Ex-prisoners urge Singapore to scrap security law

Former political prisoners in Singapore have demanded the abolition of a British colonial law allowing detention without trial after neighbouring Malaysia vowed to repeal similar legislation.

In a rare public message, carried by an independent website and reported in pro-government media Tuesday, 16 former detainees held under the Internal Security Act (ISA) said it was time to abolish the controversial law.

"Singapore inherited the ISA from Malaysia. This law has been in existence for more than half a century and its impact on society is both crippling and pernicious," the petitioners said.

The ISA, first implemented by Britain after World War II to fight communist insurgents in colonies collectively known as Malaya, was retained by Singapore after it became independent from the Malaysian federation in 1965.

The ISA has been denounced by critics in both nations as a tool to stifle dissent, but Singapore rejected calls for its abolition after Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak announced last week that his government would repeal it.

In a statement on Friday, Singapore's Ministry of Home Affairs said the ISA remained "relevant" against threats of subversion, racial and religious extremism, espionage and terrorism.

"No person has ever been detained only for their political beliefs," the ministry said.

The Singapore petitioners included Chia Thye Poh, who spent 26 years in detention and was one of the world's longest-held political prisoners along with South Africa's democracy icon and former president Nelson Mandela.

Chia was a 1960s socialist intellectual and opposition MP who was accused of being a communist subversive, a charge he firmly denied.

Seven of the signatories were detained in 1987 for an alleged Marxist conspiracy against the government of Singapore's founding leader Lee Kuan Yew, who was prime minister from 1959 to 1990.

Lee, 88, stepped down in May as an adviser to the cabinet of his son, Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong, following a general election in which the ruling party lost six seats and garnered an all-time low of 60 percent of the vote.

Since the campaign for the May polls, government critics have become increasingly bolder in their demands for greater political freedom in Singapore.

Last month's presidential election, in which former deputy prime minister Tony Tan won by a slim margin against three rivals with just 35 percent of the vote, was seen as a further sign of public support for reforms.

"Singapore has many existing laws that will deal with acts of terrorism," the petitioners said, citing the penal code and laws specifically directed at terrorism, firearms and explosives possession and illicit fund transfers.

"These laws provide severe punishments which include death, life imprisonment and caning."

There was no immediate reaction from the home ministry to the petition.

123 comments

  • Alan 11 hours ago
    to all those who still defends the isa,dont they know it is more harmful then helpful to us ordinary singaporeans?
  • Cuemal 3 days ago
    If it is miss used then the population will know in this era nothing can be hide, so for the time being I had not see very serious miss use of the ISA, like the new three cartoonists that is only declare lock up when USA celebrate their terror attacked since 10 years ago that they had over come all damage almost is there a miss used?? But I guess a re-study the detail (an addition independent body to check on this ISA) and president should do his work since he has the rite to.
  • No Eye See 2 days ago
    demolish ISA then enact Anti-Terrorist / Homeland security, its LP and PL again lar.
  • lim 2 days ago
    why worry if you have nothing to worry
  • beggardog 3 days ago
    even with the isa existing, it should be upgraded. the body remained and the organs changed. british communism n present day terrorism are quite different. if malaysia can and willing to change to improve; we should not feel shy to follow
  • Lam 2 days ago
    No problem with the ISA or ASI.
    Like a double edged sword.
    It depends on how the decision maker use it..
    It can be used to slash not only the bad people but also the good ones.
    So proper rules and instructions must be included.
    A safety fuse or switch must be installed so that no innocent people will be electrocuted.
    At most just get a shock.
  • Aigoo 3 days ago
    I heard that detainees had to sign a declaration form saying that they were Maxists or Communists and they denounce these beliefs before they are deemed reformed and released.... is this true? If it is, then that is why Chia was detained for 26 years by not succumbing to threats and if not physical torture then mental ones. Brave but Poor guy. Most would have just signed and got on with life. You will never find any more people in Singapore with those unwavering principals.
  • Sage On 3 days ago
    Imagine 26 years of life wasted away! Where is the balancing scale of justice?
  • suntilon 2 days ago
    The reason given for keeping ISA is to protect the general public of Singaporeans. However we all know who it really protects.
  • David 3 days ago
    Yes, I support you SaripDol! Political Detainees also need Human Rights! Btw, who are they and how many of them? Nobody knows and yet still shout loud loud?
  • Jane 2 days ago
    @seah Not only low iq and dumb idiot singaporean voted them . all the asshole SOBs foreigners voted for them too. Mother..f....s
  • mms 2 days ago
    dictionary cannot find the word "abolish" for the PAP because the ISA is their weapons to tackle the opposition as long as the Lee empire is around their barking dogs work along with him...so dont think of it it's the PAP strong weapons.....
  • nwar524 3 days ago
    as far as i can see, from a normal person, you have turned someone into a vegetable inside..and not surprising why u keep such person in detention- for fear of legal repercussions?? wake up- wake up..dont cover ur selves!
  • John 3 days ago
    ISA should never be used for political gains! Is the Govt too stupid to create another dept. to handle terrorism???
  • Over The Top 3 days ago
    Think! Who are afraid of the ISA?
  • Dante 3 days ago
    "Chia was a 1960s socialist intellectual and opposition MP who was accused of being a communist subversive, a charge he firmly denied."

    Ok, let's say Chia was REALLY a communist. So what? At that time, who wasn't engaged in political ideologies? From communism to capitalism to democracy, who wasn't swept away by the tides of changing orders of the lands?

    And what exactly did Chia did that he deserved to be put in detention without trial for 26 years??? Come on, we are not talking about 26 months. We are talking about a quarter of a century, all for what? Something the PAP 'suspected' but took a 'pre-emptive strike' before Chia do any real damage? How fantastic was that?

    My say: Lee KY was just swiftly removing all obstacles of his political path to ensure that the 'power' he newly obtained was solidly contained within his grasp. And thus, in the name of 'suspicion' and 'national threat' he rounded up all those who were different from his political beliefs and threw them into prison.

    If PAP aka Lee KY were so confirmed of their 'crimes' why don't they just list them out. Bomb the theatre? Kidnap and blackmail? Murder and threaten? The fact that all these years it was only 'lip service' paid by the PAP attests to the truth that they have nothing to show to the world. The only explanation then is to view it as a 'political massacre', which of course LKY firmly denied too.
  • . 3 days ago
    "No person has ever been detained only for their political beliefs," the ministry said.

    Right, just add a slab of potential for political change in the formula and I bet it would be enough "justification" for them.
  • The Unwanted 3 days ago
    ISA shouls counter terrorism.do not use on political opponent.come out wth a terrorism law be hard on these,extremist,muderers,jihadist,holy warriors..lock them up for life don't need trail.
  • whatever 3 days ago
    want to reform, also make sure got Plan B. Plan A fail of reform, got no Plan B, the whole country can go hell.
  • Roy 2 days ago
    Its time to demolish ISA Singapore (Singaporeans)