Jerusalem alert level raised following second day of violence
Israel shrugs off PA decision to delay UN Security Council plan
IDF closely monitoring Hamas attempts to rearm
Sinai smugglers’ attack on IDF troops a ‘game-changer’
Recording released of eyewitness emergency call from scene of Jerusalem terror attack
Court bars Olmert’s lawyers from hearing misplaced Zaken CDs
Livni: Irresponsible Israeli politicians must stop stoking flames in Jerusalem
Coalition crisis ends with forming of committee
Netanyahu moves to tamp down new election momentum
Rates of bariatric surgery have doubled since 2012
Doctors remove pen cap from boy's lung, warn of dangers of sucking on pen caps
Ministry uploads comparative data on health funds
MDA calls for blood donations after High Holidays shortage
Five scientific balloons to launch simultaneously Wednesday in Israel, Europe
Tel Aviv U. launches fuel substitutes accelerator
US agency gives $1 million to boost Israeli Arabs in hi-tech
Israeli gas firm signs bid to sell natural gas to Egypt
Israel surely in 'front line' for climate refugees, says expert
Renée Zellweger responds to Twitter’s shock at her current appearance
Lord of the dance to play ‘Dangerous Games’ in Israel
Blue-and-white on the silver screen
Show Review: Cirque Eloize - Cirkopolis
Mac Haifa hosts Ra’anana hoping to get campaign on track
Maccabi TA yet again outplayed in Moscow
IFA punishes Sakhnin with NIS 15K slap on wrist for honoring Bishara
Maccabi Tel Aviv poised for first real test at old nemesis CSKA
Women of the Wall smuggle tiny Torah scroll to Western Wall for Bat Mitzva
Pro-Israel German-language Jewish magazine launches
Jewish leaders alarmed by UKIP’s new European ally
Jewish leader compares eastern Ukraine to Gaza
Israeli youth now eligible for work permits in Australia
World Jewish Congress flips on Nazi pensions
Kuwait bolsters secondary boycott of Israel
Across party lines, Congress seeks more details from Iran talks
Most Americans unclear on objective in ISIS fight
European Rabbis worried over Mideast Christians
Erdogan says agreement reached for 200 Kurdish Peshmerga fighters to enter Kobani
Aliya’s historic shift – from rescue to free choice
Column One: It’s time to beat the Jew-haters
Parshat Noah: Caring as a remedy for corruption
The library for Israel and the Jewish world
Does Islamic State pose a threat to us?
Guarantor of the natural world
The fierce estuary of memory
Crossroad to nowhere
Rescue
What happened to Renée Zellweger?
Staying honest in the ‘Wild East’
Book Review: Expectations and reality
Book Review: Dancing with the Iranian devil
Granddad’s trees
Grapevine: Synagogue spirit
A very ‘Jerusalem’ chief rabbi race
Staying put?
Grapevine: A worthy ‘Hatan Torah’
Transcending trends
City Notes: Haifa holds viewing event in response to soccer ticket protest
A long way from the countryside
Is Israel safer Than America?
Sacrificing for a dignified life on Earth: Israel, justice and human redemption
Shirt-fronting Putin can help eradicate Islamic State crisis
How the media helps perpetuate a high cost of living
A song for TISHREI: 'A good word'
סִימָנִים עַל הַחוֹל
פֶסְטִיבַל שֶקְסְפִּיר הַבֵּינְלְאוּמִי
‘Russia’s goal is to destabilize the EU and NATO’
The way we were?
Speaking the same language
Work and play
The newest frontier in Judaica: 3D printing kippot
Grapevine: Music as a bridge
Starcatcher
Frontlines Podcast: Is there a 'silent intifada' in Jerusalem?
Ask the Rabbi: Is revenge a Jewish value?
Un pied dans le monde du travail israélien
L’incendiaire de la mosquée al-Aqsa
« Tsahal sait très bien s’occuper de ses soldats »
« Avraham ouvrait sa porte à tous »
1909-1942 : onze femmes, un destin
Depuis 30 ans, Haïfa fait son cinéma
La fabuleuse histoire de Pitigliano
Ein Mata, l’un des secrets les mieux gardés de la vallée d’Eila
Netanyahou sort les griffes pour Jérusalem
Coalition américaine contre l’Etat islamique : quel rôle pour les pays arabes ?
Israël au pied du mur
Retour sur l’opération Bordure protectrice : décryptage de la situation moyen-orientale
Il est temps de changer de partenaire
David Azrieli, 1922-2014
Dimanche 13 juillet
Deux familles, une histoire
Une gauche en perte de repères
Bennett : le vent en poupe
Et tu choisiras la vie
Les rêves déçus de Gabi
Pope Paul VI, first pontiff to visit Israel, moves closer to sainthood
Dutch Christians boycott church over exhibit on Palestinian children
Christian Pastor warns Ebola is God's Punishment for Obama dividing Jerusalem
Evangelical support for Israel? Look to the east
Vatican promotes military force in to protect Christians from Islamic Extremism
Free Schach Distribution in Honor of Sukkot
Covenant of Brothers, Covenant of Life
Celebrating the New Year in KKL-JNF Parks and Forests
International Cleanup Day in Ashkelon
Central America Celebrates Independence at the Rabin Center
European Parliament Member Bastiaan Belder Tours the Negev
KKL-JNF Helps Chile Deal with the Gall Wasp Pest
KKL-JNF and Fair Planet in Ethiopia–Seeds of Hope
Cleanup Day Activities in Central Israel
International Cleanup Day: Cleaning Together in Northern Israel
Care of the Forests Continues Even in a Sabbatical Year
Nevatim Celebrates 60 Years and Dedicates a New Reservoir
A Successful Annual Fundraising Event for KKL Milan
Der Wienerwald in Israel - The Vienna Woods in Israel
AFTER DAYS OF WAR, GIVING KIDS A CHANCE TO BE KIDS
European Leadership Conference 2014 - Brussels, Belgium
Living Green in Israel: the Contest and the Winners
Addressing Climate Change Conference
Nurturing the Foresters of the Future
Saving the Sabras
10.24.2014 | 30 Tishri, 5775
Leaving for Berlin? Maybe you’ll pay less for Milky, but what will you tell your grandchildren?
