Putin Speaks, Officials Shrug, and Doctors Are Caught in the Middle

A botched effort to reward people keeping the coronavirus in check leaves doctors and nurses who demand their due facing scrutiny.

Credit...Sergey Ponomarev for The New York Times

MOSCOW — Assailed by critics as an absentee leader at the start of the coronavirus crisis in Russia, President Vladimir V. Putin re-emerged with a splash on state television last month to show that he cared and was taking charge.

He promised cash bonuses of up to $1,100 a month for each doctor, nurse and other “front line” health worker involved in fighting the virus.

But for an all-powerful leader whose every word must be taken as a command, Mr. Putin has had a surprisingly hard time making his voice heard.

More than a month after he spoke, the money has yet to materialize for many. Instead, some doctors have received visits from police investigators and prosecutors demanding to know why they complained publicly about not getting their bonuses.

A promise meant to showcase Mr. Putin’s proudest achievement — the revitalization of the Russian state after the chaos of the 1990s — has sunk into a swamp of recrimination, security service intimidation and bureaucratic buck-passing.

“Is this a joke? Unfortunately, no,” Dmitri Drize, a Moscow-based editor, wrote last week in a scathing newspaper commentary on the unfolding mess.

He said that neither Russia’s foreign foes nor its main opposition leader, Aleksei A. Navalny, “is capable of damaging the image of the state as much as its own managers.”

The Kremlin holds more than $500 billion in various rainy day funds, so Mr. Putin has all the money he needs to deliver on his promises. But, in a system rife with corruption, many officials live in permanent fear of being criticized, or worse investigated, for spending state money not included in their previously approved budgets.

So when it came to doling out the cash, they hesitated, took the liberty of making deductions for time health workers spent on non-coronavirus patients or perhaps skimmed some of the money.

Image
Credit...Pool photo by Alexei Nikolsky

In the southern region of Krasnodar, a widely respected head doctor at a hospital was fired after his staff staged a small protest. He is now under investigation by Russia’s equivalent of the F.B.I. for criminal negligence.

A doctor in the nearby town of Abinsk who helped organize public complaints over nonpayment of Mr. Putin’s bonus received a letter from the police warning that he faced prosecution for “carrying out extremist activities.”

Yulia Volkova, a Krasnodar doctor who leads the local branch of Doctors’ Alliance, an independent trade union affiliated with Mr. Navalny, said in a telephone interview that medical workers had rejoiced at Mr. Putin’s promise of extra cash. Now, though, they are “terrified of being investigated” if they complain about the president’s orders’ falling on deaf ears, she said.

In some cases, however, prosecutors have sided with protesting doctors. The prosecutor’s office in Simferopol, the capital of Crimea, annexed by Russia in 2014, said last week that it had investigated complaints of nonpayment and found them justified. It ordered local authorities to pay up.

In Nizhny Novgorod, another region where many medical staff have not received the money promised, the regional health minister, David Melik-Husyenov, accused the opposition of using “dirty tricks” to expose the bureaucracy’s failures. “Arranging such stories is very immoral,” he said.

Mr. Putin, playing one of his favorite roles as a caring but stern father of the nation undermined by bungling bureaucrats, fumed recently in a teleconference that officials in many places had not acted on his bonus order.

“I gave specific figures for these payments for doctors, for nursing staff, for all medical staff, for ambulance crews and so on,” Mr. Putin said. Instead, he continued: “They made a bureaucratic mess, counting the number of hours worked on some kind of clock. Did I instruct that you count with a watch or something? No!”

He said earlier that 29 regions had ignored his order and that less than half of medical workers nationwide had received the money he had promised. Ordering officials to get with his program, Mr. Putin thundered, “I ask you to keep in mind that I will personally check the situation on this issue in every region of Russia.”

Image
Credit...Sergey Ponomarev for The New York Times

That things have gone so awry is a measure of the wide gap between image and reality in a country that revolves around what Mr. Putin calls the “power vertical.” This is the rigidly top-down — and, in theory, stringently efficient — system that he has spent 20 years building to replace the decrepit state structure he inherited from his predecessor, President Boris N. Yeltsin.

