12 posts / 0 new
Last post
twentyenginerunner
twentyenginerunner's picture
Contributor
Offline
Last seen: 20 hours 2 min ago
Joined: 05/17/2014 - 19:43
Karma: 351
Blog entry #2

Redesigning the Seyda Neen Lighthouse

Written by Twentyenginerunner

The lighthouse in Seyda Neen is one of the first unique buildings that players encounter when embarking on their adventure on the island of Vvardenfell. The structure plays a role in two early quests, and even those uninterested in pursuing these will probably climb it just to see the view of the game’s first  town from its highest accessible point.

Despite its status as a unique building that partially defines one of the most fondly-remembered places in Morrowind, the design of the lighthouse is something of an enigma. It does not really fit with either Imperial or Dunmer architecture. The strange, lopsided way in which the building is structured is also unbefitting for lighthouses, durable monoliths designed to withstand wind and waves.

As the artist tasked with redesigning and modeling the lighthouse for Skywind, my challenge is to correct these flaws while remaining true to the spirit of the original. My goal is not to supplant, but to enhance; to allow Morrowind veterans to re-experience those same feelings of exploring Seyda Neen, but on a grander, more consistent scale, while at the same time giving new players a better canvas on which to paint their own memories.

Rationale for Redesign

Before Vvardenfell was opened for Imperial settlement and exploitation, Seyda Neen was likely little more than another coastal fishing village in the vein of Hla Oad. A small fishing village would have little need for a lighthouse. By the time Morrowind takes place the Imperials have moved in and made Seyda Neen the headquarters of the Census and Excise Office, along with the associated Imperial Coastguard. With the increased ship traffic at Seyda Neen, the lighthouse was probably built to minimize the risks of sailing along the hazardous Bitter Coast. This would mean that, like the other Imperial-style buildings, the lighthouse is a fairly recent addition to the town.

The problem I always had with the original is that it has no consistency with the rest of the world. It looks like it has been in Seyda Neen for longer than the Imperials, which makes little sense unless you adhere to some sort of fan canon. The architecture is not Velothi, Daedric, Hlaalu, Redoran, or Telvanni. Given the lack of official lore for the history of Seyda Neen before Imperial settlement, it could be possible to interpret it as some sort of ancient Dunmer structure, since it has slight similarities to the strongholds. However, this would also mean that it should have sunk into the swamp long ago, especially considering the position of the lighthouse near sea level and in close proximity to the coast. The moist environment would have also caused the wooden supports to rot away, collapsing it even before the swamp did its work.

I’m sure Morrowind fans could come up with dozens of interpretations for the architecture and background of the lighthouse, but Imperial origin makes a lot of sense considering the state of Seyda Neen at the start of the game. This inspired the artists of Skywind to redesign it as an Imperial building.

Influences

The redesigned lighthouse is a combination of Imperial architecture and certain elements of the original lighthouse. The latter can be seen in the square shape and the use of stone blocks and slabs for the cornerstones of the base, the roof, and the upper platform. The light itself will also be similar to the original, though perhaps with a few metal parts to reinforce the stone.

The overall Imperial architecture has changed little in terms of the original game’s design, aside from added detail. If anything, the new design is grittier, a testament to the harsh environment of Vvardenfell and the speed with which the Imperials built up towns  on the island. Check out the Nordic/Common architecture thread on the Skywind forums if you would like  to know more about the designs that inspired the new lighthouse.

I researched a number of real lighthouses before commencing the redesign. Though the primary idea was to match the building with Skywind’s Imperial architecture, I took minor inspiration from La Vieille Lighthouse in France.

Conclusion

Redesigning the lighthouse is a significant undertaking, and there may already be substantial changes to its look by the time you read this post. I also understand that there are some who might not be happy with the direction we have chosen, since it is a fairly radical departure from the original. However, Skywind has become more than the port of Morrowind it originally was. We have redesigned armors, creatures, towns, and even entire regions of the world. Mechanics and characters have changed. Through years of development and work, a unique vision has emerged. This new lighthouse is part of that vision.

Edited by: Mace on 04/03/2015 - 02:56
Gundher
Gundher's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 weeks 3 hours ago
Joined: 03/10/2015 - 10:50
Karma: 1
Nice job, I was a little

Nice job, I was a little confused at first by it seeming so... ordered, but after looking at the La Vielle, I get what your doing. Really good job.

