I read on Scott Leslie’s EdTechPost about the strangely-named “stu.dicio.us“. In principle it’s a neat idea - a very simple, Javascript/Ajax on-line note-taking system which automatically shares and searches everyone’s notes.
I found the implementation a bit uncomfortable, though. It seems welded to a rather simplistic idea of study - physical attendance to regularly-scheduled classes taught by a “professor” at a “school”. To sign up you need to enter an email address and time zone (both very reasonable), but also need to specify a single “school”. I fell at this hurdle, as I would like to add notes from courses at both Suffolk College and The Open University. To continue, I decided that I’d test the system using the OU courses I have just signed up for, which will start in two months and I’m already gathering research materials.
Then another stumbling block. Before you can even begin to take notes you need to create a “class” record to attach the notes to. This is not in itself a big problem (although it does limit the ability to re-use notes with more than one course), but the implementation refused to let me proceed without specifying a “professor”, choosing one or more days of the week, and selecting a time. Open University courses are generally self-paced (thus it makes little sense to specify days or times), and supported by student collaboration and a pool of tutors (so it makes little sense to specify a professor) Even if it made sense to enter the name of my allocated tutor, I don’t know who it will be yet.
The day and time section was particularly weak. It seemed to assume that every course takes place at the same time each day of the week, which has not been true at any place I have studied. Taking lessons for a particular course, module or unit at (for example) 10am Monday, then 11am and 3pm Tuesday is not at all unusual.
Eventually, I managed to specify spurious values for these fields and could proceed to the note-taking section. Once I got there it was actually quite usable. This is obviously the concept which drove the application as a whole. At the moment it’s a fairly simple text-only outlining system, with pretty good keyboard-integration for moving about and adding basic emphasis. I can see obvious future opportunities to add sketch graphics, upload resources, automatic (wiki-style?) linking between notes or searches, and drag/drop of external links.
Essentially this is cool little note-taking application which is let down by a needlessly restrictive process before you can use it. My suggestions for improvement are:
- Run with the whole “tag” thing. Hard associations are just so inflexible.
- Lose the “school” setting from the “new user” form, to allow students to study different courses at different schools.
- Turn all those compulsory course fields into tags which may be applied to anything (a user, a course, a note, a to-do,…)
- Allow users to create arbitrary groups of tags (perhaps with “wizards” with some initial suggestions for common concepts) and provide both single tags and tag goups in a single drop-down when entering/editing a note, to-do etc.
- Turn the concept of “course” into just a group of tags.
- Allow multiple day/time pairs to be associated with a course.
- Allow association of start and end dates with courses
- Keep track of “created” as well as “edited” dates on notes, and (optionally?) show them on generated output
Oh, and why is it “stu.dicio.us” instead of the much more reasonable “stu.dio.us” ?
freedbacking stu.dicio.us What is Freedbacking?
Posted by Frank as Other News, Resources at 11:01 AM CEST
No Comments »