As I write this, there is still uncertainty about the source of the E. coli outbreak in Europe that has killed more than 20 people. But whatever the ultimate conclusion is regarding the delivery vehicle for this deadly bug, don't blame the sprouts.
Don't blame the beans, broccoli, peas, chickpeas, garlic, lentils, mung beans or radishes, either, although all of these crops are currently the focus of ongoing investigation. In fact, I encourage a "not guilty" verdict for the entire plant kingdom.
There is much we don't yet know about the current E. coli outbreak, but what we do know is scary. The bacterium is apparently new on the scene, never before having been isolated. In addition to obvious and lethal virulence, the bug carries with it a number of antibiotic-resistant genes, making it hard to kill. Good at killing while bad at being killed makes a pathogen very bad news indeed.
Since the source and origins of this organism are still matters of conjecture, how can we exonerate the plant foods on which it is currently hitching a ride? We can do it by learning from the follies of history.
After all, we have been here -- or in fixes much like this -- before. Among the better known of the dangerous E. coli variants is 0157H7. Like the current menace, E. coli 0157H7 is a recently emergent strain, disseminated as a hitchhiker on foodstuffs and capable of killing people. While E. coli 0157H7 has ridden leaves of lettuce and spinach into infamy, this is an enemy whose origins we have met, and we know they are all about meat, not vegetables. When it comes to public health mayhem from mutant germs, plants are innocent bystanders.
Because we eat quite a lot of meat, quite a lot of meat must be produced. Large-volume meat production means large farms, large herds, and large, centralized, highly efficient processing plants. At best, this all translates into relative neglect of any individual steer, and a relative inability to inspect the quality of every steak. At worst, it offers reminders of the "jungle" to which Upton Sinclair introduced us all at the turn of the 20th century.
And it means feed animals are raised as an industrial commodity, rather than as creatures. Their natural diets are disregarded, and they are fed whatever leads to the fastest growth and greatest profit. The origins of E. coli 0157H7 are not mysterious; they relate to changes in the feed of cattle. We say "you are what you eat," and since the construction materials for growing bodies come from food and nowhere else, it is literally true. It is just as true if you happen to have hooves.
Cattle eating grasses have a healthy gastrointestinal tract that is not conducive to the growth of this particular mutant germ. Cattle being fed grains instead of grasses -- and in many cases, ground-up bits of other animals including their own species -- develop abnormal conditions in their GI tract, such as a change in the pH level. It is this abnormal environment within cows that consume abnormal diets that gave us E. coli 0157H7. The jury is still out on the new E. coli variant, but precedent likely predicts the trial outcome for our current tribulations.
We -- and our resultant health -- not only are what we eat; we are to some extent what we feed what we eat.
Until quite recently, E. coli 0157H7 was the bad bug in town. Less than two years ago, in October 2009, the New York Times told us the gripping and heart-rending tale of how E. coli ravaged the health of a young woman named Stephanie Smith. The Times, focusing on modern food-processing methods, told how tens of thousands of cattle, millions of pounds of beef, hundreds of miles of transport and acres of food-processing plants all came together to produce the hamburger patty that destroyed this young woman's life. Ms. Smith developed an unusually dire case of E. coli 0157H7 infection after eating a contaminated, pre-packaged ground beef patty, prepared at home by her mother.
The Times did a fine job of highlighting the lapses and vulnerabilities in food processing and food inspection that account for food-borne illness in general, and the destruction of Ms. Smith's life in particular. But the Times limited its investigative assault to aspects of the food supply and its oversight. The true problem resides one layer deeper than that, in the food demand.
Go as far as that article went, and you will be left to believe we might have prevented new Stephanie Smith-like tragedies borne of new E. coli strains with higher standards of corporate responsibility and more vigilant inspection by federal authorities.
Go one step beyond, however, and you will see we need to rethink our food. As long as we indulge our appetites for so much meat, hamburgers will be dangerous to our own health as well as that of the planet. Into the bargain, they will challenge any semblance of morality by fostering, and apparently condoning, the brutal treatment of our fellow creatures that their large-scale consumption inevitably requires.
I am not intending to indict meat consumption; We as Homo sapiens have long, perhaps always, included some meat in our diet. But in a world of some 7 billion human beings and modern food-production methods, our dietary patterns reverberate in ways they never did before. In the end, we must concede it is an appetite for large quantities of meat derived from abused, drugged, mass-produced, mass-slaughtered cannibalistic cows that is responsible for E. coli 0157H7, mad cow disease and probably the new germ sailing on sprouts (or whatever) into unsuspecting households.
When you get to the meat of the matter, mutant germs in our food almost never have much to do with the innocently by-standing vegetables and fruits they tend to contaminate. They have everything to do with how we raise, and feed, the animals by which we feed ourselves. At least six good arguments for a greener diet have been made -- every super bug nurtured by modern animal husbandry adds another, as does the growing challenge of growing enough food for all concerned.
There is no doubt that opportunistic bacteria will continue to exploit the new environments we create by putting matter into the feed of cows, pigs and chickens that never belonged. Then when waste matter from those animals gets into fields of spinach, or sprouts, plants will be accomplices in the peril.
