Breaking down the numbers: One third of Americans believe police lie routinely

By Bill Schneider
January 15, 2015

A protester yells at a line of police officers during a demonstration against the grand jury decision in the Ferguson, Missouri shooting of Michael Brown in San Francisco, California

Do police officers “routinely lie to serve their own interests?” Thirty-one percent of Americans believe they do, and that number rises to 45 percent among African-Americans, 41 percent among young people and 39 percent among Democrats. Republicans reject that charge three to one (60 to 20 percent).

Screen Shot 2015-01-15 at 6.35.12 AM

Those numbers come from a national poll of Americans just conducted by Reuters and the Ipsos polling organization. (Explore the full results here.) Still, the image of the police is more controversial than the reality.

Asked whether they approve of the job being done by “your local police department,” nearly three quarters of Americans say they approve. Approval is high among African-Americans (56 percent) as well as whites (77 percent), among Democrats (72 percent) as well as Republicans (84 percent).

On the other hand, the public is divided over whether “Police officers tend to unfairly target minorities” (37 percent agree, 43 percent disagree). African-Americans and Latinos believe the police do target minorities (69 percent and 54 percent, respectively). Fewer than a third of whites feel that way (29 percent).

Screen Shot 2015-01-15 at 6.42.56 AM

The racist image of the police is strongly influenced by politics. A majority of Democrats (53 percent) believe the police unfairly target minorities. Only 19 percent of Republicans agree.

Young people don’t trust the police. That’s not surprising. They’re the ones most likely to get into trouble. In the Reuters poll, young people were more than twice as likely as seniors to endorse the view that police officers tend to unfairly target minorities (53 percent among Americans under 30, 25 percent among those 60 and older).

These days, young Americans are much more likely than seniors to live in a multicultural world and to interact with minorities. Even young whites were more than twice as likely as white seniors to brand the police as racist (42 percent of young whites but only 20 percent of white seniors).

Do Americans “trust the police to be fair and just?” Most do (53 percent). But that, too, is a political issue. Only 30 percent of African-Americans, 43 percent of young people and 47 percent of Democrats say they trust the police to be fair and just. Trust in the police is much higher among seniors (67 percent) and Republicans (70 percent).

Screen Shot 2015-01-15 at 6.45.36 AM

Overall, these findings are reminiscent of research showing that Americans tend to be highly critical of Congress, while they hold a favorable view of “your own congressman.” That’s why they regularly re-elect over 90 percent of congressional incumbents even while denouncing the institution.Education researchers have found that college students tend to give low marks when asked to assess the quality of teaching in their schools. However, when asked to rate the quality of the teacher in the most recent class they attended, the marks come out much higher.

The same rule appears to apply to people’s view of the police: “The police may tend to be unfair and racist, but police officers around here are O.K.”

The poll also asked people whether they have a favorable impression of the Ferguson police department. Very few Americans have any experience with the Ferguson police department. They probably didn’t even know Ferguson was a town in Missouri a year ago. Only 21,000 people live there, out of 316 million Americans. What the public knows about the Ferguson police is what they see on television and read in the news.

And that is intensely political — and racial. Sixty-two percent of Americans say they have a favorable impression of the Ferguson police. But there’s a huge difference between African-Americans (32 percent favorable) and whites (69 percent). Republicans are overwhelmingly favorable to the Ferguson police (85 percent). Democrats are divided (51 percent favorable, 49 percent unfavorable).

One question was surprisingly less divisive: “Would you approve of your children (or future children) becoming police officers?” Americans as a whole say yes, 59 to 22 percent. Young people? 68 percent yes. Democrats? 58 percent yes. African-Americans? More tentative, but still favorable. By 45 to 30 percent, blacks approve of their children becoming police officers. In this case, reality — “It’s a good job” — is more positive than image.

PHOTO: A protester yells at a line of police officers during a demonstration against the grand jury decision in the Ferguson, Missouri shooting of Michael Brown in San Francisco, California, Nov. 28, 2014. REUTERS/Elijah Nouvelage

16 comments

We welcome comments that advance the story through relevant opinion, anecdotes, links and data. If you see a comment that you believe is irrelevant or inappropriate, you can flag it to our editors by using the report abuse links. Views expressed in the comments do not represent those of Reuters. For more information on our comment policy, see http://blogs.reuters.com/fulldisclosure/2010/09/27/toward-a-more-thoughtful-conversation-on-stories/

That would still make them better than the general population and a million times better than, nearly any, politician.

Posted by kevin2oh | Report as abusive

Where is the statistic about how much the public lies? What about the percentage of scofflaws that exist? The number of people that routine break the laws and screw over their neighbors on a constant basis? What is the statistic on how many anarchists exist in the USA? What is the statistic about the number of psychotic people that are roaming the streets at any given moment?

