I Object!

Our legal correspondent lists the ways TV sets up new attorneys for crushing disappointment.

Photo: ABC

Photo: ABC

Careers WeekUntil this past fall, I practiced law, full-time, at a large international firm. My life consequently was much worse than it is now. I mean: I barely had time for TV. Sometimes, as I'd sit at the office late at night, missing yet another Real Housewives reunion special, I'd question why I ever became an attorney in the first place. Then I'd think: Oh, yeah -- television.

The thing is, television lied to me. It's lied to all of us. As long as television has been around, it's been promoting the myth that a career in law, like a career in medicine, is exciting, glamorous -- sexy, even. To be clear: it's none of those things. On the contrary, practicing law, in my experience, is one of the most deeply unsexy things one can do as a career, right up there with telemarketing, working at Dress Barn, and selling motorized scooters. I'm not saying there's not value in being an attorney (although I'm not not saying that, either), but chances are, if you're a lawyer, your life looks nothing like what TV told you it would look like.

Think of all the shows in which lawyers have appeared as happy, attractive, and vital individuals, with plenty of time for meals and sex and witty banter: Ally McBeal, Boston Legal, The Practice, LA Law, Harry's Law, Night Court. But we don't have all day, so let's just take a look at five egregious examples, ranked in order of how misleading they are, of how TV has misrepresented what it's like to be a lawyer.

1. Law & Order SVU

Premise: The District Attorney's office prosecutes the cases brought in by the dedicated detectives who investigate sexually-based, vicious felonies. Chung chung!

Why it's unrealistic: Attorneys, by and large, do not look like the ladies of the fictional DA's office on this show. So, okay, maybe Alex Cabot (Stephanie March) and Casey Novak (Diane Neal) aren't walking the runways of Paris, but they could definitely do catalog.

Why it's realistic: Sonya Paxton, the drunk ADA portrayed by Christine Lahti, seems like she could happen. Fact: alcoholism is actually a big problem among lawyers. See what I'm saying about it not being a sexy career, you guys?

Bottom line: If you want to work as a prosecutor in New York, please send a headshot and your modeling portfolio to the DA's office, and you might just have a shot.

2. Scandal

Premise: Crusading U.S. Attorney David Rosen (Josh Malina) gets on the wrong side of Olivia Pope (Kerry Washington), Fixer of Scandals, Destroyer of Men.

Why it's unrealistic: Rosen, when he's not uncovering huge, game-changing vote-rigging scandals, seems to have plenty of time to sleep with attractive women and exchange long-winded and unprofessional banter with his young, pretty assistant in his tastefully appointed office. In real life, though, U.S. Attorneys are super-busy, especially U.S. Attorneys for the District of Columbia, who are responsible for prosecuting local criminal cases in DC as well as representing the U.S. in civil law cases. In real life, Rosen would spend most of his time in the hallway of the DC Superior Court, eating a meatball sub standing up while waiting to argue a DUI case.

Why it's realistic: David Rosen's life gets ruined by someone with a cooler job than his.

Bottom line: Don't eff with Olivia Pope.

3. Suits

Premise: A lawyer who's looking for an associate hires a brilliant college dropout with NO LAW DEGREE for the job.

Why it's unrealistic: This wouldn't happen even in California, where the rules about who can become a lawyer are more flexible than Gumby. It's fun to think that, to thrive as an attorney, all you need are street smarts, a la Dodger from Oliver & Company, as voiced (unforgettably!) by Billy Joel. Turns out, the American Bar Association thinks differently, no matter how many sausage links you can snag in your mouth.

Why it's realistic: Ignoring the ethics, regulations, and bylaws involved, you don't actually need a law degree to practice law. A monkey could do this stuff, folks.

Bottom line: But yeah, go ahead and go to law school before trying to seek employment at a law firm, just to be on the safe side.

4. The Deep End

Premise: A number of model-esque law-school graduates start work at a prestigious L.A. law firm and must deal with cases that challenge their personal ethics.

Why it's unrealistic: For one thing, "prestigious" law firms don't tend to have sexy rooftop bars and pools, and the lawyers who work at such firms don't get off at five for cocktail hour. Second, lawyers, even in Los Angeles, do not wear stilettos, bandage skirts, and boob-popping tops to work. Third, and I hate to dash the hopes of wannabe attorneys here, but Billy Zane will not be your boss. Fourth, first-year litigation associates don't get to have client contact, let alone contact with celebrities and tycoons and other important rich people.

Why it's realistic: Creator David Hemingson supposedly based the series on his own experiences as a lawyer, although I question whether Hemingson actually was an attorney or just had a really vivid sex dream that took place in a law firm and got confused.

Bottom line: Don't expect to be playfully pushed into the (non-existent) pool on the first day of work at your law firm. Also, please don't wear a v-neck tee shirt with an open blazer over it to work. Where do you think you are, Samantha Jones's PR firm?

