Is raspberry pi a mid-life crisis?

Daily Newsletters

Sign up to ZDNet UK's daily newsletter.

About this blog

Fuss Free Phones: Simon Rockman

Simon has been in the mobile phone industry since Motorola was the top dog closely followed by NEC. He's been the owner and editor of What Mobile Magazine, the editor of PCW and senior at Motorola andRead more » Sony Ericsson. Today he focuses on Mobile Money and his passion of mobile phones for older people. he runshttp://www.fussfreephones.com/

htc-assembler

When my 14 year old son couldn’t get his iPod touch to work with the wifi he didn’t try very hard, he just threw it at me and said “dad fix it”. My kids and their peers have no interest in how a computer works. Oh, they love what it does, miniclip, facebook, skype. But what makes their applications work or what is inside the black box is as interesting as the washing machine or vacuum cleaner. I’ve long thought that there is a bubble of tech; people of my age are more techie than their children.

The UK has reaped the rewards of the tech boom with companies like CSR and ARM having the chips they’ve designed sharing fluff in more pockets than Chubb and Yale. The economic significance of what came out of Acorn and Sinclair cannot be over-stated.

One of the wonderful things about the time I grew up in was that every half-geeky kid had a computer and learnt to program it. Thanks to the BBC programme “Making the most of the micro” and the computers in schools initiative there were lots of computers around. The price point of Sinclair computers meant millions of kids started programming. This was a particularly British phenomenon and made us world leaders in the technology. The echos of that time in the 1980s still exist with many of the best games being written in the UK. Games are the purest form of programming because they have to be innovative, the coding has to be supremely efficient and on consoles everything has to be done with the given hardware. You can’t cover up lazy programming by specifying more memory or a faster processor.

Today they teach ICT. Information Communications Technologies, with the impression that this is about computers so that it must be the same as computing. Of course those that understand computing realise that the two are as different as baking a cake and eating it. ICT is nothing to do with computing, communication or technology. It’s office skills. Using Microsoft Office and Windows is a sensible grounding for life but it’s not going to create the next generations of programmers.

When the report from Ian Livingstone, saying that ICT was boring and we need to re-think IT, got the attention of Michael Gove, Minister for Education, I wrote to Ian Livingstone to congratulate him. David ‘Elite’ Braben is championing Raspbery Pi, a £16 computer that lets anyone learn the real side of computing that is software development. Working down at the OS and processor level. It struck me as brilliant. Just the thing to recapture the lead the UK had in this kind of thing.

Then I thought. I’m 48, I also think that Scalextric and model kits are things children play with In reality the people who buy such things are my age and older. Today’s kids aren’t interested. The world has moved on. The BBC Micro does not need to be repeated. Yes it would be great to have today’s teens learning about how a computer works, how to write code and solder a good connection, but the analogy has been made that programming is the new Latin and it holds true. Latin is great as an academic exercise, and you can argue that it’s the basis of many languages so there is a use, but it isn’t useful in itself. Indeed on one school open day a teacher at the school Stephen Hawking went to said that the prime reason for having Latin, Greek and Classics on your CV was not to have those skills but to show the Merchant Bank you were applying to that you went to That Kind Of School.

Today getting down below OS level is something you do at university, not with a firmware manual under the sheets. Trying to recapture it might appeal to those of us with grey beards and little hair, but just because you can build a Raspberry Pi for under £20 doesn’t mean thousands of kids will want one.It’s great that you could do this at home but there was a time when the leading edge of genetic research was a monk with some peas. Just because young teens led the way in computing in the 1980s doesn’t mean it should, will or can happen again. Those outside the tech age bubble have better things to do. The Raspberry Pi is a BBC Micro come-back tour and as likely to excite teens as Phil Collins getting back with Genesis.

I sorted out the wifi on my son’s iPod, and up popped the last site he’d looked at: a porn site.

Simon Rockman blogs about big button and easy to use phones.

Talkback

Good 'reality check' post.

I agree that it's unlikely the average 14-year-old will want to mess around with a Raspberry Pi board on its own -- though I do think the wide availability of very cheap and quite powerful computers like this has a lot of potential to inspire interesting projects from some bright and imaginative kids.

