Two years ago, in an airport bar in Phoenix, I watched UCLA and Gonzaga battle for the right to advance to the Elite Eight of the NCAA men's basketball tournament. As the sound of the telecast filtered out into the concourse, passersby (most of whom, unlike me, presumably hadn't intentionally scheduled a three-hour layover) started gravitating toward the bar, intrigued by what they heard. "Who is this announcer?" three separate people asked me.
March Madness is supposed to be exciting, but CBS's raucous play-by-play man Gus Johnson calls the action as if every blocking foul were a world historical event--and he was in top form that night. The game ended with a stunning UCLA comeback that drove Gonzaga's Adam Morrison to tears and produced a largely incoherent call by Johnson, that went something to the effect of: "And a steal! Farmar ... inside, the freshman up, and ... ahhh! And they go in front! Raivio ... last chance to [unintelligible] ... Ahhh! Oh, what a game! What a game!" (Commenting later on The New York Times's NCAA Tournament blog, Will Leitch wrote, "I defy anyone to ... provide a single word Johnson is screeching.") But volume proved a surprisingly good substitute for lucidity. By the time it was over, several dozen people were crowded around the television, awed as much by Johnson’s gripping style as by the Bruins' late heroics.
So, when CBS announced its broadcast schedule a year ago for the 2007 NCAA men's basketball tournament--and word spread that the network had made the dreadful choice of removing Johnson from play-by-play duty during the Sweet 16 and Elite Eight rounds of the tournament--a small but vocal segment of the sports blogosphere went ballistic. "[The] CBS brass has about zero idea what people actually want," complained one blogger. Wrote another: "We've said it before and we'll say it again … March Madness is not a showcase for 'student athletes'. It is simply a showcase for Gus Johnson to be Gus Johnson." Worse, CBS replaced him with the mellifluous but uninspired voice of James Brown, recently plucked from Fox primarily to host CBS's NFL studio show. It's a bit like substituting Barry Manilow in for Jimi Hendrix at Woodstock.
How, exactly, did an announcer low enough on CBS's totem pole to be cast aside for a former host of The World's Funniest! become a beloved symbol for one of the country's premiere sporting events? It's a little puzzling. Johnson has never been on the main CBS broadcast team for a Final Four--Jim Nantz and Billy Packer have held the job since 1990. Though certainly an up-and-coming talent, he's not generally regarded as a great announcer--when calling NFL games, he gets shipped off to Oakland and Miami to cover the dregs of the AFC. And his résumé isn't really that of a prodigy--like most announcers, he's dutifully put in his time in low-paying, far-flung jobs in places like Waco and Huntsville. He even did a stint with the Canadian Football League.