Question of the Day: Trinity's Very Own Pirate?

Dear Archivist,
I am a descendant of Captain William Kidd (1645-1701) who was active in the building of Trinity Church before he became a pirate! I understand there is a plaque to his memory in the churchyard. Do you have a reference to this? We were frequent visitors to the church when we lived in NY, but were unaware of this possibility until now.
-John and Anne

Dear John and Anne,
There is no plaque commemorating Captain Kidd in our churchyard. In our Vestry Meeting Minutes from January 6, 1982, it is noted in the Rector's report that:

"Captain Kidd, the infamous pirate who died on the gallows, was never a Vestryman of Trinity Parish in spite of the claim made by "Ripley's Believe It or Not." He was on the pew list of 1696 and lent equipment for raising stones of the first Trinity Church. Since Captain Kidd left New York in September of 1696, two years before Trinity held its first service, he never worshipped in the church."

The associations noted in this resolution are the only ones Trinity has with Captain Kidd, and are the only record of his involvement with Trinity.

--The Archivist

Posted November 19, 2008

Comments

1

Dear Archivist, I teach a class on maritime piracy at the University of Connecticut. One of my students heard a rumor that Captain Kidd's name is still on Pew #16. In the 20th century a historian found the documents in London's Public Record Office that gave Kidd his vindication. Did Anglicans stand behind him? Cordially, Dr. Park http://www.newsday.com/community/guide/lihistory/ny-hs324,0,7442594.story

Steven Park on April 17, 2009

Share Your Comments Below:




Trinity Wall Street welcomes discussion in good faith, but does reserve the right to remove user-submitted content from this website, including material that is offensive, malicious, inappropriate, unattributed or misleadingly attributed.

The Archivist

Author: The Archivist
Created: March 18, 2009

Trinity Wall Street has played a pivotal role in the religious and civic life of the city and nation since its founding in 1697. This blog will answer readers’ questions and provide a glimpse into the fascinating and provocative history of the parish.

Contact The Archivist

Trinity Wall Street | for a world of good