For other ways that kids can do 'real' computing, take a look at the Computing at School curriculum: http://www.computingatschool.org.uk/index.php?id=documents.

samdutton 21 February, 2012 11:25
Reply

Being born in 1987, I missed the programming era. We had a family PC, but I was never told that you could make you own programs. The idea seemed absurd when I learned about it years later - what would be the point? Programs were created by teams of professionals, who then sold them to people to use.

Note: the above comment suggests that the open source / free software movement may also be ominously generational - I'd be interested in the clever people of this site's views

I was however, and still am, a big fan of model kits. The reason is simple: I started building kits because I loved aeroplanes. I'm still a fan because between my interest and the kits, I learned about the technologies and history - which provoked a lifelong interest. In short, there was a *point* to building model kits which I could see and this made me want to do so.

It's a fine line between being a content consumer or creator - and having a point makes a lot of difference.

Equally, we could argue that there's a "platform" level involved - the generation discussed in the blog saw computers at the hardware level (so you make software to go on it); whereas when I was little the platform was installed programs (I published an online comic which I drew in Photoshop) and now that has largely moved to web-based "things" (what do you call them?) like Youtube.

The result being that computer-based creativity will be more likely to focus on generating content for Youtube and the like.

Thoughts?

archerthom 21 February, 2012 14:14
Reply

Not sure I agree. I'm of a similar vintage, and currently work for a digital marketing agency, where the majority of the company are a.) in their 20s, b.) spend all day on the web, and c.) have very little idea (if any) how it works.

A couple of people asked how they could host their own blogs / sites, and I offered to tell them if they were prepared to learn about how the internet actually works (the 'OS of the web' as it were - DNS, HTTP, HTML). Turns out almost the entire company now want to learn about things like: how the internet works, what browsers really do, how to code HTML / CSS etc.

The equivalent of the BBC Micro is the web, and I think a lot of young people are fascinated about how it works. Do they want to learn about web server internals - nope, but that's not relevant for them.

Hugo Rodger-Brown via Facebook 21 February, 2012 14:26
Reply

I generally agree with what you've said.. but the real story here for me is, this Raspberry Pi for (likely I guess) under £40 is a little marvel for people on low income, if it can run Lubuntu or similar. wow. parents will have no excuse not to help educate their children by giving them PC access to the internet. Just an opinion there.

David Shaw via Facebook 21 February, 2012 15:12
Reply

"My kids and their peers have no interest in how a computer works. Oh, they love what it does, miniclip, facebook, skype. But what makes their applications work or what is inside the black box is as interesting as the washing machine or vacuum cleaner. I’ve long thought that there is a bubble of tech; people of my age are more techie than their children."

I think you're describing an effect here, and not the cause. They have no interest because it's never been presented to them in a way that makes them think they can understand it. The analogy with the vacuum is good, but a bit limited, because the vacuum has a single function whereas the computer, once you can programme is pretty much limitless.

Toby Proctor via Facebook 21 February, 2012 15:35
Reply

Toby, while there is some effect here, it's not solely that. I tried them on Mindstorms and Sketch and there was no interest. Offers to take them to a software house to see games being developed are met with "meh". I don't want to belittle my kids, they will lap up National Geographic and play the guitar for hours a day, but there is no culture of coding.

Simon Rockman 21 February, 2012 19:19
Reply

What a defeatiest attitude by an old fart.
"All dem kids 'r lazy bastards.. Im my day..."

I heard the same thing when robotics competitions were started in north america "Kids these days.." is how it all started. Repeating the tired cliches of every generation as they get older.

These competitions are not only for high school but for elementary school kids (im not a fan of kids travelling thousands of miles to go to a competition when they are 9 yrs old. the costs are too much).
Are they for everyone? No. But guess what? The future engineers and doctors of this world arent like 98% of kids out there. But they are entry level enough that we might interest some kids who otherwise wouldnt.
Not everyone that does robotics will one day work in the field but its a pleasure to see students a decade later tell me theyre studying to be an engineer, physicist (one of those is doing his master at MIT), a doctor or a teacher. What they learned there doesnt always translate into their futures careers but these same kids that have a thirst for knowledge need to be stimulated.
Learning how to save a document in Word isnt one of them.

