October 18, 2011 5:38 PM

Pediatricians call TV big no-no for kids under two

By
David W Freeman
Topics
News ,
Mental Health
(CBS) TV for kids under age two is a big no-no. So says the nation's largest pediatricians group, which on Tuesday issued a new policy statement saying there's no evidence that toddlers benefit from television and some evidence suggesting that it interferes with normal development.

PICTURES - Oops! 8 ways parents make kids fat 

The statement - which reaffirms a similar one issued by the academy in 1999 - says that 90 percent of parents permit their children under age two to watch TV or other electronic media  - even though research suggests that kids that young are incapable of following sequential screen shots or dialog. By age three, almost one in three children have a TV in their bedroom.

"Clearly, no one is listening to this message," Dr. Ari Brown, a pediatrician in Austin, Texas, told the New York Times. "In this ubiquitous screen world, I think we need to find a way to manage it and make it a healthy media diet."

Media diet? Some parents of toddlers seem almost to be force-feeding electronic media. Fourteen percent of children 6 to 23 months of age watch media at least two hours a day, according to the statement.

In addition to parents who use TV as a sort of electronic babysitter while they're otherwise occupied, many parents say they're convinced that educational programming is "very important for healthy development."

Those parents are dead-wrong, the statement says. Studies have tied toddlers' TV viewing to language delays, though there's no proof that the viewing actually causes the delays.

Instead of parking kids in front of the TV, the academy urges parents to give kids "unstructured, unplugged play" that encourages them to think creatively, solve problems, and hone their reasoning and motor skills.

As Dr. Brown put it in a written statement, "Children need this in order to figure out how the world works."

9 Photos

Oops! 8 ways parents make kids fat

View the Full Gallery »


Add a Comment
by pdhgal October 19, 2011 9:09 AM EDT
I am raising my now 3 year old grandson and he is well rounded we watch and have watched since he was about 6 months old many educational television programs such as Word World, Super Why, Sesame Street, Wild Katts and others. This began as a visual stimulation movement and color and evolved into learning. We have also watched many Brainy Baby DVD's and Baby Einstein. I can go out with my grandson and he reads simple signs such as open, closed and stop. We do not have any video games or battery operated vehicles that he can ride. I feel that he is very well rounded in his development and television has had its place in his development.
Reply to this comment
by PourpaixPourpaix October 18, 2011 8:19 PM EDT
Exactly what in the world is "unstructured, unplugged play" to a one year old? A bunch of blocks to give the little darling something to gnaw on?
Reply to this comment
by tmonta67 October 19, 2011 12:51 AM EDT
Exactly. As a mom and a pediatric nurse, same reply as below: kids go through stages of development brought on by playing alone and in groups and by learning in their environment, through trial and error and yes, even through boredom and frustration because these encourage coping skills-- not by staring fixed at a colorful screen they can't understand and drooling on themselves.

I used TV selectively with my three kids and yes, it allowed me to go take a shower at times, but my brother and sister in law plopped their twins in their seats from birth in front of a TV, they even slept in front of it. Today, at 10, one has ADD and the other is autistic. There may be no connection, but at the very least TV sure didn't help them.
by cameraphone October 18, 2011 7:25 PM EDT
I just got a tweet from a 1 year old saying that no TV infringes on his rights as an American.
Reply to this comment
by tsigili October 18, 2011 7:10 PM EDT
TV dumbs down all of us.......partly because we spend more time watching commercials, than programs.
Reply to this comment
by 924s29j October 18, 2011 6:52 PM EDT
my kids watched tv all their lives.they turned out just fine.let kids be kids.she dont have a clue what shes talking about.liberal.thats what they do.cause problems
Reply to this comment
by tmonta67 October 19, 2011 12:27 AM EDT
Everything has to have a political connection for some people, but had to chuckle at this one. Statements like "let kids be kids" sounds to me like the definition of a liberal mindset independent of any political innuendo.

But if kids were to truly "be kids", they'd go through stages of development brought on by playing alone and in groups and by learning in their environment, through trial and error and yes, even through boredom and frustration because these encourage coping skills-- not by staring fixed at a colorful screen they can't understand and drooling on themselves.

I used TV selectively with my three kids and yes, it allowed me to go take a shower at times, but my brother and sister in law plopped their twins in their seats from birth in front of a TV, they even slept in front of it. Today, at 10, one is hyperactive and the other is autistic. There may be no connection, but at the very least TV sure didn't help them.
by alank4440 October 18, 2011 6:16 PM EDT
bull they should watch tv even xxx channels as well get them on the right track .
Reply to this comment
.

Follow HealthPop

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
Better Information. Better Health.
CBS News on Facebook