Album: Britney Spears, Circus (Zomba/Sony)

2.00

News in pictures
News in pictures
Arts & Ents blogs

Must watch: Gangnam Style Robot

One robot stole the show at a robotics competition in China with its version of the viral video danc...

Ne-Yo: If you don’t give yourself the option of failure then it won’t find you

In the past six years, as well as selling 23 million of his own singles, hit maker Ne-Yo has written...

The evolution of UK Bass

Later this week the Red Bull Music Academy hosts its third Culture Clash, a huge music competition w...

       

It's anybody's guess how two such high-profile pop acts as Take That and Britney Spears came to release albums with the same title on the same day – especially as neither bothers to develop the circus theme to any extent, save for Spears's claim to be "the ringleader" in her title track, the latest admission of her pathological desire to be the centre of attention ("all eyes on me in the centre of the ring, just like a circus") that made last year's Blackout such a grisly, charmless car-crash experience.

Circus is almost as charmless, but at least it succeeds better than its predecessor in their intention of portraying the former Mouseketeer as some kind of robotic nymphomaniac doll – groaning and grunting "let's make out" with the chilly distance of a future-sex cyborg unit in "Mmm Papi", before plugging directly into the notion of synthetic, emotionless sex with a faceless pleasure-droid in "Mannequin". It's as if her own life is so beset with emotional turmoil that she can't bear any more intrusive feelings in her personal relations. But there are certain standards to maintain even in the world of diva-sex, and while the slap bass lends an apt Seventies porno-funk flavour to the erotic-floorshow anthem "Lace and Leather", the titular pun of "If You Seek Amy" is crass: the entire song is simply an excuse for Spears to sing "All of the boys and all of the girls want to F-U-C-K me", about as cheap as sensationalist outrage gets.

There are glimmers of a more considered attitude towards relationships, with "Blur" notably depicting the morning-after anxieties of an alcoholic libertine: "Where the hell am I? Who are you? What did we do last night?". But the accidental effect of playing such a pop-tart nympho on so many tracks is that the songs in which she's required actually to express feelings, such as the ghastly devotional ballad "My Baby", simply drown in the tidal wave of ersatz emotion, as if she's faked it for so long that she's lost access to the real thing.

But there are moments of salvation, even if they're incidental things like the echoes of New Order's sombre hedonism in the chord structure of "Unusual You", or the way Spears's rhythmic stutter ("Boy don't try to front, I-I-I-know just-just what you are-I-I") brings a surreal flavour of Scottish country-dancing to the prancing techno single "Womanizer". "Radar", an irritatingly catchy electropop groove by Bloodshy & Avant, will doubtless follow "Womanizer" and the title track into the charts, though they do Spears's reputation as a singer no favours. The only track that does is "Amnesia", an ill-judged attempt to route the dramatic, epic-pop style of Lieber & Stoller, Spector and Springsteen through the big-beat rave era, on which her vocals are the lone saving grace.

Download this: 'Womanizer', 'Lace and Leather', 'Amnesia'

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
iJobs Job Widget

Day In a Page

A modern Mrs Robinson with a passion for laughs

A modern Mrs Robinson with a passion for laughs

Sarah Alexander is happy to play the older woman
The 10 Best style books

The 10 Best style books

Stylish reads for sartorialists of all persuasions
Forget Roger and Rafa

Murray and Djokovic: The new rivalry

Forget Roger and Rafa, Murray and Djokovic have displaced them as the game's headline act
Kevin Macdonald: 'The world is full of opinion. What we need is people who go out and find the facts'

'The world is full of opinion. What we need is people who go out and find the facts'

The Monday Interview: Kevin Macdonald
Peter Lely: Dutch master's naked ambition

Peter Lely: Dutch master's naked ambition

This renowned portrait painter also produced powerful erotic and mythological pieces
The IoS Pink List 2012

The IoS Pink List 2012

More than 1,500 of you voted for the influential LGBT people who, you feel, make Britain safer, fairer, better and more entertaining
Ed Miliband exclusive: 'We'd name and shame low-payers'

Exclusive: Ed Miliband interview

The Labour leader tells Jane Merrick of his plans to get all major firms to introduce the living wage
Al Murray: 'Comedy's my living... how did that happen?'

Al Murray: 'Comedy's my living... how did that happen?'

We're all doomed, says the surprisingly well-spoken comedian, who's just as livid as his Pub Landlord alter ego about our 'preposterous' politicians

The man who brought an end to The Killing

Soren Sveistrup reveals why Sarah Lund's third series will be her last
The joyous power of bawling out the boss

Andrew Gimson: The joyous power of bawling out the boss

Bureaucrats may try to control our working lives, but as Danny Baker dramatically showed, employees can find ways of striking back
Meet Westminster's answer to James Bond

John Rentoul: Meet Westminster's answer to James Bond

The SNP will ask the Scottish electorate to vote for a greased pig in a dark poke
How tourism cursed tomb of King Tut

How tourism cursed tomb of King Tut

Damage from breath of visitors forces closure of chamber
National Trust not happy with Alan Bennett

National Trust bites back at Alan Bennett

Clash of national treasures as volunteers object to playwright's jibes
The boondoggling race to the White House

The boondoggling race to the White House

The language of the American presidential election is as highly flavoured as the frenetic final countdown to the polls. Susie Dent unravels the terminology
Tomorrow's world! The best new inventions

Tomorrow's world! The best new inventions

Forget digital technology – James Dyson thinks we should focus more on hardware