;

Comments in chronological order (Total 47 comments)

  • This symbol indicates that that person is The Guardian's staffStaff
  • This symbol indicates that that person is a contributorContributor
  • OneGonk

    11 February 2011 1:40PM

    This comment was removed by a moderator because it didn't abide by our community standards. Replies may also be deleted. For more detail see our FAQs.

  • Shajaracode

    11 February 2011 1:46PM

    History is made in the land of history!
    The revolution is as magnificent as Egypt. Over 10 million revolutionists peacefully exposing the true terrorist morally and politically bankrupted regime.
    Mubarak could not have stayed that long on his seat unless he is well supported by equally magnificent anti-Egyptian forces.

  • DrJohnZoidberg

    11 February 2011 2:07PM

    great pics....but disturbing amounts of males involved and far too much facial hair. i fear that egypt has just revolted itself from the dictatorial frying pan and is headed for the theocratic fire.....

    now, how about some articles on what's going on in downtown tehran and about karroubi and moussavi? oh silly me, iran is anti-american and anti-israeli, so there will be no coverage of events there on cif....

  • bailliegillies

    11 February 2011 2:16PM

    Really excellent photos that tell a fantastic story. Brilliant idea to do them all in B&W as it lends to the atmosphere and gives more of a feeling than colour ever could.

  • socialistMike

    11 February 2011 2:36PM

    great pics....but disturbing amounts of males involved and far too much facial hair. i fear that egypt has just revolted itself from the dictatorial frying pan and is headed for the theocratic fire.....

    Of course you do, dear. Anyone could have predicted what you would think about it actually.

  • DrJohnZoidberg

    11 February 2011 2:41PM

    jessica-

    nice one....i almost take back what i said...'actually'....

    the cynic in me can't help but think that there will be hints that moussavi and karoubi are shills for the u.s. or 'them zionists', but i look forward to the piece.

    and good luck to the egyptians, whatever they want...i just hope that women get a say in the future as well. and not just the urban, middle class, academic ones.

    to move forward the egyptians need to look to their proud past and not to the mindset and world view which was later imposed on them.

  • SmokinGardener

    11 February 2011 2:43PM

    Superb images - you really get an idea of what Egypt is like. Like so many other countries where women are non-existent.

    Ever since this story started, and the various pictures that have whirled around world, they all seem to have one thing in common. Men. However this revolution plays out (and others), I hope it does something positive for equality in the near future. I'm not very optimistic though.

  • DrJohnZoidberg

    11 February 2011 2:45PM

    Of course you do, dear. Anyone could have predicted what you would think about it actually.

    was there any point to that comment 'actually',or were you just doing a spot on impression of a petulant lefty trying to rubbish an opposing pov?

  • GenitalLectual

    11 February 2011 2:59PM

    protestors shoot, hosni leaps and big-handed ...fingertips ...just
    ...there is a rebound

    ...
    ..But the american linesman was flagging offside anyway
    and goodness gracious
    the ref has blown had half time too


    ....some footie match innit?

  • TripleJarhead

    11 February 2011 3:13PM

    I noticed photograph number 3.

    29 January: Burnt out The headquarters of the ruling NDP party and the Supreme Press Council were set on fire by protesters

    Can I assume that those were peaceful protesters?

  • andrewwiseman

    11 February 2011 5:44PM

    Wonderful news despite the uncertain future

    How upset they must be in Tel Aviv and Tehran, one at losing their puppet, the other that their people now see succesfsul revolt in action

    But now we in the West must ask some difficult questions: how did we come to champion and support through money, arms, intelligence and diplomacy a vile dictator all these years with almost no comment - as long as the tourist busses kept rolling that is? How much did our great companies pay to get juicy contratcs while brave men and wmoemn were beatend and murdered in the basement of the Interior Ministry in Cairo?

    What a price we pay for the US israeli lobby's success in utterly perverting that country's foreign policy. Of course they had to back Mubarak, after all what Arab would supprot israel unless massively corrupted by US funds?

  • Zarahustra

    11 February 2011 5:56PM

    I feel the need to write something.

    The corporate mass media and western governments are framing this as:

    1) the triumph of popular democracy in the ME

    2) the west is both worried (about the possible emergence of Islam), and pleased that democracy will prevail and thrive.

