EDITION: U.S.
 
CONNECT    

Carina Kamel

GET UPDATES FROM Carina Kamel
 

Christmas in Cairo: Is There a Place for Non-Muslims and Liberals in the New Egypt?

Posted: 1/9/12 03:34 PM ET

This time last year Egypt was reeling from the shock of a huge explosion. Less than four weeks before the first protesters headed to Tahrir Square, a bomb went off on New Year's Eve in front of a church in the second-largest city of Alexandria killing more than 20 worshipers as they attended midnight mass. To date nobody has been prosecuted.

This may not have been the Bouazizi-type spark that set off the Egyptian revolution, but for members of Egypt's Coptic Christian minority it was a clarion call. The attack came one week before Coptic Christmas which is held on January 7th in adherence with the Coptic calendar. It's a day celebrated by the millions of Copts who form 10% of the population according to government data, although a recent study by the Coptic News Agency puts the figure closer to 20%.

I remember being in Cairo days after the attack and was struck by the scenes on Christmas Eve last year. Churches were barricaded by metal barriers, armed police guarded Church corners and metal detectors screened worshippers as they entered.

This Christmas I was back in Cairo and it appears as though both everything has changed and nothing has changed. Hosni Mubarak has stepped down and faces trial, the first post-revolution elections are complete, and a new Islamist-led parliament is taking shape. And yet, the country is run by generals of the Supreme Council of the Armed Forces or SCAF who served under Mubarak and have yet to transition to civilian rule, criticism of those in power is punishable by imprisonment or worse, violence is used against protestors and women and attacks against Copts continue.

Perhaps one of the biggest changes this Christmas was that the perceived threat of Islamism shared by liberals and Christians is now all the more real as the once-banned Muslim Brotherhood are poised to control parliament.

This makes secular parties, liberal groups, activists and Christians very nervous. They are concerned about religious intrusion in private life and restrictions on civil liberties. Already, there have been local media reports of a self-appointed "religious police" barging into places like ladies' hairdressers and ordering patrons to cease what they describe as un-Islamic practices like getting a blow dry. That incident didn't go down well with Egypt's well groomed women, who, according to reports, beat up the extremists and kicked them out of the beauty parlor.

Copts are also worried about their rights under Islamic Sharia law. And although the Muslim Brotherhood contend Sharia law is the best guarantor of Copts' rights, over the years, discrimination against Copts has continued.

This isn't just about discrimination when it comes to jobs or government posts. It's about laws preventing building churches or repairing them. It's about angry mobs storming churches and burning them down. It's about attacks against Christians going unpunished. It's about homes and businesses being looted and set on fire and families being driven from their villages. Which is why, many Copts think: if things are this bad now, won't they get worse with Islamists running the country?

It's no wonder then that, according to Coptic NGO, the Egyptian Federation of Human Rights, more than 100,000 Copts have left Egypt since March. Naguib Gabriel, head of the NGO, told me Coptic emigration since the revolution is specific in its nature. "It's different from past emigration when Christians left to get degrees or training abroad," he explained. "This has the mark of asylum from religious persecution."

Just to be clear, nobody is suggesting that the Muslim Brotherhood or the ultra-conservative Salafis are behind the attacks. The Brotherhood condemn violence against Copts and their political party even has some Christian members.

But to date, nobody has been held responsible for the Alexandria bombing, the death of Christian protestors in October or the many sectarian eruptions in villages up and down the Nile valley this past year.

There have been glimmers of hope. In Tahrir, protestors often hold up the crescent and the cross chanting "Muslim, Christian, one hand."

Copts and liberals alike are also worried about the effect of Islamist rule on tourism, the top foreign currency earner. The tourism minister warned against "irresponsible statements" by Islamists suggesting to ban alcohol, mixed beaches and bikinis in Egypt's popular resorts.

For its part, the Freedom and Justice Party, the political arm of the Muslim Brotherhood, blames the media for creating a sense of fear and confirmed in a TV interview that tourism is a priority. They also say they want to safeguard the rights of all Egyptians.

Bikinis or burkas, Egyptians are lurching towards democracy and like it or not, the future of the country is being shaped in the context of a wave of Islamism sweeping across the region.

Many of the January 25th activists maintain that democracy is still a distant goal and point to recent events including the storming of democracy NGOs and brutality against female protestors as evidence that Egypt is far from democratic.

So far SCAF's governing has been inconsistent: one minute praising the revolution and the next turning around and unleashing the full force of their troops on demonstrators. It has left people here in Egypt bewildered. Is SCAF changing course so often and so abruptly because it's not accustomed to governing or is it deliberately behaving erratically?

That's just one of many unanswered questions:

    If the revolution was fought for freedom, equality and justice, will all Egyptians -- Muslim and Christian alike -- get to enjoy that?If the Egyptian people voted in their millions for the Islamist parties, then don't those groups have the right to play a role in governing?Are minorities like Copts and liberals justified in fearing they don't have a place in the new Egypt?

This Christmas Eve, metal detectors were still at church gates and the army helped secure churches but the mood was less somber, you could even say it's festive. In the suburb of Heliopolis, Amr Hamzawy, newly elected liberal member of parliament, received a rock star's welcome at a church service.

But the all-star line up was at St Mark's cathedral where Coptic Pope Shenouda held midnight mass. Senior army generals, sheiks, Muslim Brotherhood leaders, presidential hopefuls and ministers past and present all attended the Pope's address, broadcast live on state TV.

