Wolverine, Sport -- Team (Season)
• Beth Amelkovich, Gymnastics/At-Large -- First (1999), Third (1997)
• John Anderson, Football -- Second (1976, 1977)
• Jason Avant, Football -- Second (2005)
• Dick Balzhiser, Football -- First (1952), Hall of Fame (2002)
• Norm Betts, Football -- First (1981), Second (1980)
• Mark Bodnar, Basketball -- Third (1981)
• Marty Bodnar, Basketball -- First (1981), Third (1980), Fifth (1978)
• Kyle Bohm, Baseball -- Second (2005)
• Jan Boyd, Softball -- Second (1983)
• Joanna Bullard, Track/At-Large -- Third (1983)
• Matt Butler, Baseball -- Third (2005)
• Casey Close, Baseball -- First (1986), Third (1985)
• Traci Conrad, Softball -- First (1998), Second (1999)
• Diane Dietz, Basketball -- First (1981, 1982), Second (1980), Hall of Fame (2009)
• Dan Disher, Baseball -- Honorable Mention (1986)
• Tom Dixon, Football -- Second (1983)
• Bruce Elliott, Football -- First (1971)
• Katie Erdman, Track & Field/Cross Country -- First (2007), Second (2006)
• Adam Finley, Football -- Second (2004)
• Dave Fisher, Football -- First (1966)
• Kelly Forbis, Softball -- First (1993)
• George Foussianes, Baseball -- Third (1980)
• Dave Gallagher, Football -- Second (1973)
• Lindsey Gallo#, Track & Field/Cross Country -- First (2004, 2005)
• Neil Gardner, Track/At-Large -- Second (1997)
• Alessandra Giampaolo, Softball -- Third (2008)
• Janessa Grieco, Gymnastics/At-Large -- Third (2003)
• Steve Grote, Basketball -- First (1976), Second (1977)
• Brian Gunn, Swimming/At-Large -- First (1993)
• Bill Hart, Football -- First (1972)
• Paul Heuerman, Basketball -- Second (1981)
• Ken Higgins, Football -- First (1986)
• Kelly Holmes, Softball -- First (1997), Second (1996)
• Stefan Humphries, Football -- First (1982, 1983)
• Alecia Humphrey, Swimming/At-Large -- Second (1995)
• Chris Hutchinson, Football -- Second (1992)
• Jon Jansen, Football -- Second (1998)
• Dan Jilek, Football -- First (1975)
• Jeff Jillson, Ice Hockey -- Second (2001)
• Alyson Kohlmeier, Track & Field/Cross Country -- Third (2006)
• Pam Kosanke, Softball -- First (2000)
• Kelly Kovach, Softball -- First (1994, 1995)
• Greg Lane, Baseball -- First (1977)
• Brent Lang, Swimming/At-Large -- First (1989)
• Kirk Lewis, Football -- First (1974)
• Jim Mandich, Football -- First (1969)
• Molly McClimon, Cross Country-Track/At-Large -- Third (1994)
• Zoltan Mesko, Football -- First (2009)
• Tammy Mika, Softball -- Third (1998)
• Marc Milia, Football -- Second (1993)
• Clay Miller, Football -- First (1985), Second (1984)
• Ed Muransky, Football -- First (1981)
• Matt Niemeyer, Soccer -- First (2004)
• Jim Orwig, Football -- First (1955, 1957)
• William "Bubba" Paris, Football -- Second (1980)
• Kaitlyn Peale, Women's Cross Country/Track & Field -- Third (2010)
• Dan Pelekoudas, Basketball -- Fourth (1980)
• Rob Renes, Football -- First (1999), Second (1998)
• Mena Reyman, Softball -- Second (1983), Honorable Mention (1985)
• Dan Sanborn, Baseball -- Second (1997)
• Sue Schroeder, Cross Country-Track/At-Large -- Second (1984, 1985, 1986)
• Phil Seymour, Football -- First (1970)
• Valeria Silva, Swimming/At-Large -- Second (2008)
• Brian Simmons, Baseball Second (1995)
• Kevin Sullivan, Cross Country/At-Large -- First (1998), Second (1996)
• Kevin Sullivan*, Track/At-Large -- First (1998), Third (1997)
• Eric Tannenbaum, Wrestling/At-Large -- First (2007, 2008), Second (2006)
• Robert Thompson, Football -- First (1982)
• Bob Timberlake, Football -- First (1964)
• Justin Toman, Gymnastics -- First (2002)
• Dick Vidmer, Football -- First (1966)
• John Wangler, Football -- Second (1980)
• Scott Weaver, Baseball -- First (1995)
• Beth Wymer, Gymnastics/At-Large -- Third (1995)
 
# 2004 and 2005 Women's Track & Field/Cross Country Academic All-American of the Year
*1998 Spring At-Large Academic All-American of the Year