That's what's the matter. It's not about the sprouts.
Dr. David L. Katz; www.davidkatzmd.com
www.turnthetidefoundation.org
Follow David Katz, M.D. on Twitter: www.twitter.com/DrDavidKatz
Wendy Gordon: Healthy Animals Need Antibiotics: Baloney
David Wallinga, M.D.: Fueling Resistance: Rx. for Trouble
SkyNews E.Coli Compensation Raised to 210m Euros http://bit.ly/kRQPuK | ||
SPIEGEL_English Hunt for Deadly E. Coli Source: Fresh Clues Point to German Sprout Farm... http://tinyurl.com/6jjcc... | ||
greencelebrity
RT @DailyMeGreen Germany Faces Criticism Over Its Handling of Deadly E. Coli Outbreak http://sns.mx/RucRy1
4 hours ago from SNS Analytics
|
||
RFI_English
Euroean Union - Worst of E coli over, Germany says, as cases reported in France http://rfi.my/lHQf0w
6 hours ago from Rfi Update
|
||
SPIEGEL_English Berlin Blasted for E. Coli Crisis Management: EU Wants Germany to Seek International Help ... http://tinyurl.com/6bvf5... | ||
Revkin
Beyond Sprouts, The Roots of E. Coli Problem - http://nyti.ms/jDFxAc as per @bittman
7 hours ago from TimesPeople
|
||
PostWorldNews
German health minister says numbers of new E. coli cases are reducing http://wapo.st/lihdlD
8 hours ago from twitterfeed
|
||
RT_com
Numbers of new E.Coli cases reducing - German health minister #news
9 hours ago from web
|
||
LamiaHassan
Egypt reports its first suspected case of E. coli infection http://bit.ly/jr4jhn #Egypt #Ecoli #Germany #food #health
9 hours ago from web
|
||
globalasia
» Hong Kong alerta casos de infección E.coli, mientras que en China el riesgo al brote es bajo: http://t.co/mVEhpdR via @AddThis
9 hours ago from Tweet Button
|
||
greenmeme
NY Times: Germany Is Criticized Even as E. Coli Outbreak Slows http://nyti.ms/jgOPBL
11 hours ago from twitterfeed
|
||
nytimeshealth Germany Is Criticized Even as E. Coli Outbreak Slows http://nyti.ms/mjEf0W | ||
nytenvironment Germany Is Criticized Even as E. Coli Outbreak Slows http://nyti.ms/l5wzWG | ||
nytimeshealth Mark Bittman: E. Coli: Don't Blame the Sprouts! http://nyti.ms/lnsJkf | ||
NatureNews
RT @robinlloyd99: Good @NatureNews Euro map of people affected by new E. coli strain. Main point: Germany tops by far http://bit.ly/lziwVN
13 hours ago from TweetDeck
|
||
Climatechg
How to avoid E. coli, and a look back at recent outbreaks http://bit.ly/ki1ljz
14 hours ago from twitterfeed
|
||
nytimesbusiness Germany Faces Criticism Over E. Coli Outbreak http://nyti.ms/luJFmf | ||
MedicalNews
Salmonella Cases Up, E. Coli Down in U.S. http://bit.ly/iAUVw2
17 hours ago from twitterfeed
|
||
MedicalNews
Major E.coli outbreaks decline, salmonella up http://bit.ly/jZR3cv
17 hours ago from twitterfeed
|
||
Climatechg
E. coli symptoms: What to look for http://bit.ly/jAf54Z
18 hours ago from twitterfeed
|
||
E. coli Bacteria Infection Symptoms, Causes, Treatments
Germany Faces Criticism Over Handling of E.Coli Outbreak
E. Coli Deaths at 23 After Another Fatality as Source Eludes Investigators
Share your Comment:
Probably the most studied in this category are alfalfa sprouts. There are reports of animal and human consumptio
Here are a few links on the issue, in no particular order:
Dietary amino acid-induc
http://www
http://lup
Pathogenes
http://www
Effects of L-canavani
http://www
Two years ago, I spent 5 months reviewing the life cycle in a meat packing plant. I learned a few things while I was there:
These guys go to incredible lengths to give folks healthy, clean food.
We are the ONLY major country that does not screen every 'head' for mad cow.
While you can no longer feed 'cow meat' to cows, you CAN feed 'chicken/g
The only natural source for creatine - an important part of our skeletal muscle - can best be obtained through beef or fish. (The body can produce some on its own - but during the 'formative years' - beef and fish are best).
If you check out beef from most South American countries - their laws forbid most of our practices. Thus, a steer from there, after 3 years is only half the size of ours - and tastes a tad more gamey. (I had a large party and served a mixture of steaks from here and from there, purposely putting some of both on each plate. At the end, I asked anyone if they tasted the difference - and not one person did. So you have to wonder how much of the 'gamey' taste is psychologi
Nuff said.
You have to jump thru several hoops (8) to get to this point of being so resistant to a series of antibiotic
I'd like to see the source for this bit of info. Is there a study? Bacteria mutate all the time. How was the cause of mutation determined in this particular instance? I realize the author has exceedingl