Tatiana Stanovaya, an expert on Russian politics, said the “power vertical” has always been a political project focused on protecting the Kremlin from opponents, not on delivering efficient administration for the public’s benefit.

“It has never been effective in routine management. This is not something Putin knows how or wants to do,” she said.

“Nobody deliberately defies Putin or lets him down,” she added in a telephone interview. ‘‘That is impossible. But nearly everyone does it unintentionally because they are afraid of taking decisions.”

Much of the blame for unpaid bonuses has now fallen on the staff of Prime Minister Mikhail V. Mishustin, who spent much of this month in the hospital recovering from Covid-19.

The prime minister complained in a conference call with officials shown on television that documents needed to turn Mr. Putin’s promise into action had not been drafted properly and left too much room for regional officials to wriggle out of paying.

One of the first signs that Mr. Putin’s bonus program was going off the rails came in early May when ambulance drivers, paramedics and others gathered outside the main hospital in Armavir, a town in the southern region of Krasnodar. “We have received nothing. Not a ruble, not a kopeck,” they chanted.

Image
Credit...Sergey Ponomarev for The New York Times

A video of their protest appeared online, stirring copycat actions across the country. Krasnodar’s governor, Veniamin Kondratyev, responded that he was aware of “many complaints” of nonpayment and vowed to “investigate the situation in detail” to make sure Mr. Putin’s promise was fulfilled.

An official commission was then sent to investigate the Armavir hospital and quickly found a scapegoat: the head doctor, Sergei Smirnov. Accused of not filling in the necessary paperwork on time, he was branded as the main culprit in media outlets controlled by the regional authorities.

Reports last week that Dr. Smirnov had been fired provoked only more protests by exhausted and irate medical staff.

A group of nurses gathered near the Armavir hospital to sing Dr. Smirnov’s praises, saying that he had worked hard to make sure his staff had proper protective equipment, and to warn, in the words of one angry nurse, that “without him work will stop.”

  • Frequently Asked Questions and Advice

    Updated May 20, 2020

    • How can I protect myself while flying?

      If air travel is unavoidable, there are some steps you can take to protect yourself. Most important: Wash your hands often, and stop touching your face. If possible, choose a window seat. A study from Emory University found that during flu season, the safest place to sit on a plane is by a window, as people sitting in window seats had less contact with potentially sick people. Disinfect hard surfaces. When you get to your seat and your hands are clean, use disinfecting wipes to clean the hard surfaces at your seat like the head and arm rest, the seatbelt buckle, the remote, screen, seat back pocket and the tray table. If the seat is hard and nonporous or leather or pleather, you can wipe that down, too. (Using wipes on upholstered seats could lead to a wet seat and spreading of germs rather than killing them.)

    • What are the symptoms of coronavirus?

      Common symptoms include fever, a dry cough, fatigue and difficulty breathing or shortness of breath. Some of these symptoms overlap with those of the flu, making detection difficult, but runny noses and stuffy sinuses are less common. The C.D.C. has also added chills, muscle pain, sore throat, headache and a new loss of the sense of taste or smell as symptoms to look out for. Most people fall ill five to seven days after exposure, but symptoms may appear in as few as two days or as many as 14 days.

    • How many people have lost their jobs due to coronavirus in the U.S.?

      Over 38 million people have filed for unemployment since March. One in five who were working in February reported losing a job or being furloughed in March or the beginning of April, data from a Federal Reserve survey released on May 14 showed, and that pain was highly concentrated among low earners. Fully 39 percent of former workers living in a household earning $40,000 or less lost work, compared with 13 percent in those making more than $100,000, a Fed official said.

    • Is ‘Covid toe’ a symptom of the disease?

