April 20, 2011 1:08 PM

Life-size Barbie's shocking dimensions (PHOTO): Would she be anorexic?

By
Neil Katz
Topics
Diet ,
Mental Health

Galia Slayen stands with her life-sized Barbie

Galia Slayen stands with her life-size Barbie, which would be 5'9", weigh 110 pounds, and have a BMI associated with anorexia.

(Credit: Galia Slayen)

(CBS) For generations of young women, Barbie has been larger than life. But when Galia Slayen, a Hamilton College student who once battled an eating disorder, tried to make an actual life-size Barbie, she was shocked at the result - a freakish woman with pencil-thin legs, breasts that threatened to topple her over, and a body mass index (BMI) that would put her squarely in the anorexia camp.

"If Barbie were an actual woman, she would be 5'9" tall, have a 39" bust, an 18" waist, 33" hips and a size 3 shoe," Slayen wrote in the Huffington Post. "She likely would not menstruate... she'd have to walk on all fours due to her proportions."

Slayen estimates Barbie would weigh 110 pounds and have a BMI of 16.24. She based her numbers on the book "Body Wars" by Dr. Margo Maine, and readily admits the doll's head, hands and some other features are not to scale.

"The goal of Barbie is to get just get people's attention," Slayen told CBS News. Eating disorders are "very prevalent and not talked about. It's sensationalized in the media every time a star loses weight, but this is a very internal struggle."

Slayen's own struggle started when she was 15 in Portland, Ore. She battled pressures at school to look and act a certain way and her relationship with her parents was so troubled that she obtained legal separation (emancipation) from them.

"I was living on my own and trying to figure out how I was going to survive," she said. "My life was completely out of control and it was the one thing I was able to control - the hours at the gym, the calories I was in-taking. It's a means to control your life."

"This is a young woman who has fought through this disorder and now has a voice to fight for other women," says Marisa Sherry, a registered dietitian in New York who specializes in eating disorders. 

Sherry says the proportions of Slayen's life-size Barbie are cause for concern.

"A BMI of under 17 is considered underweight or anorexic," she tells CBS News. "That puts you at high risk for negative side effects like osteoporosis, amenorrhea (not being able to menstruate) and low heart rate."

As many as 10 million Americans are now struggling with eating disorders like anorexia and bulimia, according to the National Eating Disorder Association. A recent study found that teens are hit hard - as many as 500,000 have had an eating disorder. People with eating disorders are at high risk for depression, suicide and substance abuse. The condition can lead to sudden death.

"There are so many misconceptions," says Slayen. "Eating disorders are are not a choice. They are not a thing of vanity. They are disease and they are really serious."

Slayen says she's not mad at Barbie, which she played with as a child, but wasn't "obsessed" over. She says she first built the life-size Barbie as part of National Eating Disorder Awareness Week when she was in high school and is now showing her off at college where she is studying China and government. Slays says she recently raised more than $10,000 for the cause and wants insurance companies and the federal government to take notice.

"A lot of insurance companies don't cover eating disorders," she says. "They don't see this is not a choice."


Add a Comment See all 15 Comments
by Ragnar18 October 1, 2011 7:54 PM EDT
One wonders how much money could be saved if those programs that were highly redundant or ineffective in the cost effect analysis in decreasing eating disorders versus physical labor, such as that occuring on the often maligned family farm, were discontinued and that the resulting reduction in taxation was not used elsewhere but returned to those who had earned it, and could be used for the maintenance of secondary rural residences potentially involving agricultural actvities.
The great "strong people" of old all shared a background that involved manual labor. But the greatest cost today facing those people who wish to maintain their family farm, or those who wish to obtain one is actually gang harassment that is often well designed and motivated or fueled by elements of sexual harassment.
Talking about Barbie's big **** may seem funny to some, except that she is a doll, and for those who have listened to women hurt by the negative comments directed at their breast size, it is no laughing matter. There is a tremendous amount of evidence showing that breast reductions are always harmful, and that people need to be capable of loving who they are, and that large breasts are never, and never have been an invitation to ogle, or comment. It is social values that should change, and the absence of moral Christian living should be aknowledged as our society's current deficit.
My personal belief is that Hamilton college should remember its core mission to be
an elite but accessible member of the Conservative academic community. The kind of place that Alexander Hamilton with his wanton background could only have dreamed of attending, or to decide to change it's name.

