Gamasutra - Features - Postmortem: Humble Hearts' Dust: An Elysian Tail
My Message close
Postmortem: Humble Hearts' Dust: An Elysian Tail
Printer-Friendly VersionPrinter-Friendly Version
Latest News
spacer View All spacer
November 8, 2012
Jordan Mechner finds his cinematic rhythm with Karateka remake [2]
Game Developer magazine's Power 50: Business
Activision beats estimates by going big, focusing on retail hits [6]
Latest Jobs
spacer View All     Post a Job     RSS spacer
November 8, 2012
GREE International
Game Studio, Android Developer
GREE International
Sr. Analyst, Social Game Platform
GREE International
HTML5 UI Developer
Avalanche Studios
Senior Tools Programmer, New York
Avalanche Studios
Senior Graphics Programmer, New York
ZeniMax Online Studios
Customer Service Analytics Manager
Latest Features
spacer View All spacer
November 8, 2012
arrow Postmortem: Sony Bend Studio's Uncharted: Golden Abyss [1]
arrow Is Game Music All It Can Be? [31]
arrow The End of the Journey: One Indie Studio's Tale [21]
arrow The Tip of the Iceberg: Storytelling and Reactive Design in Canabalt and Capsule [4]
arrow The Tightrope Walk: Hitman Absolution, Freedom, and Realism [8]
arrow How to Design Your iOS Game to Grow: Learning from the Style of Tiger Style [5]
arrow Postmortem: Humble Hearts' Dust: An Elysian Tail [16]
arrow An Assassin's Revolution [3]
Latest Blogs
spacer View All     Post     RSS spacer
November 8, 2012
Making Failure Fun [2]
Quality of Life: Bring more snus! [7]
The Best Political Games of Election 2012 [2]
An argument for easy achievements [46]
Six words about role-playing games [35]
spacer Editor-In-Chief:
Kris Graft
Features Director:
Christian Nutt
News Director:
Frank Cifaldi
Senior Contributing Editor:
Brandon Sheffield
News Editors:
Frank Cifaldi, Tom Curtis, Mike Rose, Eric Caoili, Kris Graft
Leigh Alexander, Chris Morris
Jennifer Sulik
Gina Gross
Feature Submissions
Comment Guidelines
  Postmortem: Humble Hearts' Dust: An Elysian Tail
by Dean Dodrill, Alex Kain [Audio, Design, Postmortem, Production, Art]
16 comments Share on Twitter Share on Facebook RSS
October 31, 2012 Article Start Page 1 of 4 Next

In this candid and detailed postmortem, developer Dean Dodrill tells the tale of the challenging and largely solo development of Summer of Arcade hit Dust: An Elysian Tail, a title that took him over three years to create.

I had always loved video games, and thought making my own would be cool.

Late in 2008 I read an article in OXM detailing what was possible with a new programming language, cryptically called XNA. I had never programmed before, and besides a short contract doing cutscenes for Jazz Jackrabbit 2, had never worked on a video game (I'm actually an animator/illustrator by trade).

For years I had been feeling the call to make my own game -- something small, like an 8-bit NES title. The OXM article convinced me to download the free tools and just try it. Four years later, I released Dust: An Elysian Tail as the headliner of XBLA's Summer of Arcade 2012. Yeah, I can't believe it either.

This is the story of how Dust: AET came to be, along with what went right and wrong during production and launch. Admittedly it was hard to come up with a list, because when you are independent and your livelihood is at stake, you can't afford to let things go wrong.

After convincing my wife that I'd like to take "only three months" off to learn to program and release a small 8-bit-style indie game in early 2009, I downloaded Visual Studio and XNA, and joined Microsoft's XNA development community.

A week of rudimentary tutorials later, I quickly realized you have to make EVERYTHING from scratch! No level editor existed. No animation tool. No scripting or dialogue systems. No nothing -- just a bunch of otherworldly programming words. But that's what made it exciting: learning a new language (literally), slowly making my artwork interactive, and more importantly, growing my aspirations beyond the original 8-bit design.

Most of my education came from online tutorials, and while each one provided valuable insight into the process, very few were directly applicable to what I wanted to achieve. That's when I came across James Silva's book on developing for XNA, which he had written while working on The Dishwasher.

Up until that point, I had committed to working with a blocky tile editor that I had been cobbling together to create my game. His book offered concepts that allowed for much more organic world creation and animation tools. That was the eye-opening moment for me, and an image of a mysterious turquoise character running through a beautiful forest alongside a herd of deer cemented itself into my brain.

What Went Right

1. Crafting The World and Characters

First things first: I needed a protagonist. He needed a unique silhouette, easily readable from a distance and exaggerated in motion. He would be fully animated in the traditional Disney sense.

Animating "Dust", as the protagonist would be called, was time-consuming. I would rough out each motion with pencil on paper, and then do a digital pencil test. When I was happy with the motion, I would ink each frame on my light table, scan the artwork into Photoshop, and then separate the shadow layer out and do cleanup/color/shading (a technique I developed while working on my film). Finally, I would composite a CG animated weapon into each frame to create the final artwork.

Each frame would be downsampled from film res to a 300x300 block, and arranged neatly on a sprite sheet. In the end Dust himself comprised over 500 unique frames of animation, across four massive 4k sprite sheets. Dust alone used up most of the RAM available on the Xbox 360.

The character editor was created in tandem with the artwork. The editor was also customized to handle segmented characters, which ended up comprising the rest of the cast.