      There is an uptick in people reporting symptoms of chilblains, which are painful red or purple lesions that typically appear in the winter on fingers or toes. The lesions are emerging as yet another symptom of infection with the new coronavirus. Chilblains are caused by inflammation in small blood vessels in reaction to cold or damp conditions, but they are usually common in the coldest winter months. Federal health officials do not include toe lesions in the list of coronavirus symptoms, but some dermatologists are pushing for a change, saying so-called Covid toe should be sufficient grounds for testing.

    • Should I wear a mask?

      The C.D.C. has recommended that all Americans wear cloth masks if they go out in public. This is a shift in federal guidance reflecting new concerns that the coronavirus is being spread by infected people who have no symptoms. Until now, the C.D.C., like the W.H.O., has advised that ordinary people don’t need to wear masks unless they are sick and coughing. Part of the reason was to preserve medical-grade masks for health care workers who desperately need them at a time when they are in continuously short supply. Masks don’t replace hand washing and social distancing.

    • What should I do if I feel sick?

      If you’ve been exposed to the coronavirus or think you have, and have a fever or symptoms like a cough or difficulty breathing, call a doctor. They should give you advice on whether you should be tested, how to get tested, and how to seek medical treatment without potentially infecting or exposing others.

    • How can I help?

      Charity Navigator, which evaluates charities using a numbers-based system, has a running list of nonprofits working in communities affected by the outbreak. You can give blood through the American Red Cross, and World Central Kitchen has stepped in to distribute meals in major cities.


Vladimir Lotnik, a resident who signed a petition protesting Dr. Smirnov’s dismissal, said in a telephone interview that officials were scrambling to protect themselves up and down the system by blaming the powerless. “A fish rots from the head,” he said.

Nikolai Petrov, a political scientist, dismissed Mr. Putin’s public anger and dismay over the bonuses as mostly theater.

“He is trying to show that he is the good guy,” Mr. Petrov said. “But he is losing popularity and will continue to lose it.”

An opinion poll by the Levada Center, an independent polling organization in Moscow, found that the president’s approval rating sank last month to 59 percent, its lowest level since he came to power in 2000. His highest approval rating, nearly 90 percent, came after Russia seized Crimea from Ukraine in 2014.

After nearly two months cooped up in his country residence outside Moscow, Mr. Putin has become so isolated, in Mr. Petrov’s view, that he “risks returning to a changed country after the pandemic is over.”

He likened the situation to what Mikhail S. Gorbachev, the last leader of the Soviet Union, faced when he returned to Moscow after the collapse of a coup attempt in 1991 that had kept him isolated for days in a villa in Crimea.

Mr. Gorbachev, his authority drained, resigned soon afterward.

Image
Credit...Sergey Ponomarev for The New York Times

Predictions of Mr. Putin’s imminent eclipse, however, have invariably proved wrong, and many expect the president to bounce back from these travails, albeit in a weakened position.

Russia, with more than 350,000 reported coronavirus cases, is the third most infected country after the United States and Brazil. Kremlin-controlled media outlets, however, have presented Russia’s response to the pandemic as a triumph, trumpeting official figures that show a remarkably low death rate of 2 per 100,000 people, compared with 30 in the U.S. and 55 in Britain. This, they say, is a “Russian miracle.”

The pandemic has nonetheless disrupted the centerpiece of the Kremlin’s political program for the year, forcing the cancellation of an April referendum on constitutional changes that would allow Mr. Putin to brush aside term limits and stay in power until 2036.

But, with the recent lifting of a nationwide lockdown order — despite a steady rise in the number of infections — the Kremlin is expected to push ahead with its vote on the Constitution as early as June.

The referendum’s outcome, like nearly all votes in Russia, is in little doubt, and it would secure Mr. Putin’s unassailable position for many years to come.

Opening the door for him to stay in power indefinitely, Kremlin critics say, would only entrench the dysfunctions of a system that for 20 years has paid lip service to the stated goals of a single man but often confounded them instead.

“The diagnosis is obvious,” said Mr. Drize, the editor. “Officials have forgotten how to make decisions on their own. And this disease is worse than the coronavirus.”

Oleg Matsnev and Sophia Kishkovsky contributed reporting.