Ultimate Car of the Year Finalist: 1972 Citroen SM

First foreign COTY

There's no brake pedal. Just a big, black button on the floor between the gas and the clutch. The pictograms on the buttons, switches, and warning lights make no sense. The seats are either reclined or really reclined. The Citroën SM seems like a UFO, making you wonder what our experts made of it in 1972. Except we do know: They made it the first foreign-branded Car of the Year.

It was an illustrious panel, to be sure. Created in 1971 to bring industry expertise to our judging, the Conference of Automotive Research Specialists (CARS) included racer Phil Hill, racer and automotive safety engineer Bill Milliken, automotive engineer/designer/reporter/author Karl Ludvigsen, automotive designer and Art Center design professor Strother McMinn, and MotorTrend EIC Eric Dahlquist.

That the SM was heavily based on the existing DS' mechanicals was outweighed by the advancement of the technology. A technical dive involving rare access to Citroën officials described enhancements to the car's hydropneumatic systems, a rework of the DS' unique control-arm front suspension, an automatic brake-force proportioning system, and a hydraulically powered steering centering mechanism to compensate for the race car-quick steering ratio at high speeds.

1972 Citroen SM rear three quarter
1972 Citroen SM front in motion
1972 Citroen SM front interior seats 1
1972 Citroen SM front interior seats 2
1972 Citroen SM rear wheel
1972 Citroen SM rear three quarter in motion 2
1972 Citroen SM rear three quarter in motion 1
1972 Citroen SM headlight
1972 Citroen SM front wheel
1972 Citroen SM front three quarter
1972 Citroen SM front three quarter in motion 2
1972 Citroen SM front three quarter in motion 1
1972 Citroen SM front grille
1972 Citroen SM engine
1972 Citroen SM detail 2
1972 Citroen SM detail 1

Also receiving good-natured scrutiny: the car's wind tunnel-tested aerodynamics and its new Maserati V-6 with 170 net hp nosed up to the firewall with the five-speed transaxle ahead of the engine driving the front wheels. As American automakers were limping into the malaise era, the Citroën was a technological tour de force. Or at the least it tried to be.

Nearly a half century later, Bill Lundby's personal 1973 SM is as strange to drive as it sounds. The steering is lightning quick, so you're often correcting yourself after turning harder than you'd intended. Once you have that figured out, you have to learn to be deliberate as you return the wheel to center. Most cars return to center slowly; the SM's steering wheel snaps back quickly enough to have you flopping around the cabin.

Short Shifts
View All
HOT ROD Power Tour: Sideshow Freaks
HOT ROD Power Tour: Sideshow Freaks
03:05
Watch This! MotorTrend Chooses the Most Significant Car of the Year From 70 Years of Winners
Watch This! MotorTrend Chooses the Most Significant Car of the Year From 70 Years of Winners
02:58
First Test: the 1949 Kurtis Sport Car
First Test: the 1949 Kurtis Sport Car
01:57
5 Cool Things: The 2020 Bentley Bentayga Hybrid
5 Cool Things: The 2020 Bentley Bentayga Hybrid
01:24
MotorTrend Presents Mojave Road: Three Trail-Ready Trucks Against the Desert
MotorTrend Presents Mojave Road: Three Trail-Ready Trucks Against the Desert
06:14
The Four Wheeler Overland Adventure: Part 1
The Four Wheeler Overland Adventure: Part 1
01:56
2019 Hot Wheels™ Legends Tour: New Jersey
2019 Hot Wheels™ Legends Tour: New Jersey
05:48
Coffee Break: Mazda Comes to MotorTrend
Coffee Break: Mazda Comes to MotorTrend
03:29
Watch This! Lamborghini Urus vs. Porsche Cayenne Turbo at the Track
Watch This! Lamborghini Urus vs. Porsche Cayenne Turbo at the Track
01:13
5 Cool Things: the All-New 2020 Hyundai Palisade
5 Cool Things: the All-New 2020 Hyundai Palisade
01:30
Behind the Wheel: the 2020 McLaren 720S Spider
Behind the Wheel: the 2020 McLaren 720S Spider
01:44
How to Flair “Army-Navy”-Type Brake Fittings
How to Flair “Army-Navy”-Type Brake Fittings
03:18
5 Cool Things: the All-New 2020 Ford Explorer
5 Cool Things: the All-New 2020 Ford Explorer
01:49
First Test: 2020 Kia Telluride SX
First Test: 2020 Kia Telluride SX
01:24
Need to Know: What’s Underneath the 2019 Jeep Cherokee Trailhawk?
Need to Know: What’s Underneath the 2019 Jeep Cherokee Trailhawk?
01:09

The brake button is pressure sensitive but has almost no travel, seemingly taking your input and figuring the rest out for itself. The dynamic brake proportioning means the car never dives under braking or squats under acceleration but simply settles or lifts gently.

This body control only applies to longitudinal behavior. Turn a corner and glance out the window, and you might catch a glimpse of the door handle dragging on the ground. The car has a front anti-roll bar, but it's apparently cosmetic. The motions are controlled and predictable, and the car returns to upright just as nicely. There's just more motion than needs be.

The highlight, though, is a ride quality that would make Rolls-Royce envious. (Indeed, Rolls licensed the technology in 1965 for the Silver Shadow.) Potholes, speed bumps, cracks, seams, even cattle guards simply cease to exist under the wheels of an SM. They're heard but never felt, not in the chassis and not in the steering. The multiposition ride height is just a bonus.

View 16 Photos

That tech would also doom the SM. Citroën did not get the exemption it expected from 5-mph bumper regulations in the U.S., its largest export market, in 1974. That and the need for separate Citroën and Maserati specialists to service the car turned off customers worldwide. The SM was dead by 1975. Only 12,920 were built.

That the car was a moonshot didn't concern our judges. Rather, it invigorated them. "The cars we evaluated as Car of the Year from [1952] on were looked to as promising directions for the automobile evolution," we wrote. "Viewed in the perspective of the last twenty-one years, the SM fits more precisely in the spirit of the Car of the Year, maybe better than anything else being made in the world today."

Read more about our Ultimate Car of the Year finalists:

1968 Pontiac GTO
1986 Mazda RX-7
2013 Tesla Model S

Photo Gallery

  • 1972 Citroen SM front three quarter
  • 1972 Citroen SM rear three quarter
  • 1972 Citroen SM front in motion
  • 1972 Citroen SM front interior seats 1
  • 1972 Citroen SM front interior seats 2
  • 1972 Citroen SM rear wheel
16 Photos in this Gallery
FIND YOUR NEXT CAR see all
TOP NEW CAR MODELS