Letter: Hell in the ancient world
Friday 31 December 1993
Latest in Opinion
Opinion blogs
Auschwitz: How relevant is it in today’s society?
A while ago, I was having a conversation with friends; the Holocaust came up and we began to tentati...
Heathrow third runway: back to the beginning
When and why did David Cameron come out against the expansion of Heathrow airport? This was a questi...
Do we need a social netiquette upgrade?
As children we learn not to speak with our mouths full or accept sweets from dubious looking strange...
He should have ventured into the second millennium BC when, the evidence from Ancient Egypt shows, belief in a fiery Hell was earnestly held. It is massively attested in both texts and iconography and is firmly linked to the doctrine of divine judgement after death. I have examined this belief in my book The Divine Verdict (Leiden, 1991), comparing the later parallel beliefs in other cultures. The priority of the Egyptian concept is beyond question.
According to the Egyptian doctrine, the damned suffer manifold and agonising tortures, but they end in annihilation. Eternal torment is not suggested. It seems that this sinister refinement was first produced by the Judaic idea of the fiery Hell of Gehenna, which was subsumed by Christianity. I accept Mr Maccoby's claim that the idea was modified in later Judaism, whereas in the Christian tradition it was unhappily magnified.
Yours faithfully,
J. GWYN GRIFFITHS
University of Wales
Swansea
30 December
- 1 Robert Fisk: Syria's newspapers trumpet an army victory but the sound of shellfire tells the true story
- 2 Robert Fisk: The bloody truth about Syria's uncivil war
- 3 Laurie Penny: It's nice to think that only evil men are rapists - that it's only pantomime villains with knives in alleyways. But the reality is different
- 4 Robert Fisk: 'Rebel army? They're a gang of foreigners'
- 5 The Daily Cartoon
- 6 David Randall: The Prince's New Clothes (26/08/12)
- 7 John Rentoul: Forget Dave and George. The real story is the two Eds
- 8 Patrick Cockburn: As the violence intensifies in Syria, there can be only one winner - the Kurds
- 9 Andrew Martin: I have a confession to make - I go to church
- 10 Claudia Pritchard: Pardon my French, but, vraiment, who needs it?
- 1 Sealed for 99 years and 363 days - so what was inside the mysterious parcel left to a small town in Norway?
- 2 Israel breaks silence over army abuses
- 3 Cheerleader must compensate school that told her to clap 'rapist'
- 4 Special report: The empire strikes back
- 5 Robert Fisk: The bloody truth about Syria's uncivil war
- 6 The talent myth: How to maximise your creative potential
- 7 Laurie Penny: It's nice to think that only evil men are rapists - that it's only pantomime villains with knives in alleyways. But the reality is different
- 8 The Hermione Granger effect: why teenagers are finally starting to say no to drugs and alcohol
- 9 'Hello mum, this is going to be hard for you to read ...'
- 10 Sex and the modern girl: Are we witnessing a new age of female sexual assertiveness?
Experience the Heineken Hub
Get free wi-fi and exclusive i content while you enjoy a tasty pint of Heineken at participating pubs.
Win a guided tour of Superhuman
With dinner for two and a £50 book token for the intriguing exhibition at the Wellcome Collection.
Win your very own tailor-made holiday to Switzerland
Whether you'd rather hike up a mountain or relax in a spa, you'll love this trip to Graubünden.
A legacy we can be proud of
The most lasting effect London 2012 will have is to motivate children all over the UK to get interested in science, technology, engineering and maths
Looking to make extra cash this summer?
London will be busy this summer, so why not rent your house, flat or spare room with Airbnb?
Now showing at the O2
Check out the cool stuff happening under our tent: the hottest gigs, comedy, sport, films, clubs, bars, restaurants and much more.
Enter the latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Business videos from commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Comments