Nationals all-star Bryce Harper’s unique contract could lead to a grievance hearing

Jonathan Newton/The Washington Post - Bryce Harper, shown at the 2013 All-Star Game, could find himself on the opposite side of a legal dispute with the Nationals next offseason.

As the Washington Nationals seek to augment a roster core they believe is built for long-term success, an unusual and previously unreported aspect of outfielder Bryce Harper’s contract remains unresolved.

Harper, the No. 1 overall selection in the 2010 draft, reached an oral agreement on his current deal less than a minute before the Aug. 16 midnight deadline to sign picks. The five-year major league contract, rare for a draftee, called for Harper to be paid $9.9 million, including a signing bonus of $6.25 million. However, the Nationals insisted that the contract not contain a clause that would allow Harper to opt out of the contract terms and into baseball’s lucrative salary arbitration system once he was eligible; Harper’s agent, Scott Boras, was equally adamant that the virtually standard opt-out clause be included.

More MLB coverage

Harper, Nats have unresolved contract issue

Harper, Nats have unresolved contract issue

Bryce Harper could be eligible for arbitration after the 2014 season, but a grievance hearing might come first.

Nationals interested in Perez

Nationals interested in Perez

As the Nationals cast a wide net for lefty relief help, they have expressed interest in Oliver Perez.

Wrapping up awards season, Jayson Werth’s finish in MVP voting

Wrapping up awards season, Jayson Werth’s finish in MVP voting

Looking back at the seasons of two of the Nationals’ standouts this season -- Jordan Zimmermann and Jayson Werth -- who placed in award voting.

McCutchen, Cabrera win MVP awards

McCutchen, Cabrera win MVP awards

Pirates center fielder receives 28 of 30 first-place votes while Detroit’s Miguel Cabrera grabs hardware in AL for second consecutive year.

Boras: Strasburg played hurt

Boras: Strasburg played hurt

Stephen Strasbrug pitched a “good amount” of the 2013 season with pain his forearm from bone chips, his agent says.

Complete coverage

Nationals Journal

Nationals Journal

Insight on the Nationals and all the latest news from Post reporters Adam Kilgore and James Wagner.

Days later, the Nationals presented a final written contract that did not contain an opt-out clause. Anticipating the possibility that Harper, at the time 17, could reach the majors sooner than expected, Boras and the Harper family refused to sign it.

At that time, Major League Baseball and the Players Association took the unusual step of interceding with a compromise: a letter of agreement stating that, if Harper qualified for salary arbitration before he reached the end of the contract, a grievance hearing would determine whether he could opt of his contract.

Boras and two other people familiar with Harper’s contract confirmed the unusual arrangement. It means that, barring some resolution in the interim, Harper and the Nationals could find themselves on opposite sides of a legal dispute next offseason.

“We reached an agreement with MLB and the MLBPA memorializing that Bryce only signed with the Nationals on the condition that his rights were preserved,” Boras said. “So, as planned when the issue arises, we will proceed under the terms of that agreement.”

Under normal circumstances, players qualify for salary arbitration after accruing three full seasons of major league service time. Among the players with between two and three years in the majors, the top 22 percent in service time are eligible for arbitration early. Following the 2014 season, Harper almost certainly will be among this latter group, known as “Super Two” players.

In the arbitration process, an independent panel, after hearing from both the player and his team, decides on the player’s one-year contract value based on service time, the salaries of comparable players and any special awards. Most players and teams agree to a new salary before a hearing is held. Either way, practically speaking, the process usually means huge raises for players.

In the case of Harper, the 2012 National League rookie of the year and a two-time all-star, his draft deal calls for him to earn $1.5 million in 2015. Presuming he remains healthy and continues to perform at projected levels in 2014, he could land a 2015 salary between $4 million and $7 million through arbitration, were he eligible. Were Harper to get hurt or to decline in performance, he likely would make less.

Loading...

Comments

Add your comment
 
Read what others are saying About Badges