Sign on Options
Theme:

Calendar of Events

  • Monday
    • DEC 13
    • Awards Begin Categories Revealed
  • Monday
    • DEC 20
    • Editors' Choice Awards Special Achievements
  • Tuesday Dec 21 - Dubious Honors
  • Wednesday Dec 22 - Genre Awards
  • Thursday Dec 23 - Platform Awards
  • Friday Dec 24 - Game of the Year
  • Monday
    • JAN 10
    • Readers' Choice Awards Voting Ends

About the Awards

GameSpot's Best of 2010 awards cover special achievements in the field of advancements for games, dubious honors for less-than-admirable qualities, and full awards for individual genres and every major platform. Nominations and awards are the result of rigorous debate among GameSpot's editors, who select up to five finalists and one winner for almost every category (the Game of the Year category includes up to 10 finalists). To qualify for an editorial award, games must have been reviewed by GameSpot between January 1, 2010, and November 30, 2010.

Award categories are intended to call out those games that truly deserve the attention--therefore, while each award is meaningful, it's considered an honor simply to be nominated.

Special Achievement

Best Story

Not all games have, or need, a great story. But there are plenty of games in a wide variety of genres that have a plot--and in rare cases, they have truly great stories. The Best Story award highlights the best story in any game released this year.

Watch the video below for more!

GameSpot's Best Games of 2010 Readers' Choice WinnerAnd the winner is…

Red Dead Redemption

Red Dead Redemption's story is a combination of excellent writing and superb characterization that make its protagonist John Marston relatable and sympathetic. And this great story makes his epic journey unforgettable.

Readers' Choice Voting

  • Winner
  • Results
And the winner is…

Mass Effect 2

GameSpot's Best Games of 2010 Readers' Choice Winner

The Mass Effect trilogy is an emotionally charged science fiction adventure set in a vast universe filled with dangerous alien life and mysterious, uncharted planets. In Mass Effect 2, players will once again step into the role of the heroic Commander Shepard, commanding their crew of some of the most dangerous operatives from across the galaxy on a mission so challenging that it's potentially suicidal. Featuring intense shooter action, a rich futuristic storyline, space exploration and emotionally engaging character interaction, the game delivers an unparalleled cinematic experience.

Title Vote Result Graph % of Votes # of Votes

Alan Wake

 
8% 3,764

Enslaved: Odyssey to the West

 
2% 1,076

Heavy Rain

 
21% 9,329

Mass Effect 2

 
38% 16,814

Red Dead Redemption

 
20% 8,950

Amnesia: The Dark Descent

 
2% 835

BioShock 2

 
3% 1,371

Deadly Premonition

 
1% 372

Mafia II

 
3% 1,180

Silent Hill: Shattered Memories

 
1% 625

675 Comments

  • AvatarMan96

    Posted Apr 2, 2011 5:50 pm PT

    RDR!

  • Xeuton_Mojukai

    Posted Jan 20, 2011 10:30 pm PT

    The only game that I didn't play out of the top five was Enslaved. So I'll talk about the other four.

    Alan Wake's story was intelligent, gripping, scary, and at one special point, hysterically funny and undeniably awesome.

    Heavy Rain's story was also intelligent, also gripping, also scary, and additionally had twists, a beautifully intricate mystery, replayability, and perfect music.

    Mass Effect 2's story was fun, cool, exciting, interesting, and full of hilarious, badass, and extremely good voice acting.

    Red Dead Redemption's story was perfect for me. As perfect as could be with the story it was trying to tell. I couldn't find any plot holes, nor could I find any places where the storyline felt weak. Every character was important, every chance encounter felt like a genuine moment of decision. I will remember all these games, but Red Dead Redemption was my favorite.

    I end by saying this is all my opinion. Whether you agree is immaterial, what matters is that all four of these games were winners in their own right, and deserve to be bought, played, and enjoyed.

    I hope to get the same experience from Enslaved.

  • mohsenkeshavarz

    Posted Jan 19, 2011 10:03 am PT

    The story was just perfect.

  • Noctisversus

    Posted Jan 17, 2011 2:03 pm PT

    Definitely has to be mass effect... just has to be....

  • 00-Riddick-00

    Posted Jan 16, 2011 5:41 pm PT

    Alan wake

  • Devvy01

    Posted Jan 16, 2011 4:05 pm PT

    ME2 was the best story for the PC, since RDR didnt make it to the PC, it's abit hard to judge for yourself

  • Alexrmf

    Posted Jan 16, 2011 2:02 pm PT

    at least the readers got it straight way to go Bioware... looking forward to DA2 and ME3. keep it up

  • Gamer_4_Fun

    Posted Jan 16, 2011 1:34 am PT

    @Armarganth : *** is wrong with you? Clearly alot, stop complaining and get!

  • AccOfTheLost

    Posted Jan 16, 2011 1:04 am PT

    so RDR had best story ?

    nice

  • Amarganth posted Jan 15, 2011 3:55 pm PT (does not meet display criteria. sign in to show)

    Amarganth

    Posted Jan 15, 2011 3:55 pm PT (hide)

    Way to go Gamespot; most of your fanboyish idiots of readers were able to make a better choice than you did. Although ME2 is a bit overly superficial as opposed to Amnesia (the only game in the list worthy of winning), Rockstar Crap Redemptation has as much of a story as Bad Company 2 has...but hey, who am I kidding? You gave GTA4 more than a 2 so you know as much about games as a virgin knows about sex.

  • lsw3638

    Posted Jan 15, 2011 2:02 pm PT

    I personally really enjoyed playing ME2 and its presentation was amazing, but its storyline is somewhat plain and little too predictable (not much twist or surprises) to be the best pick for story award.

    Even if it's inevitable for most RPG stories to be predictable, ME2 story seems to lack details to enrich story,

    My guess is dev team streamlined its story, too. Giving up good part of good story substances just like other RPG elements...

  • Jaydog19833

    Posted Jan 15, 2011 12:17 pm PT

    I'm really surprised Mafia 2 got nothing. I loved Mass Effect and Red Dead but I really think Mafia should have won this.

  • DawnForMe

    Posted Jan 15, 2011 8:30 am PT

    Thats the right winner !!

  • Mikethechimp

    Posted Jan 14, 2011 11:59 pm PT

    Red Dead Redemption? Best story? It's just a consistent tease that lasts 50 hours until you reach a lousy anticlimax. And the bonus ending is just pathetic.

  • TurambarGS

    Posted Jan 14, 2011 9:20 pm PT

    Nice. I thought for the middle instalment in a trilogy ME2 had a great story and really set up Mass Effect for an epic conclusion. RDR's wasn't bad but I think the high quality of Marston's character distracted me from the really quite simple story.

  • olgert56

    Posted Jan 14, 2011 9:07 pm PT

    Wow, even gamers themselves can't choose the game with the best story by voting...once again, popularity contest.

  • ShadowofSonic

    Posted Jan 14, 2011 5:23 pm PT

    tsk,tsk

  • Pickleking23

    Posted Jan 14, 2011 3:45 pm PT

    I thought Heavy Rain was better but ME2 is still a worthy winner.

  • Lord_Nas3k

    Posted Jan 14, 2011 3:40 pm PT

    Mass Effect 2's story was actually pretty terrible, but it was told well.