EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

David A. Love

GET UPDATES FROM David A. Love
 

China and the U.S.: World Leaders in Executions

Posted: 12/22/11 03:59 PM ET

They say you're judged by the company you keep. And the countries that execute the most people are members of quite a club.

According to Amnesty International, two-thirds of the nations of the world have abolished the death penalty, including 30 countries over the past decade. Only 21 of the 192 UN member nations carried out executions last year. China was the world leader with likely thousands of executions a year.

Following China were Iran, North Korea, and Yemen, with the U.S. in fifth place. Trailing the U.S. were Saudi Arabia, Libya and Syria.

As the world trends toward abolition of the death penalty, so too is the U.S. losing some of its appetite for executions. As the Death Penalty Information Center announced in its year-end report, 2011 was the first year since 1976 -- when capital punishment was reinstated in the U.S. -- that fewer than 100 death sentences were produced in one year.

But let's not be mistaken. The death penalty, though on the decline, is still widely practiced in America, and it still is the law in 34 states.

State-sponsored executions represent the ultimate violation of human rights, and it is shameful that the U.S. is one of the world's most willing and enthusiastic executioners. China, which makes no pretenses regarding human rights, executes thousands of people a year because life is cheap in that authoritarian, hyper-capitalist state. Mass forced evictions and demolitions are commonplace for the sake of urban development, whether to make way for the Olympics, the Asian Games, a shoddy high-speed rail project, or Disneyland.

When Wang Yue, a two-year-old girl was left to die by two hit-and-run van drivers and 18 passers-by, people in China blamed a Nanjing judge for creating a climate of apathy. In 2006, the judge forced a Good Samaritan -- a young man who helped an elderly woman who had fallen in the street -- to pay her hospital expenses. The judge's rationale was that "common sense" dictated that the young man took the woman to the hospital because he was guilty.

In China, with the world's most voracious appetite for executions, 55 crimes (down from 68) are capital offenses, including nonviolent crimes such as government corruption for a relative few unlucky scapegoats, and drug smuggling. It is an arbitrary system in which political maneuvering, the absence of an independent judiciary and perhaps even public pressure play a role in who is executed.

But at least the U.S. isn't China, right? Maybe not.

In the land of the free, capital punishment remains the tip of the iceberg in a society that often disregards human dignity and human rights. Nearly one in two Americans is poor or low income, and America has the highest level of economic inequality of the advanced nations. We stand alone in our lack of a national healthcare system. Our lawmakers, legally bribed by corporations, deny climate change for the sake of profit, and squeeze working people as they reward the rich.

Executions are merely the most violent manifestation of this inequity and injustice in the land, a failure to come to terms with bad habits and the demons of an American past that continue to torment us today. In 2011, three-quarters of the executions in the U.S. took place in the South. The lion's share of executions have taken place in the former Confederacy, with its long history of racial violence and segregation, and dehumanization born out of a legacy of slavery.

The U.S. death penalty discriminates against the poor and uneducated, racial minorities and those who cannot afford adequate legal representation. And a small number of counties are responsible for seeking most of the country's death penalty prosecutions and convictions.

Meanwhile, as America touts its human rights record, it is hard to preach to others, especially China, as it continues to execute its citizens. The death penalty remains America's moral blind spot. It will take a movement, not to mention Europe cutting off America's supply of lethal injection drugs, to turn things around.

David A. Love is the Executive Director of Witness to Innocence, a national nonprofit organization that empowers exonerated death row prisoners and their family members to become effective leaders in the movement to abolish the death penalty.

 

Follow David A. Love on Twitter: www.twitter.com/davidalove

 
  • Comments
  • 9
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
05:12 PM on 12/23/2011
I have been having this conversati­on with a co worker for the past couple of months. He keeps trying to give me different situations­. But at the end of the day No One Should Play God!! There are way too many cases coming up know thanks to DNA and other advances in CSI that are being overturned­. Not including ppl who where forced to confess in the time before video interviews­. If it's meant to be God will take care of it. Well Him or my buddy Karma.
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
niumarmion
a temporary being
10:03 AM on 12/23/2011
Capital punishment is a tool used assert the supremacy of the state over the individual­.
09:50 AM on 12/23/2011
Capital punishment is the modern day example of lynching.
----------­----------­----------­----------­----------­----------­----------­------

AGAINST THE AMERICAN SYSTEM OF CAPITAL PUNISHMENT

By Jack Greenberg

"...realit­y of American capital punishment is quite to the contrary. Since at least 1967, the death penalty has been inflicted only rarely, erraticall­y, and often upon the least odious killers, while many of the most heinous criminals have escaped execution. Moreover, it has been employed almost exclusivel­y in a few formerly slave-hold­ing states, and there it has been used almost exclusivel­y against killers of whites, not blacks, and never against white killers of blacks. This is the American system of capital punishment­. It is this system, not some idealized one, that must be defended in any national debate on the death penalty. I submit that this system is deeply incompatib­le with the proclaimed objectives of death penalty proponents­."

http://www­.pbs.org/w­gbh/pages/­frontline/­angel/proc­on/greenbe­rgarticle.­html
11:05 AM on 12/23/2011
Ok, so if we equalize it does that make the death penalty all of a sudden ok?
Racism is a big problem in American society, but that's not why the death penalty is wrong.
02:02 AM on 12/23/2011
The death penalty is not just a moral outrage. It is an economic nightmare which can beggar a county when it is called for. Besides the nightmare of executing innocent people, it actually increases the murder rate where it exists. Governor Perry of Texas and Dubya were happy to have signed so many many men and women to their deaths. The qulity of mercy was strained to the breaking point with them.

Beyond executions­, America can boast of having the largest prison population of any country in the world. It is beggaring America to be paying to kep more people in jail than any other country in the world including China.

None of it makes sense when one considers the power of the Christian evangelica­ls and fundamenta­lists. They seem to care nothing for what Christ said re mercy and giving to the poor. In fact, they seem ruthless. China, the Saudis and other countries seem models of rectitude compared to America. Their determinat­ion to favor the rich and punish the poor will destroy America.
01:11 AM on 12/23/2011
There IS no comparison­. According to Dui Hua (San Francisco?­), an anti-China entity in America, the Chicoms executed 4,000 in 2010.

When the number of killings is known (30,000 a year, reported by the CDC every year), and not only did the government not do anything about it, the several arms of the government actually worked to EXPAND the right to allow this travesty - the Supreme Court finds more rights for people to have guns, making it easier to do more of same; Congress either refuses to act or is going to expand "gun rights".

"GUN RIGHTS"? How about the rights of those 30,000 a year to LIVE?

Yes, the pigheaded (moi) is totally puzzled.

In the 33 years during which China's government lifted over 300,000,00­0 out of poverty, this fundamenta­l insanity executed a million (almost all of them innocent) in America.

4,000 executed, out of a population of 1.3 billion, for deterrence of crime, and done only after due process of law. Compared to 30,000 shot and killed, out of 300,000,00­0, most the killed died for no reason but the bloodthirs­t celebrated­. That is about 30 times higher per capita.
TomMartin
Freedom and equality.
12:57 AM on 12/23/2011
It is not really known how many executions are there really in North Korea. We can't expect them to tell the truth, they have been lying about so many things.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
David A. Love
Executive Director, Witness to Innocence
08:38 PM on 12/22/2011
Sad but true...
06:21 PM on 12/22/2011
The death penalty remains America's moral blind spot.
----------­----------­----------
Your article describes many blind spots associated poverty and inequity.