Mcloganator
Mcloganator's picture
Member
Offline
Last seen: 2 hours 31 min ago
Joined: 10/15/2013 - 16:18
Karma: 42
I think it's heading in the

I think it's heading in the right direction.  Honestly, I LOVE that this project is doing more than just re-skinning Morrowind.  As someone who has been playing Morrowind for more than eleven years, it's wonderful and refreshing to see all of the new little touches that the game is now getting.  As long as the changes have a reasonable foundation on lore and a good reason for implementation, I say we make those changes and be proud of them!   

hemipepsis5p
hemipepsis5p's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 months 2 days ago
Joined: 03/16/2015 - 18:31
Karma: 1
It looks great! All it needs

It looks great, but where's the light source going to be placed? I like that you're staying true to the original light source, it was the bees-knees. All it needs now is a pair of Weeping Willows :)

Sputnick
Sputnick's picture
Member
Offline
Last seen: 1 month 1 week ago
Joined: 04/25/2014 - 16:09
Karma: 46
I love these blog post! I

I love these blog post! I check this website all the time and it's nice to have a quick place to keep up with what's happening. :)

ErikChristensen
ErikChristensen's picture
Contributor
Offline
Last seen: 7 hours 7 min ago
Joined: 11/21/2014 - 04:01
Karma: 576
Donor
Thanks!

Thanks!

We are aiming to push one new blog post out each week, However they are quite a mission to put together. Once the landscaping ramps up, there will probably be a far greater influx of posts explaining our design choices in each reigon.

Njord
Njord's picture
Offline
Last seen: 2 months 8 hours ago
Joined: 03/19/2015 - 01:57
Karma: 1
La Vielle is haunting and

La Vielle is haunting and beautiful in its own right, but part of that beauty is its context -- the lone lighthouse among crashing waters.  There is so much room for this in Morrowind, but not in Seyda Neen.  The lighthouse is our first hello to Vvardenfell and irreplacably iconic.  If you change that, you change everything that comes after.  I know you've all worked harder than I can imagine, but please reconsider.  This is not a good implementation.

Mcloganator
Mcloganator's picture
Member
Offline
Last seen: 2 hours 31 min ago
Joined: 10/15/2013 - 16:18
Karma: 42
It's not THAT iconic.

It's not THAT iconic.

Mace
Mace's picture
Moderator
Online
Last seen: 4 min 31 sec ago
Joined: 02/14/2014 - 09:48
Karma: 197
Hold your horses Erik ;)

Hold your horses Erik ;) Currently we're doing two a month. The monthly blog post alongside posts that come from contributors. Otherwise it'll take too much focus away from the guys doing work around here, and we wouldn't want that.

Shnatsel
Shnatsel's picture
Member
Offline
Last seen: 2 weeks 3 days ago
Joined: 10/02/2014 - 15:46
Karma: 32
It looks like it has been in

It looks like it has been in Seyda Neen for longer than the Imperials, which makes little sense unless you adhere to some sort of fan canon.

You have a reply from Michael Kirkbride himself on the topic:

Early concept art shows House Hlaalu with gems in their foreheads. These gems were purportedly part of the glass in the construction of the Seyda Neen.

 

The Seyda Neen was the flagship of a fleet that Hlaalu sent to sea at the behest of a Saint, "to see the face of Veloth". The mariners on this voyage would send back for the rest of their House when they had found whatever this "face" was.

 

But an unnatural storm destroyed the fleet, the jetsam and flotsam coming back to the shore. The Hlaalu used this to construct the Lighthouse, so that any of their countrymer that may have survived the storm could find their way back. House nobles embedded their flagship's glass in their foreheads, because Morrowind.

Source: https://www.reddit.com/r/teslore/comments/2zfvm2/are_there_a...

Doesn't fully explain the stone parts (added later, after the initial construction?), but gives a nice backstory and explains the weird, mish-mash architecture. As for sinking into the swamp, supposedly Dunmer got very good at building things on swamps over the millenia.

Sergg
Sergg's picture
Offline
Last seen: 1 month 2 weeks ago
Joined: 09/04/2012 - 01:27
Karma: -1
New design is awful! I hate

New design is awful! I hate it! Please return old nice looking lighthouse.

twentyenginerunner
twentyenginerunner's picture
Contributor
Offline
Last seen: 20 hours 2 min ago
Joined: 05/17/2014 - 19:43
Karma: 351
New design is awful! I hate

New design is awful! I hate it! Please return old nice looking lighthouse.

Y'know, many of the comments on here raise valid points, but this one... not so much.