Dust (the early working title, later changed to Dust: An Elysian Tail to make it searchable, and to tie it into my existing IP) would be an open-world mix of genres, where the player could gain new abilities and take on side quests from non-playable characters, and feature a simple leveling-up and loot system. My largest inspirations were Blaster Master, Monster World, Cadash, Strider, and Castlevania.

Again, with the help of James' book, I crafted a level editor that would allow me to incorporate my skills as a painter. Small pieces of background art would be digitally painted with a Wacom using a custom set of brushes in Painter, then assembled into 4k sprite sheets. Segments could be scaled, rotated, tinted, and flagged for motion and particles through the editor.

The final game ended up featuring over 230 handcrafted maps -- individual gameplay areas assembled into a number of themed regions, all accessible from a central world map. Creating the background assets and maps ended up being the most time-consuming task through the entire production. I stuck with familiar themes for areas to reflect my preference for older games. A Metroid style mini-map was retroactively implemented later in development.

One of the first systems to be written (and rewritten, and rewritten) was the particle system. This might have been one of my favorite areas to work in, making everything spark, glow, or just come to life in some way. In Dust: AET, a particle could be as simple as a floating mote, or as complicated as an entire avalanche, spawning hundreds of new particles in its wake. A dynamic weather system was also implemented to bring the world to life.

Immediately after my first sketches of Dust, I created his flying companion, Fidget. I needed a character at his side to help the narrative along, and to compliment/contrast his personality. And really, that's all Fidget was good for, mechanically. At first, anyway.

I was showing my brother how maps were assembled, using hundreds of sprites. We joked how funny it would be if the world around you were sucked into a spin move I had animated, since it was technically possible, if not a bit ridiculous. It dawned on me that I could expand on the simple throw axe/knife/what-have-you of a Castlevania and do something flashier with projectiles.

I animated Dust throwing out a projectile and programmed what would become the Dust Storm. The problem was that you had to stop running as he threw the projectile from his hand, and it killed the flow of combat. Then I realized I had this floating character following you the whole time. I had Fidget cast the projectiles, created some animation and code, and the combat clicked.

Dust: AET finally had its signature mechanic, and it looked and felt very, very cool. The next thing I needed was for it to sound very, very cool.

Article Start Page 1 of 4 Next

Thomas Happ
profile image
What I have always wondered is, did Microsoft provide any sort of cash advance with which to support yourself, or was it all out of pocket?

Thanks for the awesomely detailed postmortem, Dean. You're an inspiration!!

Ramon Carroll
profile image
Wow, this was a really good read. Thank you so much for sharing this, Dean.

Alfie Parthum
profile image
Dean, when I was a much younger man, I used to post on your forums. I really wanted to know how it was done! Even after seeing so much of the magic in its unfinished state, even knowing how itís made, the level of craftsmanship and creativity present in your art still never fails to amaze me. This postmortem was also enlightening.

Iím happy to hear you have been able to apply your particular brand of assiduity to game development as well, and that your family life is still great. Thanks for sharing.

Muir Freeland
profile image
This is a great postmortem, and this is a really beautiful-looking game.

Josh Mulanax
profile image
Fantastic write up Dean - I know I'm not alone when I say that I hope to see more games from you in the future!

Kevin Gadd
profile image
Thanks for sharing a postmortem, Dean! Love the amount of detail in here.

Per Micael Nyberg
profile image
Dean, Thank you for sharing your difficult but ultimately rewarding and life-altering journey with us. Great read!

Talat Fakhri
profile image
The story is sheer inspiration. The process of making the game itself sounded like a hardcore game.

Lars Doucet
profile image
What I think is really cool about this story, is how Dean wasn't afraid to learn new skills and techniques out of his safety zone, and created something brilliant.

Alexei Baboulevitch
profile image
Amazing work, but it worries me that this is yet another indie game where the creator nearly tore himself apart trying to put it together. I'd love to know ó is it really impossible to create a game with similar quality while maintaining a healthy five-day work week? I'd love to make a game as personal as this some day, but I don't know if I could sacrifice my health and social life for it.

On another note, this is an incredible achievement for someone who didn't know how to program getting into it. I'm a programmer and I know I'd have a lot of difficulty with some of these problems.

Lars Doucet
profile image
I've done alright keeping a regular work schedule with my own indie projects, but whether it's of "similar quality" is an exercise best left to the reader. I think it's possible to maintain work-life balance, but there's also just an undeniable element of risk involved.

Ramon Carroll
profile image
I think the key question to ask is: Why do we do what we do? Once a person resolves that question himself/herself, then one can determine whether an endeavor is worth his/her time.

Hint: Wealth and fame only satisfy for a season. Autonomy, mastery, and purpose are forever.

profile image
You could do it without the sacrifice but remember that it took this guy 3.5 years working 7 days a week. At a leisurely pace it's probably going to take you significantly longer than that.

On a related note though, this was a passion project for him. Do what you do but if you're not willing to make some sacrifices for it you could probably find a significantly less stressful hobby to get into.

Kain Shin
profile image
The game has so much love put into it, and it really shows in just about every detail.

Keith Thomson
profile image
This sounds like exactly the sort of game I would want, hopefully it will come out on other platforms in the future. Given the steep memory requirements, I can only think of 2 other platforms it would work on though.

Taure Anthony
profile image
Easily one of the best reads on here, thanks for talking the time. The game looks epic.


UBM Tech