Striking a hopeful note, the Pope reached out to Islamists, saying it was the first time in history representatives of all of Egypt's Islamist groups attended mass and called on them to work together with Copts. The Pope also appeared conciliatory towards the military and after his address a bevy of generals ascended the altar and embraced him.

The message this Christmas was clear: Muslim and Christian are one hand, as the chant goes. And as one priest put it: "We're all in the same boat. Sink or swim, we're in it together."

 

Follow Carina Kamel on Twitter: www.twitter.com/carina_bn

This time last year Egypt was reeling from the shock of a huge explosion. Less than four weeks before the first protesters headed to Tahrir Square, a bomb went off on New Year's Eve in front of a chur...
This time last year Egypt was reeling from the shock of a huge explosion. Less than four weeks before the first protesters headed to Tahrir Square, a bomb went off on New Year's Eve in front of a chur...
 
  • Comments
  • 15
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
ChiProgressive
01:18 PM on 01/22/2012
Christmas in Cairo: Is There a Place for Non-Muslim­s and Liberals in the New Egypt?

Not if the Salafis can help if it and the "moderates­" stand idly by.
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Randolph Greer
I am a Poet .
08:59 AM on 01/11/2012
Freedom is not something the rest of humanity will grant you if they can help it. Freedom is something you have to demand as your "RIGHT." Just keep demanding it and never stop. Even for one minute. If they object, tell them you will stop fighting for it whenever you get it. Not one minute before. Sooner or later, depending on the degree of wisdom possessed by those you are fighting, you will WIN IT.
01:30 PM on 01/10/2012
It's not only the Copts that are being targeted:

"Muslim Brotherhoo­d members... were at al-Azhar Mosque in Cairo on 25 November calling for genocide against Jews. The call came in the form of a recitation of an authentic hadith... The occasion was the commemorat­ion of what the Internatio­nal Union of Muslim Scholars named "Save al-Aqsa Friday"

Abd al-Rahman al-Barr, a member of the Muslim Brotherhoo­d Guidance Bureau:
“We must prepare the generation­s for the hour of jihad and conflict, which is not far off. The leaders of the Zionists said they are expecting a coming war. But I say you can even be certain of it, for the Prophet (PBUH) told us, "Fight against the Jews until a Jew will hide behind the rocks and the trees, and the rocks and the trees will say, 'O slave of Allah, o Muslim, this is a Jew behind me, come and kill him'."

Shaykh Muhammad Mukhtar al-Mahdi, professor at Al Azhar and head of the Islamic Law Society reiterated this.

http://www­.translati­ngjihad.co­m/

"24/11/201­1, salahsolta­n.com
The Internatio­nal Union of Muslim Scholars (IUMS) calls on all Muslims to make next Friday, 25 November 2011, al-Aqsa Friday...t­o give the Zionists a stern warning...­Let the Zionists know that every stone, even every atom (which is disturbed) will be met with heavy bloodshed.­.."

http://www­.translati­ngjihad.co­m/2011/11/­internatio­nal-union-­of-muslim-­scholars.h­tml
04:24 AM on 01/11/2012
For God's sake, why bring Jews or Zionists here as a reply?! Egypt is a mess!! Please don't call the whole country anti-Semit­ic when its own people being killed, Christians and Muslims alike. The article fails to mention how members of both religious get killed almost every day by SCAF. u r mentioning an irrelevant subject like Egypt's foreign policy. shouldn't we care about its internal affairs first?!
11:15 AM on 01/10/2012
It's hard to write this any shorter, NO !!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!­!
photo
adamben
yes i said yes i will yes
09:26 AM on 01/10/2012
sadly, hamas, which is a wing of the muslim brotherhoo­d, is showing what they are aiming for in egypt; enforced, "unofficia­lly" dress codes, banning of alcohol and harassment of the christian minority. hopefully, ordinary egyptians will get involved and vote in the next elections, if there are any, and turn egypt to a saner path where all egyptians will be treated equally under the law. i know its a long-shot but who knows?
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MarcEdward
likes all cats more than most people
09:11 AM on 01/10/2012
I love the story about the self appointed "religious police" getting their butt kicked by women.
You can't give the religious zealots an inch!
photo
CarmenCameron
Prepping 4 US version of French Revolution
06:28 AM on 01/10/2012
Egypt has always been the cultural leader of the Islamic Middle East. For the last year, it has always been my heartfelt prayer that the wonderful people of this ancient land find a way to come together on a path that gives hope to ALL the world!

Thank you, Ms. Kamel, for giving us the first glimmers of the hope that could light that path.

May God be with you all.
Satirist1
All 4 d best in the best of all possible worlds
05:48 AM on 01/10/2012
Q:Is There A Place For Non-Muslim­s And Liberals In The New Egypt?

A:Certainl­y. At the airport counter. Shopping for a one-way ticket.
06:58 AM on 01/10/2012
Your sarcastic comment helps nobody. Unfortunat­ely, it's also very true.
Satirist1
All 4 d best in the best of all possible worlds
08:06 AM on 01/10/2012
Lemme clue you in, Frank, no amount of our debating here will change Egyptian politics. Not a single iota.
Satirist1
All 4 d best in the best of all possible worlds
08:35 AM on 01/10/2012
You're coming here with "truth is unhelpful" comment. hmmm....
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
MarcEdward
likes all cats more than most people
09:12 AM on 01/10/2012
Did you even read the story?
Satirist1
All 4 d best in the best of all possible worlds
12:40 PM on 01/10/2012
Did you even research the facts?
09:58 PM on 01/09/2012
And soon we will be lucky to have another state like this in the West Bank and Gaza yipeeeeeee­eeeeeeeeee­eeeeee cant wait.