?

Red Dead Review Average Prediction

  1. 100, 10/10, Recommended, Essential, and Other Perfect Scores, GOTY Material

  2. 90-99, 9/10, Recommended, Essential, GOTY Material

  3. 80-89, 8/10, Recommended

  4. 70-79, 7/10, Recommended

  5. Below 70, Not Recommended

Results are only viewable after voting.
  1. Am I on Gamefaqs right now?
     
  2. Sinder

    Sinder
    Member

    Here we go

    Shit starting has commenced
     
  3. Toolifercle

    Toolifercle
    Member

    Yani hame khaye kardan. Khoda bood!
     
  4. LordKano

    LordKano
    Member

    uh, is it really native 4k on xbox one x ? 'cause that'd be absolutely unreal

    nobody takes them seriously they're like the dailymail of french video game press
     
  5. jschreier

    jschreier
    Press Sneak Fuck Verafied

    Oh whoops I forgot a link. Here: https://kotaku.com/red-dead-redemption-2-the-kotaku-review-1829984369

    I cannot recommend this review enough. It's one of the best I've ever read.

    Intentional or not, Red Dead Redemption 2 can be read as a meditation on failed leaders, and even as a potent critique of the internal and external cultures that Rockstar has helped perpetuate. Dutch Van der Linde is every inch the manipulative boss, frightening not only for his violent nature but for his ability to marshal people to work against their own self-interest. Time and again he reveals his shameless hypocrisy, and his promises of a new life are consistently shown to be empty maneuvering. “This isn’t a prison camp,” he says at one point, uncannily echoing every supervisor who has ever coerced an underling into a technically optional task. “I am not forcing anybody to stay. So either we’re in this together, working together to get out together, or we’re not. There simply isn’t a reality in which we do nothing and get everything.” I half-expected him to promise everyone bonuses if they hit their sales target.​
     
  6. Really never heard of Slant Magazine but what is there reason for that number? I rather not go read any reviews myself, I've done so well when it comes to staying away from knowing anything about the game in fear of spoilers.
     
  7. Blade Wolf

    Blade Wolf
    Member

    Slant Magazine who gave BOTW a 6/10 gives RDR2 a 7/10, that's a good thing in my book.
     
  8. IIFloodyII

    IIFloodyII
    Member

    How many reviews are there? MC is dead for me.
    If it's 40+ it's probably be either 95-97, that's usually how these go after the first batch of reviews.
     
  9. Last_colossi

    Last_colossi
    Member

    I know but it looks so damn good on this list xD
     
  10. steviejd1

    steviejd1
    Member

    The Eurogamer review name dropped both BotW and Witcher 3, blame them. And it is fine to compare games you know? It can be done in a rational and calm manner.
     
  11. tulpa

    tulpa
    Member

    up to 97 on MC with 45 reviews
     
  12. ldcommando

    ldcommando
    Member

    Got my 10 from EZA, I´m satisfied
     
  13. Sinder

    Sinder
    Member

    Yep
     
  14. Coyote Starrk

    Coyote Starrk
    Member

    [​IMG]
     
  15. LoudMouse

    LoudMouse
    Member

    Easy Allies is all I needed.
     
  16. Silence_and_i

    Silence_and_i
    Member

    Please write in English not Finglish!
     
  17. DrBo42

    DrBo42
    Member

  18. mazi

    mazi
    Member

    my guess is it'll end up at 95. usually some nore critical reviews come out a bit after the embargo is lifted
     
  19. SuikerBrood

    SuikerBrood
    Member

    The hype is real. Now announce that damn pc version, Rockstar.
     
  20. Jawmuncher

    Jawmuncher
    Crisis Dino - Snake is in Smash Moderator

    Don’t derail the thread to make this about another titles MC
     
  21. MillionIII

    MillionIII
    Member

    How much they gave knack?
     
  22. Trickster

    Trickster
    Member

    Some of the things the reviewer in the IGN review gushes over makes the game sound like a chore to play honestly. I mean I'm sorry, but slow manual looting is not, and will never be a good thing
     
  23. Kolx

    Kolx
    Member

    97 now on MC.
     
  24. ekim

    ekim
    Member

    Was my bet. Good.
     
  25. Camstun187

    Camstun187
    Member

    Nope
     
  26. VinFTW

    VinFTW
    Member

    Yeah it’s pretty pathetic.
     
  27. What a twist!
     
  28. Edge

    Edge
    Member


    For you.
     
  29. Sinder

    Sinder
    Member

    I’m betting it settles at 97.
     
  30. Fat4all

    Fat4all
    Community Resettler Member

    got my pre-load going right now, the EZA review was more than enough to make the final push
     
  31. And you'll never get bloodborne 2
     
  32. Milennia

    Milennia
    Community Resetter Member

    Hope the 97 sticks, I’m losing my shit
     
  33. Bud23

    Bud23
    Member

    98 or bust
     
  34. VinFTW

    VinFTW
    Member

    Good Christ.
     
  35. bequietdrive

    bequietdrive
    Member

  36. Kusagari

    Kusagari
    Member

    Red Dead is a 30/20 if you play it in the Tokyo Dome.
     
  37. Gridlock

    Gridlock
    Member

    Votes 10/10 - the second coming

    Scrolls down and sees GameSpot 9/10.. fuck GameSpot!!

    jk
     
  38. Kolx

    Kolx
    Member

    Yeah. I was afraid of that since the previews and it seems like it's true (for me at least). Still going to enjoy the game probably but I wish they toned that down a bit.
     
  39. Trickster

    Trickster
    Member

    If it was a good design choice, more games would do it
     
  40. Blade Wolf

    Blade Wolf
    Member

    97 this is unreal
     
  41. Much118

    Much118
    Member

    97. I think this is either a hard lock at 96 or 97.
     
  42. Sure, it can be. It just won’t be here.
     
  43. Fat4all

    Fat4all
    Community Resettler Member

    5 fucking RDR2 vids popped into my YouTube sub box right at 7 am, lol
     
  44. Dhuggs_

    Dhuggs_
    Member

    Kenny Omega and Okada have somehow found their way into 1899
     
  45. bomma man

    bomma man
    Member

    The Eurogamer basically makes it sound like what I expected - it’s a Rockstar game, but more. Disappointing, but I’ll probably still like it.
     
  46. MegaSackman

    MegaSackman
    Member

    So, following Eurogamer's review, it seems the story is less "interesting" than Red 1 so is the main character, and they say the game shines after you finish it.

    Looks like my biggest fear can be true after all.
     
  47. mazi

    mazi
    Member

    bazicenter hanouz zende ast?!
     
  48. Toolifercle

    Toolifercle
    Member

    Think it's going to chill on 96 at the end.
     
  49. Seems like the game is reviewing better on European sites.
     
  50. Ryo

    Ryo
    Member

    97 Meta, 97 Opencritic, nothing has such a high average on both platforms at the same time.