[…] But I want people to think of something. See this from my earlier post Guns & Violence, Again… […]
[…] proportion than whites. I have a suggestion to Mr. Hall in his retirement — glance at a map of world homicide rates and ponder the patterns. While you’re there, follow up by reading the FAQ at the esteemed […]
An easy argument for the emotional types to understand is this:
Billions more innocent people have been killed by armed military, police, and criminals than by armed law abiding citizens.
Knowing this fact, why would you demand that law abiding armed citizens be disarmed?
[…] to language, to crime, [Edit: to guns, see also Guns, violence, and the Dylann Roof rampage and Guns & Violence, Again…,**] to education, to social attitudes (such as on the death penalty, on healthcare, on corporal […]
“I struggle with a name for this collection of people”
pirate biologists
I am so glad I read this entry. Just read the major newspapers in the north and you’ll notice shootings increase as temps go up. And guess the demographics of the neighborhoods where most(not all) of the shootings will take place? And they happen in suburbs more than ever. Seems like Suffolk County Long Island is quite the shoot ’em up suburb.
Jayman,
If you’re worried some casual observers will give you the “tl:dr” tripe when you make them aware of this post, just point them to this to get the point across:
Full disclosure: I actually own that shirt.
shhhh! suggesting such a thing might hurt people’s feelings 😉
Thank you!
As soon as you’ve figured that out, call me… 😉
Thank you!
Yes, the American nations bit is something. Of course, if culture was indeed the product of the inherited temperaments of the people who exhibit it, would we expect anything different?
One of the best treatments on the subject I’ve read in awhile. It continues to amaze how well the Nations hypothesis consistently tracks across various topics.
Yes yes, quite right.
And let’s not forget not indoctrinating them in “gun culture”. How foolish of you to miss that…
This addresses the cause (beautifully) but not what we can do about it. If you import violence prone people into a less violent society and the guns everyone can buy suddenly start killing people in larger and larger numbers, what do you do? Do you then restrict gun ownership? The law abiding citizens won’t stand for that, they know they won’t be out killing people with their guns and they want to be able to protect themselves from those who will. But you also can’t deport the violent ones, not today, nor can you kill them (in most states, and even those that do, do so rarely and only after great expense). Meanwhile parole and conjugal visits ensure that the most violent among us will contribute to the next generation even after they’re convicted.
But how terrible of me for not understanding that violence is all in the upbringing. Jayman, if only we taught these poor children not to kill, then all of this heartache could be avoided!
Excellent work Jayman, ( I am not being sarcastic, I really mean it ) but now how do we get people who are immune to facts and logic, people who prefer to go with how they feel about things ( and they are at least half the population I would think ) to acknowledge and understand this?