Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports
Howie Kendrick
This offseason saw a record 20 free agents extended a qualifying offer, and for the first time ever, we saw someone accept. The trio of Colby Rasmus, Matt Wieters and Brett Anderson all agreed to the one-year, $15.8 million pact.
As the winter progresses, it has begun to look more and more like a number of other free agents should have given serious thought to accepting their offer.
The following four players in particular should have accepted:
- SP Yovani Gallardo
- SP Ian Kennedy
- 2B Howie Kendrick
- OF Dexter Fowler
In one of the deepest starting pitching markets in recent memory, so far teams have been unwilling to sacrifice a draft pick to sign Gallardo or Kennedy, who are both solid pitchers but far from being ace-caliber.
Next offseason's market is relatively thin on quality starters behind Stephen Strasburg, so accepting the one-year offer and gearing up for a big payday next winter seems like it would have been their best course of action.
In the case of Kendrick, the market for second basemen this winter was deeper than usual, and that hurt his stock.
Daniel Murphy and Ben Zobrist both cashed in with multiyear deals, while Stephen Drew, Chase Utley and Darwin Barney have also signed new contracts.
Zobrist got $14 million annually from the Cubs, while Murphy received $12.5 million per year from the Nationals, so that $15.8 million figure has to be looking better and better to Kendrick.
The most likely of those four players to still agree to a lucrative multiyear deal might be Fowler, as he represents the best center fielder and leadoff hitter on the market.
That said, the outfield market has been very slow to develop, and after Alex Gordon accepted less than expected to re-sign with the Royals, that could have a trickle-down effect on how much Fowler winds up getting.
Big picture, a $15.8 million payday and another run at free agency in a weak market next winter seems like it would have been the best course of action for each of those four players.