Are there less geeks than before? Are kids more stupid than before?
Your Micro semi-geeks still exists today. Its not like little Bobby who ate boogers and Billy whose only interest was football were those Micro geeks. Guess what? Its probably the same now if not more.

Besides, even without the educational aspect, if it doenst catch on, you still have a nice little computer to surf and play Angry Birds on the TV.

Mediocrity has never been a problem and good students who want to learn exist everywhere,no matter the country or the economic backgrounds. This is a very cheap way to get your kids out of a future of mediocrity and service industry jobs.

Arthur Dent via Facebook 21 February, 2012 22:47
Reply

contd-

Selling out a whole generation because its perceived to be lazier and more apathetic than the last is a tired old cliche that you see very often with people who ARENT involved with teaching kids.
I take time out of my schedule to help a teacher run the robotics group in elementary school because there ARE kids who are interested. And every so often we get some kids you would not expect to be interested but who think that robots are cool. If we can make learning fun and educational, there are no losers.
There is only a losers mindset.

As a parent, you job isnt to teach your children, its to teach them to learn things on their own.
Giving up on them is the worst and laziest thing you can do.

Lets stop teaching advanced math and calculus because lets face it, most kids can barely count,right?
Wrong.
The young mind is a like a sponge and can absorb much more than people give them credit.

I for one am always amazed at my friends 8yr old who can play Chopin beautifully while Im not better than a pop tart after 20yrs at it. We each find our niche. Some kids it will be science, some it will be languages (4 year old nephew speaks four languages), some it will be sport.
To give up on finding those that might be interested seems like callous thing to do.

I only visit England on business so Im not sure if robotics is a big thing in UK schools but the educators involved in those in north america are thrilled about the Pi since its a continuation of what they are doing.

But then again, a lifetime of serving fries with that doenst demand more than touching a few buttons so there is a lot to look forward to.

Arthur Dent via Facebook 21 February, 2012 22:48
Reply

The Raspberry is not going to find a mainstream audience but will be a boon to kids who do like taking things apart and I think that's a reasonably-sized minority and one definitely worth empowering.

It sounds to me that the golden age of computer programming you describe came about because programming was cool. It wasn't that the kids involved saw that learning to code was inherently virtuous - they did it because other kids did it/spoke about it/prized it. In short, there was buzz.

On a side-note: it's very rare, these days, to see buzz combine with virtue where kid-fads are concerned (then again, playing the guitar is cool, and music has plenty of moral applications).

Programming will probably never be a kid-fad again, but start-ups like Codecademy do offer some hope.

Colin Myer via Facebook 22 February, 2012 18:11
Reply

Post your comment

In order to post a comment you need to be registered and logged in.

You can also log in with Facebook. Log in or create your ZDNet UK account below

  • Login

Will not be displayed with your comment

By signing up for this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understood our Privacy Policy. Questions about membership? Find the answers in the Community FAQ

Get ZDNet UK's daily newsletter

Enter your email address to sign up

ZDNet UK Live

IJ24

It's good to know that measures are made to make printing tasks easier aside of course from products like cheap Canon ink that help diminish the...

11 minutes ago by IJ24 on Cloud printers wrest ink from Google, HP
Paul Smyth

I'm bored of all the luddite Unity knockers. Think you can do better? Put up or shut up. I love Unity, it's elegant, beautiful, highly functional...

28 minutes ago by Paul Smyth via Facebook on Canonical defends its shift to Unity
DrJonno

Nice new agenda/mail client. Shame it doesn't appear to integrate with Bridge. The Bridge clients seem not to have changed at all. Overall...

2 hours ago by DrJonno on RIM delivers BlackBerry PlayBook OS 2.0
Keith Jamieson

@1000099915 I totally agree with you. I was just letting DmitryKirsanov know that there is more than "just" a receiver at work here. I dont own,...

2 hours ago by Keith Jamieson via Facebook on UK Sentinel study reveals GPS jammer use
1000099915

@Keith Jamieson You turn off GPS on your device. You don't block GPS in the surrounding area! If you are required by your company to be tracked by...