    The fact is the western or anglo-american elite has fermented this 'revolution'. This will have the impact of:

    1) Possibly giving rise to 'Islamic democracy' (the quotes indicate that a Islam that is supposedly radical will be given power, it will not actually be radical for instance the people behind the Islamic bank are supposedly radical Muslim Brotherhood, yet they integrate Islam into the quasi capitalist system).

    2) Many muslims will be fooled into thinking this is the real thing.

    3) It will bolster the war on terror, justify spending billions of dollars on defense and keep the anglo american elite in power.

    When one man leaves government and another takes over nothing really change. Remember the Euphoria many felt when Tony Blair first won his election? Try watching some old footage of this event. Tony Blair the nut job. And now we have David Cameron!! Democracy is really just a rotten tree which gives bad fruit.

  • JohnCan45

    11 February 2011 6:25PM

    As Nicholas Kristof and others have said, seeing the back of Mubarak is not the end. The essential regime - a military junta in Armani suits - is still in power. There's a hell of a lot of work to do before Egypt is a democracy.

  • Novocastrian13

    11 February 2011 7:01PM

    Don't delude yourselves. This is nothing less than a military coup. Wave bye to one military hard man and prepare to welcome his successor. It will take a hard man to zap all the roll-eyed men with smelly beards and bruises on their foreheads

  • TonyPancake

    11 February 2011 7:30PM

    What rubbish about a "peaceful revolution", as if this can be portrayed as the same as Czechoslovakia in 1989 - over 300 people killed, and even deaths yesterday (but not in Cairo where the media focuses all its cameras). Police stations burnt and violent attacks on bourgeois property have been an essentiam part of this movement. But it's so convenient to portray it as peaceful because that way the "new" rulers can impose an idea that any of the poor who try to continue this movement is a violent enemy of the "people" (which people?) and deserves to be put down by "the friend of the people" - the army.

    The real struggles (against poverty and its world) will continue, but let's not pretend this is in any way over.

  • Zarahustra

    11 February 2011 7:38PM

    @Novocastrian13

    Perhaps, but it's a fucking sight better than the alternative/blockquote>

    This is a common refrain. Lets look at the facts. Both the US and UK are supposedly democratic, they impose their will on other countries, topple governments and generally cause mayhem. This means democratic governments have hostile relations with other countries.

    Lets look at the UK at home. Supposedly these law makers that we the people elected have the power to increase taxes (steal our property through coercion), they can bailout billionaire bankers when they fail with tax payers money. And once we agree to give a bunch of people the power to make laws for us, it means they can take away our liberty whenever they deem it right and make it perfectly legal. Under British Common Law, we have very few laws, and they cannot be changed on a whim, and the golden rule is everything is allowed so long as no other individual is harmed, in his/her person, reputation, property or life, and do whatever you have contracted or agreed to do or pay the penalty. No one is exempt from this, not even government. The democratic government takes our property in taxes and is therefore against common law.

  • BadDog

    11 February 2011 10:04PM

    DrJohnZoidberg 2:07PM

    great pics....but disturbing amounts of males involved and far too much facial hair. i fear that egypt has just revolted itself from the dictatorial frying pan and is headed for the theocratic fire.....

    Which might possibly be because most of his photographs were taken when the protesters were confronting Mubarek's thugs and had moved their women to safety.
    He describes one of his photographs:

    The police kept firing continuous rounds of live ammunition, rubber bullets, birdshots. I don't know how many died. I saw at least one. Many were injured.

    Here is one of his photos.
    I can't make out much facial hair there. Can you?

  • agreewith

    11 February 2011 10:24PM

    Ozymandias

    by Percy Bysshe Shelley
    I met a traveler from an antique land
    Who said: Two vast and trunkless legs of stone
    Stand in the desert. Near them, on the sand,
    Half sunk, a shattered visage lies, whose frown,
    And wrinkled lip, and sneer of cold command,
    Tell that its sculptor well those passions read
    Which yet survive, stamped on these lifeless things,
    The hand that mocked them, and the heart that fed;
    And on the pedestal these words appear:
    “My name is Ozymandias, king of kings:
    Look on my works, ye Mighty, and despair!”
    Nothing beside remains. Round the decay
    Of that colossal wreck, boundless and bare
    The lone and level sands stretch far away.