Another Tack: The 14th century in Washington
Know Comment: The power of Shabbat
Sinai Today: On the eve of making history together
Into the Fray: Let their people go!
My Word: The royal peace
October 24: FM and football
Opinion
By JPOST EDITORIAL \
09/11/2014 23:02
Intervention’s limits
US President Barack Obama delivers a statement on the situation in Iraq from his vacation home at Martha's Vineyard, Massachusetts.. (photo credit:REUTERS)
President Barack Obama won the presidency in 2008 in part based on his promise to pull out American soldiers from Iraq and Afghanistan. Numerous surveys have shown that keeping US troops out of Iraq and others places in the region remains popular among Americans.In a speech given on the eve of the 13th anniversary of 9/11, in which he laid out his strategy for countering Islamic State, Obama remained faithful to his belief that US troops should not be on the ground.“As I have said before, these American forces will not have a combat mission – we will not get dragged into another ground war in Iraq,” Obama said, referring to a few hundred American servicemen dispatched to Iraq in June to provide intelligence, training and logistical support to Iraqi and Kurdish forces.When he discussed the dangers to Americans that might result from a more aggressive offensive against Islamic State, Obama added, “But I want the American people to understand how this effort will be different from the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. It will not involve American combat troops fighting on foreign soil.”Instead, he proposed providing aid and air cover to populations in Syria and Iraqi opposed to Islamic State, while refraining from providing support to the Assad regime.Many critics of Obama on the Right have accused him of showing weakness in his policies toward the region. They cite as proof his decision during his first term in office to pull out all American troops from Iraq and his push during his second term to hasten US departure from Afghanistan.In an editorial titled “Dick Cheney is still right,” The Wall Street Journal blamed Syria’s deterioration into “a terrorist sanctuary from which the Islamic State has conquered a third of Iraq” on Obama’s “peace-through-withdrawal” strategy. The same went for the expansion of al-Qaida affiliates across the Middle East and Africa.But is Obama’s foreign policy really to blame? The problems with Western intervention in Syria remain the same today as they did from the outset of the civil war. So-called moderate rebel groups remain divided and ineffective.To succeed, air strikes need to be followed up by ground troops who can recapture and hold territory against Islamic State. The experience of the US’s invasion of Iraq has taught the world that foreign troops cannot be a surrogate for local forces.That is not to say Obama has completely lived up to the “Don’t do stupid things” mantra that encapsulates White House thinking about foreign policy issues. He offered only muted support for the 2009 Green Revolution in Iran, the first serious grassroots democratic uprising since the ayatollahs took over in 1979.His demand that Israel impose a building freeze as a precondition for talks with the PLO at the end of 2009 served only to further harden an already intransigent Palestinian political leadership that seems incapable of taking responsibility for its own state-building. Backtracking on his redline regarding the Assad regime’s barbaric use of chemical weapons against rebels in Syria was both embarrassing and damaging to US deterrence.Obama has made some stupid comments. In January, in an interview with The New Yorker, he compared Islamic State to a “jayvee” [junior varsity] team. Just last month during a discussion of his strategy to fight Islamic State he admitted, “I don’t want to put the cart before the horse. We don’t have a strategy yet.”But Republicans have little to offer as an alternative.Suggestions for combating Islamic State, put forth by Sens. John McCain and Lindsey Graham in a recent op-ed in the New York Times, are almost identical to Obama’s strategy.Like him, they suggest expanding US-led air attacks to Syria. And Americans view skeptically McCain’s claim that a large contingent of US troops should have remained in Iraq after 2011.Over the decade since the invasion of Iraq, Republicans and Democrats alike have learned the hard way the limits of the US’s ability to effect change. Afghanistan and Libya offer additional examples of how difficult, if not impossible, regime change can be. In contrast, Egypt is proof that regime change is possible when the local population is actively involved in the shaping of its future.Ultimately, Syrians, Iraqis and other peoples in the region will have to sort out their own problems and take responsibility for their own destinies. Obama speech on the 13th anniversary of 9/11 reflected this hard-learned fact.
Your comment must be approved by a moderator before being published on JPost.com. Disqus users can post comments automatically. Comments must adhere to our Talkback policy. If you believe that a comment has breached the Talkback policy, please press the flag icon to bring it to the attention of our moderation team.
Sign up for our newsletter
Please insert a valid email address
By signing up to The Jpost mailing list, I hereby
Tags