Posted by SixthRomeo | Report as abusive

It means two thirds aren’t paying enough attention…

Posted by EndlessIke | Report as abusive

How would whites know if minorities were targeted unfairly? It’s silly to include their opinion since a white person would have no idea how other people are being targeted. As far a cops lying I absolutely agree. I am a white guy with a clean record except for traffic related incidents and even I have experienced cops outright lying on several occasions.

Posted by oakpkdude | Report as abusive

I really think the PD in my area is honest and little too soft when dealing with the Liberians.

Posted by Macedonian | Report as abusive

Police are just people. They do not deserve exceptional powers. You do not have to speak to police or agree to a search of any kind. Even when you are totally innocent, give them nothing. Make them work for it, it’s their job. They are public servants and they work for you. Always ask: “Am I being charged, or am I free to go.” They are required to pick one. And if they charge you, the charges can’t just be their feellings. They need to have a basis in law, and they need to be written up. Police are just. Treat them with basic human respect, and no more. They are not special or above anyone.

Posted by AlkalineState | Report as abusive

The opinions of the public are formed by watching TV. This makes them generally imbeciles, which is why they vote in their same corrupt politicians, because they are imbeciles. The Police are a necessary entity for any society, but the problem isn’t most police but some police and there is never a time when any police union or other police officer admits that a policeman has been at fault. That is the point when the police become corrupt too. It is not possible that there is never a policeman at fault. So, they become as slimy as our politicians and supreme court. They are corrupt and absolute in their denials and unapologetic about the deaths of Americans. Sometimes they are doing their jobs, but it is impossible that they are never at fault. This lets us know too that the criminal justice system that never finds fault with itself or it’s soldiers is also corrupt. Most crimes are committed by whites and most prisoners are not white. Comments on the population are stupid since most people are just followers. They see the corruption in the system, it’s obvious to anyone who is awake, and they think what the heck, everyone is a dishonest crook, so only a fool is honest. So, so what if the people are crooked, they learned from the owners and masters, and their minions in the criminal justice system. And really, isn’t what they think true. If all our leaders and the corporations and the police and the criminal justice system are corrupt, and they are, then who is honest? Just the stupid fools who think that is the way it should be, just the fools.

Posted by brotherkenny4 | Report as abusive

the 60% response just goes to show that all those cop shows on TV are doing their job at providing positive PR for the police (state) – if they knew how the cops view them, they wouldn’t be so sanguine.

Posted by wilhelm | Report as abusive

1/3 lie?? ho! a NYTimes (IIRC) investigation across several NE states revealed the liars held, at a minimum, a 90% majority. even cases where open perjury in court (against video evidence, no less), blatant falsehoods on sworn statements or depositions, criminal investigations and reports, or charges filed against innocent people, if an LEO was ever charged there are no known convictions in any court. ever.
so, if the man in front of you has a badge and a gun, the odds are pretty good he’s a liar, and not to be trusted.
sad.
the USA used to be the one country where a person did not live in fear of their police. and the first question they ask, is “why did you run?”. indeed.

Posted by KelevAdom | Report as abusive

It seems to me that this sample set was not representative of the American public.

Posted by jgenauer | Report as abusive

police need to protect and serve only. if no one is in danger and no one needs assistance they have no right to bother anyone. just do your job.

Posted by potehid | Report as abusive

If you don’t support your own country’s police force then leave go to a country that you do support. IF you can’t stand behind your police then feel free to stand in front of them.

Posted by betrayed | Report as abusive

Nothing like the lies that are directed at them.

Posted by Redford | Report as abusive

Police officers are not in the business of creating doubt. They testify to make the case. Creative testimony to bring a perp to justice occurs. Looking on the bright side, many of the convicted actually did commit a crime.

Posted by JimTheDiver | Report as abusive

The title of this article is silly. Everybody lies at least once in a while. Even the Pope has lied. So what.

Posted by 123456951 | Report as abusive

Your statement of “What the public knows about the Ferguson police is what they see on television and read in the news”. Therein lies a huge problem because so often media slants the news to reflect their views. They showed Michael Brown as nice boy with a happy face instead of what he had become. I just viewed a video of Brown knocking an elderly man to the ground, kicking him then stealing his belongings. Is this the real Michael Brown? Would the people be rioting if they knew Brown was a felon and a bully and a thug that seemed enjoy beating up people smaller then him. By not reporting the real truth the media is inciting people to behave badly which I guess “sells newspapers”.

The media should be ashamed.

Posted by fedupaj | Report as abusive