I live in Buffalo NY, and recently there was a report of a possible Coronavirus outbreak here. I told my kids (3 boys) to start wearing medical masks when they leave the house. We already have some here as it's a common practice when the younger 2 get sick, plus I ordered cotton masks as to not have to purchase any more disposable ones (there is a shortage, so I'm trying to do my part to save them for the sick)
Yesterday my 10 yr old son was asked to remove his mask. He tried to refuse, but after threatening to send him to the principal he complied. I was angry when I found out, and told my son to continue to wear it, and to have the school call me if they give him a hard time
Today I sent him in with a mask again. Once again they told him to remove it. He refused, and was sent to the principal's office. The principal told him that wearing the mask doesn't stop you from catching the virus, it only stops people from spreading it, so it wasn't necessary for him to wear one. (I googled a bit and got a couple mixed responses, so I'm unsure if that's accurate or not)
I feel like it's not the school's decision to make. I don't typically fight against policies, but this seems insane to me. Him wearing it is not disruptive to his learning, so why force him to remove it?
I don't know if this is a battle worth fighting or if I'm being paranoid. Would I be an asshole to keep sending him in with a mask? Obviously I'd have to argue with the principal, and I don't want to negatively impact my son's school experience. But I don't feel like this is their decision to make
Edit 3 - My son didn't get into any trouble. As I found out today, them sending him to the principal was not a punishment. No literature had gone out yet, and this was more of a way to let the kids and parents know why they felt masks weren't necessary. I have not changed my stance that I feel that's not their decision to make, but I am respecting their wishes
Edit 2 - The mask my son wore was a disposable mask that I already had on hand from when my 7 yr old had the flu.
The masks I currently purchased were simply cotton & elastic - not effective as I'm now being informed. But I didn't buy any speciality masks. As I said previously, I'm aware of the shortage, and don't want to contribute to it. The masks I bought are from Etsy, IE homemade
I have not once argued against any medical professional. My question was about my rights as a mother.
I love my kids school, and I know most of the faculty. But you can't put out an automatic call about Coronavirus possibly being in the area and expect parents to not get concerned. I'm not a medical professional, I'm just a mom who loves her kids. My children were also not the only ones to show up with masks.
Thank you to those who have given me good info & feedback
Edit 1 - I hear what you guys are saying about the differences in masks. That makes sense
I was omw to an open house (where the principal was), which is why I posted here first. I definitely wouldn't make my kid take the fall without talking to someone. He wasn't the only child wearing a mask. My teenage son said his school has been encouraging them to wear masks, so there's a lot of mixed info out there
I decided to back down on this. It's not the proper mask, and the outbreaks here are not confirmed, so I see that I'd be TA if I fought this. Thanks for the feedback
Welcome to r/AmITheAsshole. Please view our voting guide here, and remember to use only one judgement in your comment.
Help keep the sub engaging!
Do upvote interesting posts!
Click Here For Our Rules and Click Here For Our FAQ
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
YTA. Because the mask doesn’t help protect your child. And you’re teaching him to be paranoid.
Agreed. No way would I have worn a mask to school at 10. In surprised the kids didn't rip it off as soon as the parent left.
Info: is your kid vaccinated?
Also there is lots of stuff (you know like doctors and medical research) that says the mask doesn’t help and actually makes it worse due to trapping the the germs with the humidity if your mouth.
I second this. The masks help people who have it stop spreading it. Not the other way around. OP is also contributing to the shortage of masks we now have. YTA
It's also likely against school dress code, which is why the school pushed back without an active quarantine in effect. Most schools don't allow faces to be covered for the safety of the students.
Most people really have no understanding of how small** a virus is, how porous certain materials are, or how little a Walmart issue mask does for the most part for things outside basic hospital precautions. Quarantine masks are much more involved. They're close-fitted, airtight, made of harder materials, and include a respirator with filter.
**For reference, thousands of viral units could line up on the period at the end of this sentence and dance the cancan without getting squeezed for space.
This. Healthy people wearing masks = bad practice. Your children should really only be wearing masks if they’re sick. Please go off of what the CDC recommends, not what other parents say.
Yeah. Honestly wearing the mask probably does the kid more harm than good. Most 10 year olds who are forced to wear a mask are probably going to fiddle with it a lot. You know a great way to get sick? Touching your face.
Not to mention that Covid-19 has proven to be relatively benign to children so far with no deaths in the 0-9 age bracket and only mild symptoms. Like chicken pox, it seems to be much more effective in adults.
Not sure if it's been said, but wearing the mask can increase odds of being sick because people tend to mess with it and touch their faces more.
I lived in Japan for a decade. It was common to see Japanese people wearing masks. But it was always people who were already sick and trying not to spread illness.
Also, last year I thought my son had the flu. Took him to ER. None of the staff were wearing a mask, but the first thing they did was put a mask on my son--the person at risk of spreading illness. If it helped keep you from catching illness, wouldn't everyone working in the ER be wearing one?
Pretty much this. A mask does not protect you from getting sick, it just helps propagate paranoia.
How is wearing a mask to try and not get sick(whether it’s effective or not) paranoia? refusing to leave the house, or something along those lines, is paranoia. NAH
37 more replies
YTA I don’t know what „mixed responses“ you found online but medical masks make it less likely for infected to infect others, they do not protect people from viruses. So exactly what the principal said.
Tell your kids to wash their hands regularly, avoid touching their faces all that much and be sanitary in general.
And hand sanitizer. Kids aren't always allowed enough time to properly wash their hands and doing a thorough job isn't exactly the priority of a child.
I feel so much sympathy for people who still have to basically work in a germ factory. The community spread has started and panic will set in. Won't help having "proactive" parents stepping in.
Potential Assholes
Judging you right now