own home
DKB-Cash: Banking in Germany made easy
SPONSORED ARTICLE
DKB-Cash: Banking in Germany made easy
Photo: Eurail
SPONSORED ARTICLE
Eurail and InterRail: Where a journey becomes an adventure


See all ads | Join the Marketplace

Jobs in Germany, in English

1001 jobs available
662 new jobs this week
0 new jobs today

ALL JOBS »

Latest news from The Local in Sweden
Blog
Essentials

Dating
Looking for your own blonde bombshell? Or is the strong, silent type more your style? Find a German sweetheart here.

Weather
"After clouds comes clear weather," say the Germans. But what about after that? Find out in The Local's weather section.

Blog
German stuff that's distracting us today.

Noticeboard
Whether you want to buy, sell, hire, announce or promote something, here's the place to do it - completely free of charge.

Discuss
Debate the news, ask for advice, make friends - or just let off steam.

Search News


Register

Register now for:
> Free use of noticeboard
> Special discounts
> Weekly news roundup
> Unlimited use of discuss

REGISTER FOR FREE »

News from the Goethe-Institut
News from Young Germany
News from DeutschlandOnline

Toytown Germany
Germany's English-speaking crowd
Rental apartments in Berlin
For home-from-home holiday accommodation, search for a Berlin apartment to rent.

The Local Europe GmbH
Schwedter Strasse 227
10435 Berlin
Germany