A popular anti-drug program provided free to schools in San
Francisco and elsewhere teaches concepts straight out of the Church of
Scientology, including medical theories that some addiction experts described
as "irresponsible" and "pseudoscience."
As a result, students are being introduced to somebeliefs and methods of
Scientology without their knowledge.
Anyone listening to a classroom talk by Narconon Drug Prevention &
Education is unlikely to recognize the connection with Scientology; the
lessons sound nothing like theology. Instruction is delivered in language
purged of most church parlance, but includes "all the Scientology and
Dianetics Handbook basics," according to Scientology correspondence obtained
by The Chronicle.
Narconon's anti-drug instruction rests on these key church concepts: that
the body stores all kinds of toxins indefinitely in fat, where they wreak
havoc on the mind until "sweated" out. Those ideas are rejected by the five
medical experts contacted by The Chronicle, who say there is no evidence to
support them.
Narconon was created by L. Ron Hubbard, the late science-fiction writer
who founded Scientology, a religion that claims to improve the well-being of
followers through courses aimed at self-improvement and global serenity.
Narconon operates a global network of drug treatment centers, as well as
education programs for elementary, middle and high school students.
Its lectures have reached 1.7 million children around the nation in the
last decade, Narconon officials said, and more than 30,000 San Francisco
students since 1991. Meanwhile, Narconon's anti-drug message and charismatic
speakers earn rave reviews from students and teachers.
Narconon officials are adamant that Narconon is secular and that a
firewall exists between it and the Church of Scientology, and San Francisco
school health officials say they know of no church-state problem with Narconon
or of any pseudoscience taught.
But a close look reveals a crossover of church language, materials,
concepts, personnel and some finances, leading to accusations that Scientology
has slipped into public classrooms.
"Narconon, to me, is Scientology," said Lee Saltz, a drug counselor with
the Los Angeles school district, where Narconon has made classroom
presentations for many years. "We don't use their curriculum because it's not
grounded in science. But they bypass our office and go directly to the schools.
They're very persistent."
Narconon speakers tell students that the body stores drugs indefinitely
in fat, where they cause drug cravings and flashbacks. Students are told that
sweating through exercise or sauna rids the body of these "poisons." And, some
teachers said, the speakers tell students that the drug residues produce a
colored ooze when exiting the body.
"It's pseudoscience, right up there with colonic irrigation," said Dr.
Peter Banys, director of substance abuse programs at the VA Medical Center in
San Francisco.
Dr. Igor Grant, professor of psychiatry and director of the Center for
Medicinal Cannabis Research at UC San Diego, agreed: "I'm not aware of any
data that show that going into a sauna detoxifies you from toxins of any kind.
" Three other addiction experts contacted by The Chronicle echoed their
skepticism.
But Narconon officials say their science is sound and their curriculum
free of religion. And they say Narconon is legally and financially separate
from the church.
"It's our job to keep them separate," said Clark Carr, president of
Narconon International and a Scientologist. "We work full time to do this. If
we went into the school district as Scientology, with the separation of church
and state, it wasn't going to work. It would be as if someone said, 'I have
some things in the Bible I think would be very helpful.' No, thank you. It's
corporately and financially separate, and that's appropriate.
"For us, the larger issue is that kids need help. We're not in this for
any other agenda.''
Federal law prohibits religious instruction in public schools -- but it
also prevents school officials from ousting secular programs just because they
are provided by religious groups.
more