Pappageorge easily survives primary challenge in state Senate race

Oakland County Republicans and Democrats chose their nominees for five state Senate seats in Tuesday’s primary.

All 38 Senate seats were up for election and 30 had no incumbent.

All precincts had not been counted at press time.

In Oakland County, only one incumbent — John Pappageorge —sought re-election and he faced two primary challengers. The other four were open seats created by term limits and those drew strong candidate interest.

In the 13th district, which includes Troy, Clawson, Royal Oak, Madison Heights, Birmingham, Bloomfield Hills and Bloomfield Township, incumbent Republican John Pappageorge of Troy led with 17,963 votes with 92 of 125 precincts reporting followed by David R. Kniffen of Troy with 3,365 and Roi Chinn of Bloomfield Hills with 1,848. The winner faces Democrat Aaron Bailey of Royal Oak in November.

“The good news is nobody (got) nasty in the campaign,” said Pappageorge, who said he met with opponents to talk about ethics before the race began.

“In elections there is the tendency to tell a small truth to tell a bigger lie,” he said.

Pappageorge said he worked hard for the primary.

In the 14th district, three Republicans and six Democrats vied to replace term-limited Sen. Gilda Jacobs, D-Huntington Woods. With 63 precincts counted, Republican Michael A. Peters of Farmington Hills had 3,274 votes, Robert A. Vaughan, 2,131, and James Hardin of Southfield, 1.572.

State Rep. Vince Gregory of Southfield led with 5,897 votes, Democratic County Commissioner Dave Coulter of Ferndale had  5,039, Jenifer Marlene Franklin, 2,385, Howard Worthy, 599, Derhun Daniel Sanders, 574, and Anthony Stafford McDonald, 517. Continued...

Coulter called the campaign “energizing, long and hard-fought.”

He said while jobs were on voters’ minds, “the issue that surprised me was schools and education. They were much higher on people’s lists because schools are closing and teachers are being laid off.”

Gregory said he knocked on doors, called voters and sent out mailings.

“We did everything we wanted to do,” he said.

The district includes Farmington, Farmington Hills, Southfield, Franklin, Bingham Farms, Beverly Hills, Southfield Township, Lathrup Village, Berkley, Huntington Woods, Oak Park, Royal Oak Township, Pleasant Ridge, Ferndale and Hazel Park.

In the 12th district — which includes Keego Harbor, Sylvan Lake, Pontiac, Lake Angelus, Auburn Hills, Rochester Hills, Rochester and townships of Independence, Orion, Oxford, Addison and Oakland — six Republicans and two Democrats campaigned to replace term-limited Senate Majority Leader Mike Bishop of Rochester.

With 14 precincts reporting, Republican term-limited state Rep. Jim Marleau of Lake Orion led challengers with 1,799, closely followed by Copper Rizzo of Rochester Hills at 1,573, Kim Russell of Rochester, 1,432, former state Rep. John Garfield of Rochester Hills at 559, Gene Taliercio of Rochester Hills with 497 and Lois Golden of Rochester Hills, 189.

Democrat Casandra Ulbrich was leading Ted Golden 1,195 to 216. Both are from Rochester Hills.

In the 15th district, six Republicans and three Democrats vied to succeed term-limited Sen. Nancy Cassis, R-Novi.

Republican Kerry Bentivolio of Milford had 1,920, Paul Graves of Milford, 1,060, White Lake Township Supervisor Mike Kowall 5,975, John Cyrus Mohyi of West Bloomfield, 633, Alan Stephens of Milford, 1,070 and Steven Valentini of Novi, 774. Continued...

Kowall also said that if elected he would work on changing the single business tax to make the state more inviting for businesses to expand.

Democrats vying for a spot on the ballot in November were Tom Crawford of Milford, with 788 votes, Pam Jackson of Commerce Township at 2,801 and Christopher P. Maloney of Northville, 785.

The district includes the townships of Holly, Rose, Highland, White Lake, Milford, Lyon, Commerce and West Bloomfield plus Novi, Wixom, Walled Lake, Wolverine Lake, Orchard Lake, South Lyon and part of Northville.

In the 26th district, four Republicans and three Democrats campaigned to succeed term-limited Democrat Sen. Deb Cherry of Genesee County.

Republican David B. Robertson of Grand Blanc led with 467, Fran Amos of Waterford, 160, Michael Matheny of Grand Blanc, 92, and Tim Terpening of Davisburg, 50.

Democrat Katherine Houston of Ortonville had 63 votes from Oakland County, Jim Slezak of Davison, 59 and Paula Zelenko of Burton, 47.

The district represents Waterford, Springfield, Groveland and Brandon townships, plus all or parts of nine other townships in Genesee County.

 

Comments

The following are comments from the readers. In no way do they represent the view of the Daily Tribune or dailytribune.com.

F. Hayek wrote on Aug 5, 2010 4:27 PM:

" Pappageorge's win is good news for Oakland County and good news for Michigan. He has been one of a few voices of reason in Lansing with common sense solutions to save/create jobs, balance the budget, and limit taxes. He has also been able to reach across the aisle to advance substance over petty bickering.

Perhaps as a now senior member of the Senate, he will be a candidate for Majority Leader or other major leadership position.

If only southeastern Michigan had more like him, we might be in better shape. "

Login To Comment

You must be logged in to post a comment.

*Member ID:
*Password:
Remember login?
(requires cookies)
  Forgot Your Password?
 

Not Registered? Sign up today for free!

Do not use usernames or passwords from your financial accounts!

Note: Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required!

*Create a Member ID:
*Choose a password:
*Re-enter password:
*E-mail Address:
*Year of Birth:
 

(children under 13 cannot register)

First Name:
Last Name:
Address:
City:
Zip Code:
I want to receive info from dailytribune.com: Please add me.
By registering, you agree with our terms of service.
 


ADVERTISEMENT


Talk of the Web




View More

Place a Classified

National News Videos

Recent Activity on Facebook



Blog Center

crumm

Oakland Press' Election 2010 blog

Charles Crumm wants to help you stay fully informed about the upcoming elections, so check in for the latest inside information, insight and updates on everything impacting Oakland County's elections.

adler

Inside the Oakland Press Opinion Page

The Oakland Press opinion page carries daily editorials, guest columns, and letters to the editor. All are fair game here.

The Responsible Community

The Responsible Community

The Responsible Community will examine in a rational and reasonable manner the issues that we all face in our communities from the point of view of shared responsibility. It expands on Rousseau's Social Contract that individuals have with each other.

It's Time to Take a Stand

It's Time to Take a Stand

Right or wrong, it matters not. Take a Stand is a pledge to get involved in what is happening in our area and around the world. What matters is that you believe in something enough to take a stand. Make a decision, get involved in something in which you have an interest, vote for someone or something or vote against someone or something and stand by it.

The Blog Prof

The Blog Prof

C.J. Kobus resides in Oakland County and teaches engineering. He is also a Christian, a husband, a father of six and a competitive natural bodybuilder. He writes about politics, faith, science and technology, physical fitness and life.

More Blogs

Community Calendar

National AP Headlines

View all AP National Headlines