2 hours ago by 1000099915 on UK Sentinel study reveals GPS jammer use
Jake Rayson

If they can pull it off with phone manufacturers, this could be the back door for relatively widespread adoption of Ubuntu: who wouldn't want a...

2 hours ago by Jake Rayson on Ubuntu for Android arrives: In pictures
Keith Jamieson

@DmitryKirsanov There are companies who fit GPS trackers onto their vehicles. They are basically a GPS receiver and GSM (phone) transmitter. At...

3 hours ago by Keith Jamieson via Facebook on UK Sentinel study reveals GPS jammer use
catman1

My satnav always stops working through the channel tunnelwhen I exit UK end.It will not restart until 24hrs later.OK going from UK to france no...

4 hours ago by catman1 on UK Sentinel study reveals GPS jammer use
DmitryKirsanov

Wow. People from Facebook are either trolls or plain stupid. Why it is so hard to understand how GPS works? Is the difference between the...

4 hours ago by DmitryKirsanov on UK Sentinel study reveals GPS jammer use
Abz Izback

lol, before it was illegal for prisoners to remove their tags, and slaves to remove theirs or to burn their branding before that, now guess who the...

6 hours ago by Abz Izback via Facebook on UK Sentinel study reveals GPS jammer use
mileswade

I have no idea if GPS jamming in the US is a crime or not, it should be. There has been a lot of discourse civil and otherwise concerning jamming...

9 hours ago by mileswade on UK Sentinel study reveals GPS jammer use
whitty44

Gurpeet - GPS does not track you. Things such as your phone may use it, but all that GPS is are messages of the time it was sent. Matthew - GPS...

9 hours ago by whitty44 on UK Sentinel study reveals GPS jammer use
qst4

I've been quite happy with Ubuntu 11.10. And I'm happy to see Canonical making aggressive changes. I've been using this distro for the past month...

10 hours ago by qst4 on Canonical defends its shift to Unity
Matthew Shea

What a police state the UK has become. Dear God!

10 hours ago by Matthew Shea via Facebook on UK Sentinel study reveals GPS jammer use
Matthew Shea

How about No. What a load of bullshit this article is. People have the right to not be surveillanced if they wish so long as they aren't causing...

10 hours ago by Matthew Shea via Facebook on UK Sentinel study reveals GPS jammer use
Simon Bisson

Set the clock forward, and then set the clock back. That resets the lock out timer. No need to connect while "in the future" - in fact you'll get a...

11 hours ago by Simon Bisson via Facebook on BlackBerry PlayBook OS 2.0
bluedalmatian

"Even in the Gnome world now, they're talking about design and user experience and user research and user testing in a way that was never important...

14 hours ago by bluedalmatian on Canonical defends its shift to Unity
Gurpeet Sangera

God save GPS? Invasion of privacy more like it. True freedom is to be able opt out of being tracked and recorded.

14 hours ago by Gurpeet Sangera via Facebook on UK Sentinel study reveals GPS jammer use
Mast sense

they have tried to get planning permison to errect a 50ft 4g mast 38 ft from our back fence, yet they claim there will be no side effects to it....

15 hours ago by Mast sense on Almost 1m households to be hit by 4G interference
disgruntled

i have no desire for extra boxes in my living room. if 4G interferes with my tv, i'll go hunting for mobile phone towers after closing time and...

16 hours ago by disgruntled on Almost 1m households to be hit by 4G interference

Community highlights

Alan Priestley

Fears about cloud security are largely unjustified

Blog Post Despite cloud technologies being adopted at a relentless pace there is always...

22 February, 2012 by Alan Priestley
First Take

Samsung Series 7 Chronos

Blog Post The Samsung Series 7 Chronos isn't the kind of notebook we normally spend...

21 February, 2012 by First Take
Jake Rayson

I am a mighty advertiser!

Blog Post I’ve noticed an interesting trend of late in the social networking world:...

21 February, 2012 by Jake Rayson
J.A. Watson

SimplyMEPIS 11.0.12 Released

Blog Post I came across something else that happened while I was away the past few...

21 February, 2012 by J.A. Watson