  • Nobel

    12 February 2011 3:33AM

    As A Reporter, NBC Richard Engel is A Hero Now

    When NBC’s Richard Engel stands on the tank with the People power, I Knew he reached his career’s high point!
    Indeed, he shows his vision, determination, courage and his capacity to truly report what happens on the ground in Cairo!
    After the first day, he reported the People power, which generated by Facebook and Twitter; he knew the biggest event would come in Egypt! I am very glad that in the 18th day, he witnesses his life’s biggest moment as a reporter. And the most, he is one of them of the people power that toppled down the former President of Egypt, Mubarak!

    The biggest loser is CNN’s Anderson Cooper, he sacred and retreated too early to his safe heaven. No guts, no news! And most regrettable, he missed once lifetime of moment on the ground.

    The biggest outsider is Fox channel! I do not know why this Fox exists in America!

    The most rubbish is MSNBC’s Chris Matthews, he totally did not know what happens in Egypt. No clue! No point!

    The Johnny come lately is NYT’s Richard Cohen; I do know why he came to Egypt.

    The notable figure missing is Christiane Amanpour, After she “helps” Mubarak explain his position in interview, she missed at all.


    Richard Engel is Hero now!

  • TripleJarhead

    12 February 2011 7:17AM

    BadDog

    Which might possibly be because most of his photographs were taken when the protesters were confronting Mubarek's thugs and had moved their women to safety. He describes one of his photographs:

    Quite the opposite of Hamas then.

  • TripleJarhead

    12 February 2011 7:20AM

    Nobel

    The biggest outsider is Fox channel! I do not know why this Fox exists in America!

    That's simple. There are no longer any real NEWS channels/Media. All of them have an agenda. Americans go sick of listening to radical left drivel presented as 'News' and started watching radical right drivel as presented as news.

    It's as simple as that.

  • TripleJarhead

    12 February 2011 7:27AM

    SmokinGardener

    Ever since this story started, and the various pictures that have whirled around world, they all seem to have one thing in common. Men. However this revolution plays out (and others), I hope it does something positive for equality in the near future. I'm not very optimistic though.

    100% yes.

    I did hear on the BBC, a person presented as a demonstrator saying that it would be Egypt's own model of democracy. That worries me but if women have complete equality before the law and homosexuality is decriminalized, that will be a great step forward. And independent judiciary, free news services of all types and an armed services subservient to the government of the day would also be welcome.

    I do hope that they are not going for the Iranian 'model'.

  • CesPoole

    12 February 2011 7:42AM

    TripleJarhead

    I did hear on the BBC, a person presented as a demonstrator saying that it would be Egypt's own model of democracy.

    Part of the BBC's presentation is to pick and choose which 'interviews' are broadcast and it hardly presents a balanced picture of anything it reports on.

  • Gelatelli

    12 February 2011 10:35AM

    4.30 pm Friday was :- Mubarak has a miss guided sense of his own intellect. He has for 30 yrs got away with fiddling the books, sallied at the top table of despots, supped up the greasy pole of the Teflon kings. If G Bush actually got away with it, so can I. (Its a done deal Jeb, we've got pregnant chads) How fast history can change.

  • socialistMike

    12 February 2011 11:39AM

    Our right-wing friends would support the revolution, but, you see they are amazing feminists - we all know of the year's of activism and self-denial the right have put into womens' rights. It gets almost boring them demanding fairness and equality for women in the UK and all around the world.

    Such keen feminists that they simply cannot support getting rid of a murderous dictator who represses all equally without any gender bias - and that is what is important here for these feminist anti-revolutionaries.

  • socialistMike

    12 February 2011 11:42AM

    Americans go sick of listening to radical left drivel presented as 'News' and started watching radical right drivel as presented as news.

    No broadcaster in the USA has ever been a 'radical left' one. That's just a myth spread by the right to justify the fact of incredible rightwing bias.

    We get the same here in the UK, where the right controls perhaps 70% of the media. That media shouts with one voice 'the BBC is leftwing biased.'

    But these people are only about 30% of the population. They just think they are the only ones who should have a voice.

Comments on this page are now closed.

Comments

Sorry, commenting is not available at this time. Please try again later.