5. Fairly Legal

Premise: Our "quirky" heroine, Kate Reed (Sarah Shahi), quits her job as a litigator and becomes a mediator at the San Francisco law firm started by her late father.

Why it's unrealistic: First thing: law firms don't tend to employ mediators. That would sort of, you know, defeat the purpose of having a law firm. Second thing: it's really hard to become a mediator, and it takes years, if not decades. One does not simply quit one's job as an attorney and decide to become a mediator. Third thing: in the show, Reed's job consists of wearing cute clothes, going for coffee and lunch, and then meeting with harried but attractive clients, all of whom she assures she'll be able to bring positive results. Setting aside the fact that as a rule, mediators don't guarantee anyone anything, an actual mediator would be thirty years older, a hell of a lot poorer, and would not be mediating disputes involving feuding boy bands.

Why it's realistic: It's not.

Bottom line: Free advice: if you run a litigation firm, don't employ a mediator who will convince parties not to litigate. You're welcome.

So, still want to be a lawyer? Go for it! Just don't expect to find attractive coworkers, pools, drinks, Billy Zane, cute mediators, a relaxed attitude about your lack of law degree, stilettos, or free time. Have fun!

Share
Discuss
   
  • ApathyMonger

    Ah, The Deep End. I watched all seven episodes of that show, just for Tina Majorino and Clancy Brown. Probably the most blatent attempt to copy the Grey's Anatomy formula I've seen.

    Also one of the the most blatent "oops, we forgot to put any non-white characters in our show, here's an extra guy" scenes added to the pilot.

  • Stephanie Green

    Yes, the incoming associates were a veritable rainbow of white people! But there was that one black guy, so, you know, everything's fine.

  • Claire

    I started watching Suits right before becoming a paralegal, and mostly it gave me unrealistic ideas of how uncluttered and free of files my office would be.

  • Kristin Roe

    I would like to add to those watch Franklin & Bash that a new partner in your firm would not, in fact, have a naked hot tub party and if he did? Congrats, your student loans will be paid by the settlement.

  • TaraAriano

    I totally hear you, but God, I loved stupid "Fairly Legal" SO MUCH. Her outfits: so cute!

    Also: please tell me you watched "Century City."

  • Stephanie Green

    Her outfits WERE cute and she had good hair. Which adds to the cruelty of the fantasy that show perpetuated for wannabe mediators, actually. And no, never seen Century City. Did I miss something good?

  • TaraAriano

    nnnnnnno. It was set at a law firm in the FUTURE. Ioan Gruffudd, Viola Davis, Nestor Carbonell, Hector Elizondo, AND MORE!

  • http://glark.org/ David T. Cole

    SPAAAAAAAACE LAWYERS!

  • Lis

    The thing about Suits... Why don't they just never have him go to court or sign pleadings?? I mean then no one's breaking the law... they're being shady to their other employees sure, but if Harvey just always introduces him as his assistant then they're in the clear ethically. It's just so STUPID. Harvey has enough pull to get this done within the firm and still keep them from constantly being at risk for being sued by unhappy clients.

    I'm a legal assistant (omg! just like Donna!! snark) and if my boss ever asked me to do half the things that these attorneys ask of their assistants I'd get one hell of a settlement when I sued them. AND yes to Claire re. the uncluttered and free of files office reference. Also in general these firms are way to shiny and fancy... Where are all the file cabinets? Where are all the redwells of paper? The bank boxes of closed files going to the warehouse? The CASES? I mean Harvey seems to only ever have one case going on at a time and yet he still needs to be at work until midnight? He's kind of a crap attorney. Also don't get me started on the fact that in real life (at least in my experience) "lawyers" never call themselves or others "lawyers" they ALWAYS say "attorney" I've asked, no one can explain it to me, but apparently it is preferred.

  • Sara Bibel

    I love this article because I live in L.A., land of lawyers turned writers (fun fact: you don't automatically become David Kelley). Stephanie, I would like to know your thoughts on The Good Wife

  • Stephanie Green

    Confession: I've never seen The Good Wife. Is it... good?

  • ApathyMonger

    I love The Good Wife. Great fun, and definitely worth catching up on. There's some bad patches, but it always recovers.

  • Stephanie Green

    My mom watches it and I've heard good things. If I have an upcoming TV lull, I might check it out.

  • Jeff Drake

    I can't believe I missed that one. I love shows about space lawyers.

  • c8h10n4o2

    Attorney has more syllables. Say it enough and you get more billable hours!

    Yes, I'm a jaded non-lawyer in the legal field.

  • Stephanie Green

    FYI: http://www.lawyeredu.org/attorney-vs-lawyer.html. I always thought the difference was that an attorney had passed the bar exam and been sworn in.

  • Lis

    Stephanie, it looks like you're right, which makes it all the more amazing that none of the attorneys I've asked have given me that answer!

Topics
Newer
»
 
Older
«