I don't follow Oscars. The only Leo "fiasco" I remember is losing to Matthew Mcconaughey since everyone thought he'd win it for Wolf of Wall Street. I haven't seen WOWS, but Dallas Buyers Club was good (Jared Leto was my favorite in the movie, though). So idk if the comparison is that From, while excellent, keeps losing out to other worthy opponents. Or From is better and is losing to worse. Because I know people expected Leo to win one a long time ago.
Dark Souls 1 is the only game in that list that would win GOTY for me. And Sekiro wouldn't win it for me this year. Also GAF/Era didn't even vote DaS2 OR 3 as GOTY so...I'm left kind of confused by this whole premise lol.