Ragnar Anderssen, Iceland
Reply to this comment
by SChances September 23, 2011 3:43 AM EDT
Barbie's measurements
With regard to the ongoing claims that Barbie Dolls have outrageously unrealistic proportions that could never be obtained by a living human, I am continuing to get discrepancies between my measurements of a Barbie Doll and the measurements claimed by others including those who are taking their own measurements, so I have decided to do new measurements for which I will document my methodology for taking the measurements and the exact design year and model of the Barbie I am measuring. The claim of a 39 inch bust is not true although it is constantly repeated without being checked.
Barbie's REAL measurements can be found on my site at http://www.toyboxbitch.com/files/PAGES/BARBIESIZE/BARBIESIZE.html

or
http://www.squidoo.com/the-truth-at-last-the-real-measurements-and-proportions-of-a-modern-barbie-doll
Reply to this comment
by Puhgete April 26, 2011 12:48 PM EDT
This should make it easier to see how bad her life sized Barbie is: http://i53.tinypic.com/24q49d0.png
Reply to this comment
by discopete1 April 26, 2011 8:40 AM EDT
Hold your hand over the college student. Does that look like the Barbie you know? Not at all! If it is appropriately to scale, then it should look just like Barbie.

I don't know what Galia is studying in college, but I'll trust Barbie with my bridge building.
Reply to this comment
by JeniferBecker April 21, 2011 8:38 PM EDT
Interesting. I applaud this young girl for her efforts, I really do, but alas--there are problems. I do not know who is more confused this poor girl or the individual writing this story. I agree with a previous comment that this is an article without a clearly defined thesis. Really CBS...

I have been a therapist for many years and have treated over 60 cases of eating disorders. In all that time, I was never led to believe or perceived that a single patient out of the sixty cases had developed anorexia from societal pressures to be thin. This myth is debunked by nearly every single patient on their first visit. Anorexia is a deeply rooted behavioral problem that is no more caused by pressures to be thin than panic disorder is caused by a bad economy. Most any expert worth their weight will tell you this. Still the media beats this same dead horse over and over again. Now even Barbie is suspect.

In the vast majority of cases the major 'trigger' I have found is the girl's relationship with her mother. Often a physical absence or distance from the mother seems to spark an episode or intensify a preexisting condition. This of course is not always the trigger, but certainly more accurate and specific than viewing a plastic doll out of proportion. I think it is fair to say that the answers to her questions concerning this disorder are in the beginning of the story itself, and I quote, "her parents was so troubled that she obtained legal separation (emancipation) from them." No fault to her, it takes many years to correctly sort out the traumatic childhoods many of us have endured. If you still feel compelled to dig deeper into the abstractions of dolls and such for symbolic meanings, I would recommend the avant-garde perspective on anorexia nervosa given by Douglas Arone in his 2006 book The Theorem.
Reply to this comment
by bobnjersey April 21, 2011 1:35 PM EDT
[Slayen estimates Barbie would weigh 110 pounds and have a BMI of 16.24. She based her numbers on the book "Body Wars" by Dr. Margo Maine, and readily admits the doll's head, hands and some other features are not to scale.]
---------------------------------------------
then it's not life size ... it's a deliberate distortion to make a point about eating disorders. where's the distorted doll that shows freakishly large proportions to highlight the near epidemic of obesity?
Reply to this comment
by Harden_Tar April 22, 2011 10:11 AM EDT
Agree, there is definitely an agenda here. Barbie needs to be lifesize in all regards, not just her boobs.
by trollololol April 21, 2011 11:38 AM EDT
Does it say how she extrapolated Barbie's measurements? You can't just multiply the same factor by every dimension... height doesn't scale at the same rate as width, heads don't scale at the same rate as hips, etc. Imagine how a grown adults would look if you just enlarged a toddler to full size? Imagine how terrifying toddlers would be if you just shrunk a grown person down?

The article has a confused thesis. It opens with the premise that Barbie is unreasonably proportioned, and then goes on about how anorexia is about exercising control in those who feel they can't otherwise control their lives. The main concern seems to be that health insurance doesn't cover eating disorders. This is sad, and true. Why lose such a brilliant point with all the extraneous showmanship?

And it's not just eating disorders. The vast majority of health insurance doesn't give due attention to psychological health. This is something that really ought to be discussed more, and here you let it fall by the wayside in favor of sensationalism.
Reply to this comment
by documemts April 20, 2011 5:58 PM EDT
Well, what did you expect from a blond doll mascot of West German truckers, Reality?
Reply to this comment
by dogsoul April 20, 2011 4:57 PM EDT
I'm guessing a life sized G.I. Joe might look a little something like Shaq or LeBron - so what... the goal in monopoly was to end up rich as can be.... oh no, I'm not super rich! Superman could fly... what AM I going to DO with myself! Here's a clue... find women who by some miracle don't feel they need to look like Barbie in order to go on with life - and figure out why they seem to able to cope where others can't. It's not men, not toys, not the fashion industry or Sarah Palin folks... it's some deeper issue in some women that causes them to feel so inadequate - because, let's face it - if you're in reasonable shape (and even THAT's iffy) & have somewhat of a halfway decent personality (again, iffy) - you can find somebody who likes you.
Reply to this comment
by maypo April 20, 2011 4:30 PM EDT
Sort of reminds me of a tall Dolly Parton. She walks very well.
Reply to this comment
See all 15 Comments
.

Follow HealthPop

Scroll Left
Scroll Right More »
Better Information. Better Health.
CBS News on Facebook