Title

× Close
Social Media Buzz

A social media reminder: Tamilians and Kannadigas don't all hate each other

Karnataka and Tamil Nadu have a deep, shared history that is not defined by the Cauvery.

Shops were shuttered and political leaders took to the streets on Friday as a mark of protest over violence against Tamil people in Karnataka as well as demanding more water from the Cauvery river for the state. Ever since the Supreme Court ordered Karnataka to release Cauvery water to Tamil Nadu on September 5, tensions have been bubbling between Kannada and Tamil-speaking communities in both states.

Both states have seen sporadic instances of violence over the past ten days, be it the torching of 30 buses owned by a private Tamil Nadu operator in Bangalore or the vandalising of a hotel in Chennai owned by a family of Karnataka origin. Shops were attacked in Karnataka just as banks were picketed in Tamil Nadu. Two persons were killed as a result of the outbreak of violence in Bengaluru. Overall, the scene has been nothing short of ugly.

Demonstrations across Chennai on Friday, leading to the death of one person who immolated himself, again seemed to reiterate the impression over the last week or so that people in the two states are adversaries in a zero-sum game. But many citizens have also taken to social media to remind people that Tamilians and Kannadigas have a deep, shared history.

Twitter handle @IndiaHistorypic has been using historical images to promote harmony between Tamil and Kannadiga communities, especially of famous personalities of each state having links with the other. These have been posted with #Peace and #IndiaFirst.

“My purpose was to show that Tamils have Kannada interest in their heart and vice versa. Both Tamils and Kannada people are Indians first,” @IndiaHistorypic told The Hindu.

This trend seemed to catch on. Another Twitter account, which uses satire to make points, @RealHistorypic posted a picture on the Cauvery issue and the need to work towards a solution.

Several citizens have also been using social media to campaign against communal violence in each state. By using the #CauveryUnited, these citizens declared their non-endorsement of violence in the name of Tamils and Kannadigas.

There have also been several reminders of the help extended by the people of Karnataka to Chennai's citizens during the floods. In a Facebook post on September 11, Balaji Patturaj, popularly known as RJ Balaji wrote, "Its only a few violent groups, which are responsible for the attacks against Tamils in Karnataka. Thats a shame but for which let's not create hate tags against the entire state n its people. Its not gonna help our farmers here, rather it might worsen the situation of Tamils in Karnataka."

Indeed, the social media posts are a worthwhile reminder of the complexities of the current Cauvery agitation which date back decades and actually are the result of another thing that both Karnataka and Tamil Nadu share: Both states have terribly mismanaged their water and have local media networks that have done little to help the situation.

We welcome your comments at letters@scroll.in.
Sponsored Content BULLETIN BY 

Breaking the Myths on Girl Child Education in India

We are far from where we may think we are.

Several myths in popular imagination prevent us from seeing where the real barriers lie. As a result, we underestimate the effort needed to go from today to a future where every girl child in India is educated.

Myth 1: This issue is limited to rural India

According to a survey published by Save The Children, only 14 in every 100 girls in our cities reach Class XII. While ahead of rural India, where only 1 in 100 reach Class XII, this is still abysmal. Even the Ministry of Human Resources data, based on school reports, shows that only 33% girls reach class XII. This is not to take away from the dramatic improvements in enrolment, which is almost 100% for girls at the primary level with more girls enrolled in primary schools than boys! Enrolment, however, is not the same as attending or completing school. A UNESCO study puts primary school attendance for girls at 81% and secondary school attendance at a mere 49%.

Source: WINGS 2014
Source: WINGS 2014

Myth 2: More money will solve the problem

While funds were an issue in the 1950s, over the last two decades public spending, especially on education for girls, has increased manifold. According to World Bank data, India spent 3.7% of its GDP on education in 2015 which is not dramatically lower than the global average of 4.2%. Moreover, several Indian states are unable to spend their budgetary allocation every year.

Less expenditure does affect girls more than boys as it often means less infrastructure. For example, no separate bathrooms at school is often cited as a big reason for girls dropping out. Yet even higher spend has been unable to arrest drop-out rates and improve learning. In fact, learning levels for students are far behind those expected for their class and greater spend has not made a difference.

Source: Annual Status of Education Report (ASER)
Source: Annual Status of Education Report (ASER)

Myth 3: Technology will help us leapfrog poor school infrastructure

Educators agree, not just in India but the world over, that the single greatest factor determining learning outcomes in early education is teachers. Kiran Sethi, an Ashoka fellow and educationist says, “Children, especially in younger years, learn a lot from human interaction, collaboration, emotions and verbal and non-verbal cues. Quality of teachers and teaching methods are the most important factors for learning outcomes.” And what our schools lack is teachers. According to the government survey of 2014-15, 54% of the 7.6 lakh primary-only schools have two teachers or lesser and about 6,400 of these have no teachers!

In light of incredible improvements because of technology in every industry, one often assumes the benefits could apply to education equally well. One indicator is that global venture capital funding for K-12 education technology has grown at an annual rate of 48% over 2011-2015 crossing $ 3 Bn in 2015. Technology can indeed make a big difference and sometimes in surprising ways. For example, a 2010 study found that teacher absenteeism fell by 21% after the introduction of camera monitoring and linking of salary to attendance in rural Rajasthan. And no doubt, in the future a digital teaching system will radically alter circumstances. But for now, the greatest challenges India’s girls face have more to do with basic access than teaching technology.

Source: DISE/ MHRD 2014-15
Source: DISE/ MHRD 2014-15

Myth 4: Better performance of girls as against boys in board exams suggests the problem could fix itself

In 2010, the average number of school years was 4.1 for girls, while for boys it was 50% higher at 6.1. There remains a distinct gap between the two. While girls do outperform boys in pass percentages and merit lists in almost all board exams in every state, part of the reason is because so many drop out before the board exams. According to Census 2011, almost 20 million girls are denied education.

At the time of India’s independence girls enrolment was barely in double digits and since then we have clearly come a long way. Yet the higher performance of girls is also telling of how much more they could achieve.

Source: World Bank
Source: World Bank

These myths often lead us to believe that the issues around girl education are well on their way to being fixed. However, this is far from the truth. A new report by UNESCO on the state of global education recently stated that India is fifty years behind schedule in achieving the goal of universal education. Despite a great effort on the part of the public and social sector, progress is still slow. The challenge of ensuring education for all girls is deep seated and all around us – in our neighbourhoods and cities.

Faster progress on girls’ education is important not just as a fundamental right of girls, but also for overall positive social change. UNICEF and WHO data shows that the health indicators—from infant mortality to immunization levels to vulnerability to abuse—of future generations is directly linked to the level of schooling of women.

Debunking popular myths and accepting the challenges head-on is the first essential step in making India a better place for girls. Join the conversation.

Play

This article was produced on behalf of Nestlé by the Scroll.in marketing team and not by the Scroll.in editorial staff.

× Close
PrevNext