CONNECT    

The Smurfs Are Racist, Anti-Semites, Antoine Buéno Suggests In 'Le Petit Livre Bleu'


First Posted: 06/ 3/11 07:21 AM ET Updated: 06/ 3/11 08:26 AM ET

Smurf Village or Hitler's Berlin? Same thing, posits one new book.

French sociologist and author Antoine Buéno asserts in "Le Petit Livre Bleu," or, "The Little Blue Book," that the seemingly friendly little blue creatures living a mostly idyllic existence are actually packed with racial propaganda and are, "the embodiment of a totalitarian utopia, steeped in Stalinism and Nazism".

The comics, created by Belgian artist Peyo, were first introduced in a Belgian newspaper in 1958; by 1960, they had their own comic strip, and it was off to the races. The animated series, produced by Hanna Barbera, was launched in 1981.

As relayed by Todayxsm.com, Buéno says that Papa Smurf, the leader of the village, is an authoritarian figure, and that their lack of private property and collective-style economy is a clear nod to socialism. Meanwhile, their enemy seems Jewish: Gargamel, the monster that haunts the village, matches negative Jewish caricatures and his cat's name is Azrael, the French author writes, while Smurfette, for a long time the only female in the village, is a vision of aryan perfection.

Buéno, in an interview with The Wall Street Journal, touched on what he perceives as their blue racism.

"The first comic strip, 'The Black Smurfs,' was intimately concerned with what you might classify as a racial threat," he said. "Because in that album, the smurfs are sick. And when they're sick, they don't turn purple or red or anything like that, they become black. And when they become black, they lose all trace of intelligence. THey become completely moronic. And further more, they can no longer speak, they just go 'nyap nyap nyap.'"

The black part is indeed true; US publishers refused to publish the first Smurfs book for that reason, and years later, the sick Smurfs were recolored to purple.

Story continues below

Responding to Flemish paper Der Morgen, Thierry Culliford, son of Peyo and current head of Studio Peyo, said (via Forbidden Planet) the accusations were, "between the grotesque and the not serious."

WATCH:

FOLLOW HUFFPOST ENTERTAINMENT

Smurf Village or Hitler's Berlin? Same thing, posits one new book. French sociologist and author Antoine Buéno asserts in "Le Petit Livre Bleu," or, "The Little Blue Book," that the seemingly frie...
Smurf Village or Hitler's Berlin? Same thing, posits one new book. French sociologist and author Antoine Buéno asserts in "Le Petit Livre Bleu," or, "The Little Blue Book," that the seemingly frie...
Filed by Jordan Zakarin  |  Report Corrections
 
  • Comments
  • 491
  • Pending Comments
  • 8
  • View FAQ
Login or connect with: 
More Login Options
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Bloggers
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2 3 4 5  Next ›  Last »   (18 total)
photo
SaulBloodworth
Author of The Cabal
14 minutes ago (4:54 PM)
That should be fun...

http://www­.telegraph­.co.uk/new­s/worldnew­s/europe/f­rance/8554­973/The-Sm­urfs-are-a­nti-Semiti­c-and-raci­st.html

The row comes at an unfortunat­e time for Hollywood producers, as the big budget film Smurfs is due for release in the US in August.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
rtgmath
http://thetangentline.blogspot.com/
19 minutes ago (4:49 PM)
The argument is complete idiocy. The critic obviously think that everyone should be promoting a capitalist economy. Yet small villages throughout history have adopted ways of sharing and helping that promoted survival by cooperatio­n. Small villages have usually acted similar to extended families, looking to an elder as the one to provide leadership and authority.

Perhaps the critic should study some sociology?

And perhaps the critic should remember this is a cartoon?

And perhaps the critic should find something worthwhile to do!

Perhaps the creator of the smurfs was a bit insensitiv­e when describing sick smurfs. But it was not a racial commentary­. And I suggest that Antoine Bueno himself might be more anti-Semit­ic than he realizes, if he saw in Gargamel's behavior Jewish behavior or stereotype­s. When my kids watched it, I certainly never thought of socialism or antiSemiti­sm. Neither did they.

Grief! This is akin to claiming that character is some-odd children's program (triangles and purses or something like that) was promoting homosexual­ity. Much ado about Nothing.
19 minutes ago (4:49 PM)
Nazi architect Albert Speer's visionary plans for a bigger than life sized replica of Smurf Village in the center of Berlin were ended after Hitler and Friedrich Paulus lost the Battle of Stalingrad­. An attempt after the war by escaped Nazi's to build a smaller Smurf Village in Paraguay eventually fell apart despite President Stroessner­'s support.
GohBokhor
www.ifamericansknew.org
20 minutes ago (4:49 PM)
HAHAHA Anti-Semit­e is a meaningles­s word.
23 minutes ago (4:46 PM)
As General Secretary of the Mouse Liberation Front ( also affiliated with Rights For Rats) I would like to point out that this is no surprise to us in the rodent community. For decades we have struggled against the racial stereotype know as 'Mickey' , a clearly derogatory caricature of a black mouse. The rights and culture of true mice have been trodden underfoot and derided. The cultural and ethnic diversity of the mouse population has been systematic­ally written out of history by the two legged 'Big People'. Even today respectabl­e Harvest Mice, Doormice and Bushy Tailed Doormice struggle to find out about their culture and heritage.

No longer will we put up with this treatment. We will expose these shenanigan­s wherever they are and however inconseque­ntial the particular instance appears to be. No longer will the big people be able to hide behind 'humour' as a defence.

The Day of the Little People is at hand!
31 minutes ago (4:37 PM)
"Smurfette­, for a long time the only female in the village, is a vision of aryan perfection­."

I guess that depends on your definition of Aryan perfection­, something that usually does not include being blue.
31 minutes ago (4:37 PM)
these theories are so old. people have been saying this for at least 15 or more years. this guys needs to catch on things
34 minutes ago (4:34 PM)
Dang all that smurf propaganda just didn't take on me at all.
36 minutes ago (4:32 PM)
obviously somebody needs to get a life....Sm­urfs? seriously?
44 minutes ago (4:24 PM)
Wait, they turn black when sick? I wonder what color they turn if you choke one?
48 minutes ago (4:20 PM)
...yeah and Bert and Ernie are gay...WTF!­...enough of this anti-semit­e crap!
48 minutes ago (4:20 PM)
If this drivel is all they can find to post I guess the world is doing ok
50 minutes ago (4:18 PM)
(crying...­) LEAVE BRITNEY I MEAN THE SMURFS ALONE!
photo
ProudToBeVeryLiberal
Ellie from Seattle
51 minutes ago (4:17 PM)
Mr. Buéno,

I have a suggestion for you:

GET A LIFE.
14 minutes ago (4:54 PM)
Buéno has to pay the bills somehow.
53 minutes ago (4:16 PM)
Smurf all you smurfing smurf heads right up your smurfing smurfs. Mother smurfers.